NHS:
EVEN IN THE unlikely event of an unex- pectedly generous settlement for nurses in this year's April pay review, it would produce only a temporary slackening of the fight, since government policies are already set to sharpen the NHS crisis.
1987 saw the NHS close at least 3,500 beds, and cut many basic services, as it grappled with a shortfall of over £230m.
Yet government spending figures for 1988-89 mean a further shortfall of al- most £400m. These cuts come on top of a cumulative shortfall (estimated by an all-party commons select committee) of £1.8 billion since 1980.
Despite the unprecedented focus on NHS spending in advance of Nigel Lawson's 15 March budget, the Tories are
quite adamant that they intend to hand
out huge tax-breaks to the rich, and
make no extra cash available for health
services. The new financial year will
therefore launch a new round of cuts
- meaning more problems for
nurses and the other sections of health-
workers who have already begun to fight
back.
Thatcher's threatened 'review' of the
NHS, which is almost certain to involve
imposition of new, means-tested charges
for treatment, is due to be unveiled by
late summer — just as the 1988-89 cuts
begin.
Add to this the strong likelihood that
this year's NHS pay round will anger almost every section of healthworkers;
Defence of the National Health Service is the driving force that has animated protest strikes by tens of thousands of health workers and brought a wave of support from other trade unionists.
This is a tremendous strength. It means that only a substantial reverse in government policy — a decision to provide major new cash resources for the NHS — can defuse an escalating struggle which has vast popular support. HARRY SLOAN reports.
this year's NHS pay round will anger and add the extra inflammatory factor of a battle over London weighting pay- ments (the government has offered a miserly £51 per year increase on the £950 London weighting, against an all- union demand for an extra £1000), and we have every reason to expect NHS struggles to continue and escalate.
Naive outsiders might expect that the opportunity to lead a united trade union membership in a hugely popular crusade against a vicious government would ex- cite and delight trade union and Labour leaders. No such reaction can be seen from the same timid, spineless TUC and Parliamentary Labour Party team that
IS TAKING YAN INDUSTRIAL ACTIOI TODAY, IN DEFENCE
OF THE N.H.S. Julio Etchart/Reflex
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK
irses from Homerton hospitai, London, estion is how we move from the presen create conditions for a general strike
has brought an unbroken series of re- treats, betrayals and sell-outs since Thatcher took office.
The enthusiastic mass upsurge of rank and file nurses, which led to the success of the 3 February day of action may have inspired most activists; but it was re- garded as an embarrassment by Neil Kinnock. It also appears to have frightened the life out of a NUPE leader-
i strike 3 February: the stage of struggle to
ship besotted with Tom Sawyer's defeat- ist 'new realism', and a TUC leadership politically dominated by the hard right.
Apart from the Scottish TUC day of action on 24 February, NUPE leaders have (with some honourable exceptions) for the most part been working to pre- vent or restrict further strikes, and have actively attempted to sabotage the call by COHSE for a day of action on 14 7
March — the eve of the budget.
Instead of following the Scottish example and calling a TUC day of action, or pressing for other unions to back the COHSE call, the NUPE leaders, Norman Willis and the other TUC heavies called in COHSE's Hector McKenzie - and rapped his knuckles for having called on his own members to take action!
COHSE's rather different response to the NHS crisis arises partly from its less rigid bureaucratic control over the rank and file compared to NUPE, and partly from recognising an opportunity to rec- ruit new members, especially dissidents from the no-strike Royal College of Nursing (RCN). It is ironic, after mili- tants have argued for years against the inter-union rivalries in the NHS, that precisely these divisions have opened up the best possibilities for action: if NUPE leaders were in total control, there would be little strike action taking place!
The TUC's one initiative - decided only after an agonising five-hour debate (which began with a call for an indoor meeting) — was to call the 5 March national demonstration in defence of the NHS.
'health unions should boycott all work to implement cuts and
closures'
Clearly the task is to use this mobilisa- tion, and the opportunity to build soli- darity on the 14 March COHSE action, to build for escalating action to defend the NHS.
