Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Unstable yet durable – the paradox of Indian democracy

Socialist Outlook no. 30, February 1991 · pp 33-34 · 1,591 words

Asia Marxism Trotsky

REVIEW

The Painful Tra Bourgeois Den India Achin Vanaik Verso £9.95

isition scracy

Reviewed by Dave

Palmer

Achin Vanaik, the leading Times of India joumnalist, A Marxist and supporter of the Inquilabi Communist San- ghathan (Indian section of the Trotskyist Fourth Internation- al) has produced a major new study of the India's economy and politics.

Vanaik's work brings a theoretical originality and assured grasp to the understanding of the process of combined and uneven development on the sub-con- tinent. This makes it essential reading for all those wishing to grasp the course of events in the most complex society on the planet.

With the weak government of VP Singh recently replaced by even feebler administration, In- dian society and body politic to many observers appears riven by irresolvable tensions. How does a revolutionary build a Marxist framework for comprehending events in the world's largest, and poorest, bourgeois democracy?

Should we think of India as a dependent "third world" country dominated by an imperialist world order which blocks its development? view com- munalism as a clash of backward "pre-modem" identities, to be swept aside by the advance of capitalism social relations? con- ceptualise its rural social relations as largely "feudal"? view India as a "multi-national state" which could easily break up or be fur- ther partitioned? regard its elec- toral politics and parliamentary governance as a shaky facade verging of collapse? consider that the army may take over in a crisis or that a authoritarian Hindu chauvinist regime is a real pos sibility? see the hugely oppressed

se

92==90g

Indian masses ready to rise in revolutionary action if just given the right lead?

To these all questions both, theoretical and immediate (unfor- tunately including the last), can be given a definite no.

Vanaik's analysis sweeps away many common misconcep tions concerning India. It provides the observer of contem- porary India with the theoretical spectacles to make the conjunc- ture of events explicable. His overview is intricate, many layered and highly innovative. This subject matter is complex and multi-faceted, and for most of the Wester left is unfortunately almost totally unfamiliar.

Vanaik argues Indian capitalism is both weak and back- ward yet neither dependent upon, nor (directly) dominated by im- perialism.

He contends that, "There is no major capitalist country in the Third World which has a more powerful state than India's or an indigenous bourgeoisie with more autonomy from foreign capital" Imperialism or foreign capital (a

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30. February 1991

tiny proportion of the economy) have no meaningful

place in the dominant class relations in India. The two dominant classes of the In- dian social forma- tion are the agrarian bour- geoisie developing capitalist farmer class which dominates rural social ... relations

and politics - and the industrial bourgeoisie, predominately con- centrated in state industry and the

long standing private monopolies.

State sector

Indian capitalism - though weak, backward and inefficient has been able to embark upon the path of autarchic and bureaucrati- cally administered development due to the vast potential size of its intemal markets. The huge and predominant state sector (of the top 50 companies only 7 are private), state directed investment

funds and resources have been

used as the main instruments nur- turing industrial and commercial

capital formation and

capital formation and growth. The agricultural bourgeoisie have been the main beneficiaries of the governmental system of agricul- tural subsidies and "floor pric- ing".

This dynamic of development based on the urban and rural elites - the "top 200 million" with the vast urban middle class providing the main market for consumer goods

- however creates barriers to the growth of

Page 31

REVIEW

domestic demand and economic growth. The "alliance" between the rural and industrial bour- geoisies has become in- creasingly unstable as the rural bourgeoisie's in- fluence has grown. With 70% of the population in the countryside, the rich farmer-led peasant voting bloc is continually used to contend with the in- dustrial bourgeoisie in tha "chara nast" af tha

Lastly on "agencies for change" Vanaik pinpoints the primary obstacle to working class self-activity in the extreme fracturing and lack of autonomy of the Indian trade union movement. There are over 38,000 registered unions, and each politi- cal party has a trade union wing, while the state enmeshes the unions within a cor-

resources allocated by

porate structure of in- the Indian state. This was

dustrial relations legis- the main cause of the lation. breakup of the Congress

Advance for the left monolith.

can only arise through

the linkage of

Authoritarian

urban/rural proletariat

Vanaik's main thesis All leaders use communalism - with horrendous results

is that India is in transi- tion from one variant of bourgeois democracy to another - more authoritarian -form. This is ex- pressed in the apparent paradox that Indian politics are charac- terised by unceasing instability within highly durable framework. Yet the fracturing of Congress and its loss of political hegemony means it has also be- come incapable of a forming stable national govemment.

