Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Punjab: State repression versus fundamentalism

· Socialist Outlook no. 30, February 1991 · p 32 · 432 words

By Oliver New

The Sikh fundamentalists have quite a | Direct rule from Delhi will end only when

narrow base of support in Punjab, but they continue to benefit from a crisis in which state repression and terrorism feed off each other.

In some areas they have set up their own courts and they have attempted to intimidate and murder not only their political opponents, but those of whom they disapprove. Women have been told they must wear traditional dress, traders have been told to stop selling tobacco and alcohol; teachers, journalists and broadcasters have been told to stop using Hindi.

Criminals have been taking advantage of the instability, one estimate is that 90% of so- called terrorist crime is carried out by criminals for gain. There is no dividing line between youth genuinely attracted by the radi- cal appeal of the Khalistani movement and those who use the gun for personal gain.

Furthermore, the prolonged period of crisis in Punjab has led to the growth of close links not merely between the militant fundamen- talists and criminals, but also between both and the police. Some landlords have a strong vested interest in the situation.

The army has been brought in to try to re- store confidence in the ability of the state to keep control, but it has no political legitimacy.

elections are held, and most of India's nation- al parties are reluctant to see an election in which they expect to perform badly. They have eamed themselves nothing but hatred through their policy of naked repression and their failure to search for a solution.

Only the Communists have campaigned sincerely against communalism, many paying the price of assassination. The deadly-dull TV soaps with predictably happy endings for communal harmony are certainly not the stuff to win hearts and minds.

The national parties know it would be hard to pick up a sizeable Hindu vote: it is not there to be won. The 1981 census showed 52% Sikhs in the Punjab to 46% Hindus. Today the figures are estimated to be 68% to 30%. Many Hindus have migrated out of Pun- jab and many more Sikhs and Hindus have moved into the towns for safety, often not registering themselves.

The rise of the Hindu fundamentalism has correspondingly strengthened the hand of the Khalistanis. The successive governments in Delhi are more interested in placating them than developing a democratic anti-com munalist policy. There is therefore a crying need for a grass roots movement of the left to break the circle of state repression and com munalism.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30. February 1991

← Manifestos give way to mass violence · Unstable yet durable – the paradox of Indian democracy →

Something wrong on this page?