Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

How Trotskyists got it wrong on Stalinism

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 14, November 1986 · pp 20-21 · 293 words

Trotsky Stalinism

Trotskyists got

it wrong o

Stalinism

In the eyes of many CP members and sympathisers, the accomplished fact of the overturn of capitalism in Eastern Europe - irrespective of the manner in which it was achieved or the imperfect end result - was the decisive question.

Trotsky's approach to a similar problem - the Soviet invasion of Finland and Eastern Poland just prior to the War - had been very different. Coldly assessing the prospect that Stalin - for all his counter- revolutionary politics - would be forced to overturn capitalist property relations if the Red Army were to stay any length of time. Trotsky insisted that:

'The primary political criterion for us is not the transformation of property relations in this or anther area, however important these may be in themselves, but rather the change in the consciousness and organisation of the world proleteriat, the raising of their capacity for defending former conquests and accomplishing new ones. From this one, and the only decisive standpoint, the politics of Moscow, taken as a whole, completely retains its reactionary character and

remains to world

"The statification of the means of production is (...) a progressive measure. But its progressiveness is relative; its specific weight depends on the sum-total of all the other factors. Thus we must first and foremost establish that the extension of the territory dominated by bureaucratic autocracy and parasitism, cloaked by

the chief obstacle on the road revolution.

'socialist measures, can augment the prestige of the Kremlin, engender illusions concerning the possibility of replacing the proletarian revolution with bureaucratic manoeuvres. and so on. This evil by far outweighs the progressive contect of Stalinist reforms in Poland."

(In Defence

Marxism, emphasis

19. added)

narIOW

← Hungary: the road to 1956 · Counter-revolutionaries overturn capitalism →

Something wrong on this page?