Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Letters

Socialist Outlook no. 6, April–March 1988 · p 8 · 564 words

Letters

Stalinism

letters from Phil Hearse and from Stevi Jackson and Julian Wilson (Socialist Outlook 4) misunderstand the article I wrote in Socialist Outlook 3 with Judith Paton.

Neither letter understands what we meant by empowerment. It is not a legalistic' concept, and it is not restricted to the way abused children are treated after the abuse has been discovered. Nor is it something that belongs in the realm of socialist 'utopia'. It is an idea which is applicable immediately but which has far-reaching implications for the whole organisation of society.

The immediate demands we outlined in our article lead to a thoroughgoing re-appraisal of the way the care system, the medical establishment and the police and courts are organised and the way they perceive children.

The principle we wish to establish is that children should, wherever possible, be in control of their lives.

It is true that some children

The totalitarian methods, often mixed with xenophobia, characteristic of the left face of stalinism do just as much, if not more, damage to the socialist cause and to the development of genuine class consciousness amongst workers as direct deals with imperialism.

In any case both the 'right'

will not have the knowledge or experience to make complicated and difficult decisions. However, it is obviously impossible to choose an age at which we deem children capable of deciding. Hence the only practical way of determining when adults should intervene is to allow intervention only when a child says she or he doesn't know or doesn't understand.

It is their very powerlessness within the family and in society which makes children vulnerable to abuse and which isolates them from possible sources of support and solidarity.

Both letters claim that we said sexual abuse is 'not about sexual desire'. This is not true. A consideration of the way sex and power are intertwined in capitalist society is vital in this discussion.

To appeal to agencies of the capitalist state to protect children, as Phil Hearse does, implies putting the blame onto 'abnormal' parts of society: the dysfunctional family rears its ugly head again.

One does not have to argue for the abolition of the welfare

and 'left' sides of stalinism operate together at all times in the permanent counter- revolution in defence of the interests of the bureaucratic caste. A central part of our opposition to stalinism is the defence of human rights whether collective or individual o Colin Meade

state as a consequence of recognising that the whole framework in which social workers, paediatricians and other professionals operate is geared to the needs of society as it exists now. This framework works against the interests of children.

My final criticism of both letters is that they approach the subject in a very polemical style, and, in the case of Phil's letter, with seemingly very little background knowledge of the research and discussion which has already taken place. It is an essential part of what we are trying to say that the sexual abuse of children is a widespread phenomenon, which will probably affect everybody, directly or indirectly, in the course of their lives. As such, the discussion is not an abstract or theoretical one

I hope that this necessary debate will continue in a spirit of sensitivity, of comradely discussion and of joint exploration of important and difficult ideas • Dani Ahrens

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 6 March/April 1988

← Black sections' testing times · NHS: stepping up the fight →

Something wrong on this page?