Simply to state the truism (as some do on the sectarian left) that what is needed to defend the NHS is a general strike to defeat the Tories is to state the problem rather than the solution.
Given Thatcher's intransigence, a general strike is needed to win; and defence of the NHS is one of those issues around which, in the right conditions, a general strike could be achieved. Every previous major struggle by health- workers has seen supporting strike ac- tion by industrial unions, and already we have seen Vauxhall workers, miners, local government and other workers take supporting action.
The question is how we move from the present stage of struggle to create condi- tions for a general strike. This can only develop if we take seriously the organisa- tion and mobilisation of the health unions themselves: we must avoid emp- ty propagandist sloganising, but also oppose the kind of 'grand old Duke of York' official tactics of endless single 'days of action' which led to demoralisa- 8 tion and defeat in the 1982 pay fight.
HEALTH
0.5 SEL
TALINE ARAGE
INDUSTRIAL ACTION TODAY IN PrENCE 0F THe NEHIS,
Serious, sustained action is needed: but to achieve this, healthworkers must be convinced that there is no other way out, and that the short-term inconve- nience it will mean to some NHS patients will be made good by the long-term defence of the NHS. At present, many of the nurses and other staff who have readily responded to one day token strikes remain reluctant to take any more prolonged action (even with emer- gency cover).
Some fear it would hurt patients; others recognise that an escalation to longer strikes would change the cha- racter of the dispute and end the unreal 'honeymoon' period of favourable press coverage: it could also cost them heavily in wages — and few have any savings to fall back on. In addition there is the problem of the active scabbing role of the 250,000 strong RCN whose national leaders generally regard it as their job to attack the health unions rather than the government.
These problems could possibly be overcome by a firm and united official call for action by the health union leaders: but this is not likely in the short run. They could also be overcome by a process of organisation and escalation of the dispute which can create the convic- tion that only sustained strike action can win, and the confidence that the health unions are strong enough to undertake it.
The fact is that the mobilisation of healthworkers so far has to a large extent remained at a rank and file (therefore patchy and spontaneous) level: whole hospitals — and indeed whole unions — have lagged behind, with manual ancill- ary staff in particular less active this time than the nurses.
This is why it is essential that vigorous campaigns in each hospital and action against local level cuts and closures are combined with calls on national leader- ships for more generalised action.
This means: • Health unions in each locality should
be linking up with each other, with trades councils, Labour parties and community organisations, to build cam- paigning health emergency-type organ- isations which set out to expose and combat every cut and closure in local hospital and community health services. • Local forms of industrial action, if necessary short of all-out strikes, should be taken to combat management at* tacks. In Edinburgh a seven week work- to-rule and overtime ban by nurses last autumn won 60 extra posts.
Since much nursing overtime is un- paid, and many nurses work unaccep- tably long hours, overtime bans can also help focus the fight for union organisa- tion and win union members from the RCN. Management can be obliged to hire expensive agency staff to cover wards, often negating the 'savings' from cuts and closures. • Some unions still have formal 'no- cover' policies for unfilled vacancies, which can be enforced to expose man- agement's 'hidden' cuts. Other ways too can be found in each hospital to disrupt the workings of management while pres- erving patient care.
'the TUC should call an all- union day of action in defence
of the NHS'
• In particular health unions should boycott all work to implement cuts and closures — whether this be moving beds or patients, or clerical and other work. This policy can win widespread support from non-health unions. • Where hospitals or facilities are threatened with closure, the tested tactic of occupation (or 'work-in') has proved successful in Oxford and London, and has prolonged the life of other hospitals (sometimes for years). As long as patients stay in the hospital (protected by pickets on the gates), management must ensure it is staffed — and pay those who work there! This form of action has proved ideal for building solidarity and supporting action. • Boycotts on private patients who queue-jump their way into NHS hospitals could also be considered as more man- agers look to step up the role of private blocks as a means of 'income genera- tion' • Publicity is vital for all these activities - and tremendous impact can be achieved through 'opening the books' of local management - revealing the real growth of waiting lists, financial incom- petence, hidden losses on private treat- ment, secret plans for cuts, and horren- dous 'options' being considered. Any-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK nod March/April 1988
thing like this helps stoke up public anger and build local campaigns.
