Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Bookends

· Socialist Outlook no. 9, October 1988 · pp 32-33 · 1,216 words

Russia and the USSR Lesbian and gay

rd tc

New publications reviewed

The bombings continue in the Pacific: Kwajelein, another is- land, is the US base where star wars" was dreamed up, and is host now to the major testing of SDI initiatives...

It should. therefore, get a mention in Reshaping the US Left. edited by Mike Davis and Michael Sprinkler (Verso, £9.95) but it doesn't

This points to a weakness in this otherwise praiseworthy volume of essays from the US far left - the insularity of its con cerns (the oponing essay on building solidarity with the Centril American revolution being the exception).

Reshaping the US Leftis the thind annual collection of a very useful series called The Year Left', and takes as its subjoct what the American left like to call "movement building'.

The book is eclectic, offering 12 participant-observer perspec tives on key struggles and developments of the revitalised US left, but none the worse for that. If at time the essays seem a little local in their purview, this at allows us to see the detail of some or the many real struggles which are the well-kept secret of the Reagan.

Besides, many are stimulat- ing accounts, full of thought-

provoking and often novel Ideas Forganising which could be ex perimented with here. Perhaps next year's volume will bend the stick the other way and in- clude ideas of an overall socialist perspective for the Dukakis years.

Another book which goes close-up on building coalitions is Radical Records: thirzy vears of lesbian and gay history. edited by Bob Cant and Susan Hemmings (Routledge, 17 asi This claims to be the first his- tory book by lesbians and gay men. and takes a distinctly left- ist editorial line.

Contributions are varied, hut all concerned in one way or another with the political move- ment of lesbians and gay men. and the ways in which the dialectic of self-organisation and mass struggle has worked in practice.

Without exception the start- ing point for these essays is the lived experience of the writers: this confers personality on the writing which makes it both im mediate and (usually) easy to read.

Coming out during the gay community's health crisis and the Clause 2% backlash, it is a timely book

Reviewed by NICK

ROBIN

In 1982, the US warned the Micronesian people of the Marshall Islands not to eat food from the northern part of their atoll. It was not a timely warning.

It had been 28 years since the USA uninvited - had ex- ploded a homb 1300 times more i powerful than those thiev id dropped on Hiroshima or Nagasaki on Bikini, also in Micronesia.

In that time, as Jane Dibblin recounts in Day of Two Suns (Virago, E6.95). the Micronesian people had realised themselves that things weren't quite right as they began dying of unknown cancerous discases and giving birth to terribly mutated babies.

Dibblin's book - much of it in the words of the islanders themseives - explores the social and political realities of the US's nuclear testing in the Pacific in an account both analytical and humanistic. High- ly recommended.

lectuals, their function in the party, and their class position. This discussion is more con fused. If this review concentrates critically on this question, it should not be read as a swooping

condemnation of the hook as a

whole: which gives many in

sights on the process of change in

the Soviet Union today, but as

whole: which gives many in

sights on the process of change in

.. todas

nue example of the problems

faced by writers (and others) in the Soviet Union, so long denied

matérial and the right to open dis- cussion to enable them to form a complete understanding of their

nem le

pen a if the..

history.

Thrughout the nineteenth and

into the twentieth century the Russian intelligentsia played a

central role in the struggle for

In a1

hourgeois democratic treedoms.

but only a small minority joined the Bolshevik party. Others aligned themselves to the Men-

sheviks, the Social Revolutionaries or the Kadets. The division of the intelligentsia betwoon contending classes, was

mielligent • classes. W

adhered to the Bolsheviks, many

joined the Whites: the majority tried to find some third way, That

sharpened during the Civil War, when: Part of the intelligentsia

rsmus3in rik.. me

E AEM BUIL

is a path that steered between

bourgeois reaction and

proletarián dictatorship. Kagar-

litsky argues that the suppres

sinn of bourgeois-democratic

fredoms" dealt a heavy blow to

the intellectuals who had placed

their hopes in a free Russia. The

dissolution of the Constituent As-

lions that the lell-wing

semhly, the terror and the intro- duction of censorship were ic- insclligentsin could not excuse

under any conditions."

the author accepts that the objec-

live conditions of isolation. cconomic collapse, invasion etc. meant that censorship and attacks

Although

On CIC

on democratic rights were probab- ly invitable, in order to save the revolution, he emphasises that it was tragedy for the intellectuals. and one which the Bolsheviks

that 11 "lectus... ucvik

failed to understand. Indeed the

implication is that it was this

shue sn Solshc -IK:

the question of democracy, alheit

a result of impossible circumstan- ces, that led inexorably to in-

creased burcaucracy and to the

Page 30

IST OL:LOUK nO

rise or Stalin. The problem that this raises, to which Kagarlitsky returs to throughout the book, is the mole and function of intellec- tuals, their relationship to the workmg class to the party, and especially their class position. He arguex that contrary to Stalin's detinition of the intelligentsia as a stratum" rather than a class which is therefore unable to play an inde- pendent mie in social life. the

like any familiar on the European

The hospitality and acceptance shown lo Molly hy Else's lamily. when Molly is at last introduced

not by her mother - to the reality of township life, is a memorable example. As the oid blind grandfather at the end of the table

recognition and greeting, the

is passed Molly's hand to feel in

humanity of Afncan culture as opposed to the alienation of apart heid is, literally, palpable: here Menges achievement is to allow the black actors to make the scene, in what must have heen an unusually creative interplay he- twcen writer, director and cast.

If yuu lake the personal theme

the experience of a

"many-millioned intelligentsia" in the Soviet Union today has be-

stratum, canahle not oniv of for-

achieving them. Further he main- tains that while in the nineteenth und early this century the intel- ligentsia, both East and West 'was bourgeois (or petty-bourgoois) in

present circumstances (though for

come an independent social mulating its aims but often of brings

of the story daughter whose dominant but dis-

lant parent dedicates their life to the revolution but not to you

present circumstances (though for ditterent reasons; the intel-

Tigentsia both East and West have been "proletarianised". The Sovict intelligentsia. feeling that they belong to the oppressed and ex- ploited masses. "inercasingly claim the right to speak in their name. He thus adopts a position

heing the central subject, rather than its South African sctting, then this film most invites com- parison with Zina, Ken McMullen's powerful study of Trotsky's daughter and her relationship with her father. While A

← Kagarlitsky, intellectuals and Glasnost · A World Apart →

Something wrong on this page?