Vanaik argues that Indian's "national" bourgeoisie - its core component being its industrial bourgeoisie - has able to com- plete the tasks of the "bourgeois

revolution" (agrarian reform, na-

independence bourgeois

independence, lishment of

bourgeois democratic regime plus a high de- gree autonomous industrialisa- tion) to a degree unaccounted for in the "standard" interpretation of Trotsky's Permanent Revolution thesis (Mandel, Lowy).

Vanaik's argument that the Trotskyist tradition should review

its current thinking on Permanent

Revolution and the degree to which the tasks of the bourgeois revolution can be completed

clearly has major ramifications for revolutionary strategy in the less developed countries.

The high degree of political

and economic autonomy of the Indian bourgeoisie meant, that un- like China and Vietnam, com- munism and nationalism never fused in India. This has particular- ly ruinous consequences for the strategies of the Indian Com- munist Parties both in relation to

Page 32

the pre-independence Congress tends that "the most powerful national movement and in the candidates for nationhood in India post-colonial Indian state.

have been religious, not linguistic

Externally Vanaik holds that communities." His approach is in the Indian state is becoming an sharp contrast to traditional (and ever more hegemonic power in again "stagist") Marxist notions the South Asian region and will of the advance of capitalism, derive increased global status bourgeois democracy and from this role. It has the world's secularism modeled on the fourth largest army and has raised "European capitalist experience". its military spending by 250% in

Hindu nationalism the last decade. Both India and

In modern India any party can Pakistan are nuclear powers.

only win governmental power

The very factors that make it through appealing to a bloc of possible for the Indian state to class, communal, regional and achieve regional eminence also class identities. Though the "Hin- make it difficult for it to achieve dustan" chauvinists of the BJ.P. real global authority. South Asia mau chift the nolitical enactmm to

has been of little strategic impor- tance to the USA and Westem im- perialism, hence the ability of India to sustain its non-alignment and regional pre-eminence.

"Nation-state"

Vanaik reviews Marxist theories of nationalism and their application in the Indian context. He argues India is not a multi-na- tional state (like the USSR) but a "nation-state" which has largely "solved" the "national question".

He argues no necessary opposi-

tion exists between India's many sub-national regional linguistic

identities and a pan-Indian nation-

al identity. Most of the regional movements for autonomy (primarily language based) have not constituted national move- ments.

The most original and trench- ant section of the book is that on the role of communalism, religion and their relationship to Indian bourgeoisie democracy. He con-

the right, it is a restrained Hindu nationalism which is set to ad- vance. Thus in India, the "spread of Hindu nationalist appeal and adoption of a modulated cultural nationalism by mainstream bour- geois parties are not incompatible with preservation of the broad structures of bourgeois democracy". The Indian state can be characterised as non-com munal rather then secular. There is an urgent need for a new

socialist definition of secularism

and for the left to fight for secularisation of civil society.

around a broad social agenda. Effort must be directed towards forging an alliance be- tween of rural proletariat and poor farmers around such issues as higher wages, lower food prices and socialization of productive inputs and resources.

Finally some minor criticisms of this excellent work. The chap- ter on the Indian economy (unfor- tunately the first) contains many lists of indigestible statistics. Vanaik outlines the ideas of far too many thinkers, often for no apparent purpose, rather than sticking to the main models he

wishes to consider.

Its a pity the cancerous role of caste - uniquely Indian, ancient and all pervasive - highlighted recently by the riots by upper caste students against the Mandal Commission recommendations, is not specifically addressed.

Lastly, he gives little clue as to the existing social and political vehicles for his clearly enumerated set of tasks for revolutionary transformation.

Of course none of the above detracts from Vanaik's study being essential reading. for any

serious student of the politics of South Asian sub-continent.

ACHIN VANIAIK will be touring Britain from the end of March to promote his book. Meetings

n Scotland and London are already planned, and

topefully others will be arranged. If you are in- terested in finding out about, or helping to or-

International Forum on Asia.

Southall or phone Oliver on 081 571 5019

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30. February 1991

← Punjab: State repression versus fundamentalism · Letters →

Something wrong on this page?