Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

A World Apart

· Socialist Outlook no. 9, October 1988 · pp 33-34 · 930 words

World Apart cannot compete with the visionary scope of Zina (which nonetheless Nopped at the box office) it shares with that film the ability to pose some questions that make revolutionaries fcci uncomfort- able, while avoiding the vices of lecturing on the one hand and libcralism on the other.

7ina never cmorged from the tragedy of her childhood and her search for her father's love: she committed suicide as fascism look hold in Nazi Germany.

whereby the intelligentsia are both an independent stratum and "being

Subversive stuff

stands for the mass struggle that

film. This is part of the film's suc-

tumed into simple proletarians"

The confusion stems partly, I feel.

A World Apart Irom his desire for the intel- ligentsia to play a leading role in Director Chris Menges

Screenplay by Shawn despite the role played by a few. very courgeous individuals in the Slovo

the changes. But this desire.

past, gocs against the history of ihe intelligentsia. East and West. Marxists have traditionally argued they are an intermodiate petty- bourgeois layer and can therefore align themselves with either the working class or the hourgeoisic) and insist upon the leading mole of the working class. Indeed Kagar-

of the Federation of Socialist

Reviewed by ERICA FLEGG

The linal Trame of A W

Apart freezes a township youth hurling a stone at the South African police, in response to a tear-gas at- tack on the funeral of a black militant killed in detention.

litsky himself, as the Co-ordinator

Clubs: gives an example of the divided nature of the intelligentsia when he points to intellectuals leading right wing clubs with anti- democratic and anti-semitic polilies - Pamyar and Rodina (Memory and Homeland) - as well as left wing clubs.

The relation of the intel- ligentsia to the working class is not just am abstract question. Kagarlitsky in one or two pas- sages accepts the centrality of the working masses in radical change: however, his position as an intel- lectual leads him to ignore the fact

The image is a potent one. and has already been silk-screened

onte T-shirts. As the titles come

West End cinema expressed its revulsion at the information that Ruth First (Molly's mother,

onte T-shirts. As the titles come up, the fashionable audience of a

Diana, in the film) had been as-

sassinated in 19%2, then they

burst into applause.

In these jaded times, such

spontaneous expression of feel

ing is not easily achieved, and is

that while both intellectuals and the working class can gain from glasnost, the negative effects of perestroika - an attempt to resolve the crisis of bureaucratic planning

ut the expense of the workers and not the privileged bureaucracy and their hangers-on - will be primarily feit by the working

a tribute to the film's success in touching an audience's emotional

as well as political sensibilitics.

as well as political sensibilitics.

The film doesn'1 go into the politics of the struggle or the role

played by the African National

Congress or the Communist

Party, to which Molly's (Shawn

Siovo's) parents belonged.

primarily feit by the working class. To ignore thar difference is

to fall into the trap of the

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 9 October 1988

to tal bureaucracy - himal

David, on the vainst the Goliath

of the South African statc - is the dynamic backdrop of the

cess as a statement against apart

individuals involved in it, black

received to much critical acclaim as a joint dehut by Chris Menges (cincmatographer on The Mission

Shawn Slovo (who wrote the autohiographical screcnplay).

The actors portraying the central two characters, 13-year old

Rivonia arrests Molly and her mother Diana

Jodhi May convinces without

A World Apart has been

and The Killing Fields) and Shawn Slovo (who wrote the

CHIE CUIC 23 luscd daugh commited but emotionally

reserved mother. Barbara Her- they brings an impressive force

to her role - although to my mind the character of First remains one- dimensional.

Molly is also shown unsuccess: fully trying to claim the place she wanted in her mother's fife: with what consequences for her own development we are not told. since the film covers only the story of 1963, the year of the

In an interview, Slovo said that writing the screenplay was like a fon of therapy: her strength in the telling of her story is to do it with frankness naked of any sell-indulgence.

Going for a wide appcal seems to have been a conscious option

on Slovo's part - she said that was why she had called her mother "Dians" So it is much to

her credit (and that of Menges' direction) that the film moves its audience wilhout any of the

devices of a Hollywood epic or

Taking the cue, the South African authorities banned it after its first public screening: subver-

sive stuff. They may have killed

tear-jerkcr.

Ruth First, but they remain in they unleashed.

- have kılled

Ruth First, but they remain in awe of her and the struggle she espoused. Slovo's film now emer- ges as onc of the hydri heads

A singular triumph of the film. however is its African cast. The

two leads are outstanding, but all

the black actors - mostly Zimbab-

weans without any previous

screen experience - bring tremen

dous energy. commitment and

human warmht to the story

The scene where Elsic (the maid, played by Linda Mvusi. who 'parents" Molly) is brought the news of her brother's fate in detention (Alhée Lesotho) is a wrenching depiction of grief un-

The scene where Elsic (the

Page 31

REVIE W

Reflections on the British

← Bookends · Tom Nairn on the monarchy →

Something wrong on this page?