With a firm footing of local mobilisa- tion, demands must be made for action at national level by the TUG - and by the Labour Party, whose scandalous inaction on the NHS helped Thatcher win her third term of office, and which is now missing the chance to build a mass- ive grass-roots campaign reaching the whole working class (and deeper into the middle classes than any of Bryan Gould's loopy share schemes).
The Labour Party nationally should be working flat out on the issue, and urging local parties to build health cam- paigns and to leaflet wards — especially council estates — mobilising local sup- port.
The TUC must be told to call an STUC-style day of action by all unions in defence of the NHS: this would alert the whole movement to the crisis and pro- duce a one day general strike bigger than that over GCHO. We must also demand the Labour Party and TUC call a full- scale demonstration (or simultaneous regional events) in July to mark the fortieth anniversary of the NHS.
Healthworkers in NUPE must fight at branch, division and national level for resolutions demanding solidarity in ac- tion with COHSE; and healthworkers in NALGO, the GMB and TGWU must li- kewise demand that their unions join the mobilisation in defence of the NHS.
We should be calling on health unions to launch a national nurses' work-to-rule and overtime ban, with supporting ac- tion from ancillary staffs: they should also set a deadline for escalating this to strike action (with a call for support from the whole workers' movement) unless the government stumps up the £2.5 billion needed to restore the cuts it has made in the NHS.
A fight developed and escalated along these lines could revive the best tra- ditions of working class solidarity from the miners' strike — on an even wider level. Over 90 per cent of voters (in- cluding over 80 per cent of Tories!) in opinion polls favour spending more tax revenue on the NHS: over 70 per cent support the nurses' strikes; 70 per cent say they would pay extra taxes at once for the NHS. Only the timidity of the union leaders stands in the way of tapping this support.
Combined with the evident rebirth of militancy at rank and file level in many unions, mass trade union action to de-
Labour
Labour
and the
GOVERNMENT COST cutting mea- sures and the financial crisis they have engineered have driven the NHS to breaking point. With official govern- ment inquiries and right wing think tanks jostling for position in the race to produce proposals which 'review' (i.e. fundamentally undermine) future NHS financing, 1988 is a crunch year for the NHS.
The public know there is a severe problem, they know who is ultimately to blame and they want it put right. They
JAN TURNER
ary and other health service workers and extending to a wide range of protest actions staged by all sections of the NHS workforce (even including consultants and some managers) - is feeding the public pressure to defend the NHS. This is Thatcher's greatest weakness and Labour's big chance.
Here, you might think, is Labour's golden opportunity to make its case for an alternative to the economics of Thatcherism. A chance to argue for socialism. Or at the very least to (re)state the principles of the limited commitment to public ownership and provision that the welfare state was built on. But no.
Apparently oblivious to the clear pol- itical need, and tremendous opportun- ity, to establish an alternative political pole around which to build support for Labour from this opposition to Thatcher, off go Labour's leadership trundling into the ground tried, tested and failed by the SDP.
With superbly bad timing, at a National Executive Committee (NEC) meeting held just two days after the successful first wave of NHS strike action on 3 February, Kinnock and Hattersley issued their 'aims and values' statement
*Labour has barely yet managed to dent Thatcher's
lead in the polls'
may not necessarily know how, but in the short term they want more public money put into the NHS. Poll after poll shows continuing public support for de- cent funding for the health service - even if it means forgoing tax cuts or increasing the tax burden on the rich.
Of course the continuing action - including strike action by nurses, ancill- On the picket line at Whittington hospital, London: the mobilisation of health workers has to a large extent remained at rank and file level
SITE
STAND UP
tongton Hospita
FOR
CUT Mang
PATIENT
THATCHER
CARE
NoT
NHS
WHITTINGTON MANY
STRIKE
fend the NHS could provide our best Reflex
chance yet for a combined onslaught that could rock or even unseat the Thatcher government •
FOR ACTION NURSES
MUST
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK nod March/April 1988