Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Counter-revolutionaries overturn capitalism

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 14, November 1986 · pp 21-22 · 571 words

Stalinism Trotsky

Counter-revolutionaries

overturn capitalism

The Hungarian events fitted the general pattern of Trotsky's analysis of Stalinism. But in two important respects Trotsky's pre-war analysis differed from the reality after the war.

*The first difference was that Trotsky had expected the Soviet bureaucracy to be overthrown during the war either by political revolution within the USSR or by a concerted imperialist drive to restore capitalism. In practice, the working class lacked the necessary organisation and leadership, while the imperialists came out of the war divided, weakened and incapable of challenging the Red Army in Europe, let alone the Soviet Union.

*In In Defence of Marxism, Trotsky had pointed to the means which he expected Stalin would be obliged to use in expropriating capitalism in Poland. He anticipated that use would be made of a controlled mobilisation of the working class.

"The appeal to independent activity on the part of the masses in the new territories -and without such an appeal, even if worded with extreme caution, it is impossible to constitute a new regime - will on the morrow undoubtedly be suppressed by ruthless police measures in order to ensure the preponderance of the bureaucracy over the awakened revolutionary masses."

(Ibid pp18-19, emphasis added)

This theme was reinforced in pre-war debates in the Fourth International movement, and further information from Finland and Poland was used to back it up. Unfortunately this aspect of Trotsky's analysis was one-sidedly taken up by some Trotskyists in the post-war period, and considerable effort was expended in

+1li18.

The

seeking evidence of the Stalinists utilising

mass mobilisations to overturn capitalist

rule.

While Czechoslovakian events were

almost in line with the predictions made by

Trotsky, few other situations fitted the

theoretical mould. Far from resting in any

way on mass mobilisations, the role of

Stalinism in post-war eastern Europe was

consistently to oppose and crush the mass

mobilisations that did occur. It was only

after the post-war revolutionary upsurge was long finished that the main

nationalisations and expulsions if capitalist ministers from the coalitions took place.

The dogmatic search for mass mobilisations within the East European countries left the Trotskyist movement open to serious confusion. The more "radical' face projected by the Tito leadership in Yugoslavia was superficially interpreted as a result of "mass pressure" shifting the bureuacracy in revolutionary direction, while Tito's rift with Stalin was seen in this light as an ideological break with Stalinist politics rather than a clash of material interests beween two rival bureaucracies.

In part this was due to a definition, of Stalinism as

"The subordination of the interests of the workers in every country of the world to those of the Soviet bureaucracy." (Resolution of Yugoslavia, World Congress 1951).

It is questionable whether this definition of Stalinism was adequate even in the monolithic Cominter before the war; but it certainly has been shown to be completely insufficient to deal with the much more complex politics of the Stalinist movement since 1945.

While they were still able to spot the "rightward" face of Stalinist reaction, many Trotskyists fell prey to the illusion that mass movements could push "radical", , left-talking sections of the Stalinist bureaucracy itself to led movements for political revolution.

Once again these illusions ran up against the harsh facts of working class struggle, firstly in East Germany in 1953 and most graphically in Hungary 1956.

← How Trotskyists got it wrong on Stalinism · The politics of Post War Stalinism →

Something wrong on this page?