Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Letters

Socialist Outlook no. 30, February 1991 · pp 35-36 · 1,030 words

Letters

Trotsky

PR: an act of faith?

Pete Willsman was right in suggesting that Davy Jones' article on PR required a response (Socialist Outlook No. 29). Unfortunately, his was not the one to be expected from readers of a "revolutionary marxist" joumal.

Jones' contention, "that PR would help the mobilisation of a real popular majority to win elections and introduce socialism", may well be an act of faith as Willsman argues, but not in the sense that he meant. For both are argu- ing from within a context of parliamentary reformism - quite legitemately in Willsman's case. However, Jones a supposed Trotskyist, cannot seriously claim such a description at the same time as suggesting a parliamentary road to socialism.

I am not necessarily suggesting that mar- xists should not give critical support to PR - we should give no blank cheques to the in- stitutions of bourgeois democracy. However, the questions to be raised over PR include such problems as whether it would give workers and the oppressed greater control over their lives or whether it would help to break the hold of reformism. One can debate PR in this cort of context without any illusions that a change in the forms of capitalist democracy would allow a socialist transfor- mation of society.

Perhaps one can look to Socialist Outlook's perspective of building the Socialist Movement with (amongst others) reformist

LETTERS

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

elements outside the Labour Party for an ex- planation of Jones' attitude to PR?

Geoff Coleman Hull

We welcome letters on any subject: but please keep them brief! Letters over 400 words will be cut. Send to Socialist Outlook, PO Box 1109,

London N4 2UU

Where were the Trots?

Phil Hearse's obituary of Louis Althusser (Socialist Outlook No.29) is a well balanced piece, and for Trotskyists I think that is a bit of a problem. However useful some aspects of Althusser's project may, or may not, have been, its core was an attempt to rejuvenate Stalinism in a more acceptable, because more academic and more abstract, mode.

Of course, as Hearse notes, Althusser did not actually engage with Trotskyism. Unlike Hearse however, I don't think Althusser's in- ability to see the 1986 version of Trotsky's philosophical writings was central to this. Rather surely it was the responsibility of the not inconsiderable number of Trotskyists or- ganised in France during the peak of Althusser's influence?

Keith Flett

Tottenham

For a fortnightly

Socialist Outlook!

¿ US bungles attack on Kuwait creating a massive oil slick

* 2 million strike against the war in Spain

* Kinnock and Willis back imperialism to the hilt

i Tories slip Poll Tax announcement through

With all this and more going on around us Socialist Outlook is making plans to go fortnightly in order to respond faster and with more clarity on the vital issues of the day.

We believe that there is an audience for the ideas of revolutionary marxism within the growing anti-war movement, in the anti-poll tax movement, among socialist feminists, in the Labour Party, in the trade unions - indeed amongst all those fight- ing capitalism and trying to build an alternative to the new realist mis-leaders of the labour movement. With a fortnightly paper we hope to arm our readership with ideas and analysis that will be useful in the class struggle.

But in order to do this we need money! As ever we must turn to you - our only resource - for the funds to start this am- bitious project. We are launching an appeal for E5,000 to purchase necessary equipment - computers, an ansaphone/fax machine and other essentials. Every issue of Socialist Outlook we will be printing a running total of contributions and telling you what we have been able to buy so far. Some groups of supporters have organised socials, others are producing anti-war badges, the important thing is to raise as much money as possible. The total so far is just over E800: there is still a long way to go!

Please make cheques or postal orders payable to Socialist Outlook and send to: Socialist Outlook, PO Box 1109, London N4 2UU. Even the smallest amount will help! We are relying on your generosity and support to make this venture a success.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 30. February 1991

Page 33

HALDANE SOCIETY

SOLIDARITY

NETWORK

ABOUR

PARTI

SOCIALISTS Fighting the Tory Anti-Union Laws

= OF

SOCIALIST LAWYERS

Unshackle the Unions

Saturday April 27th 1991, 11am-530pm

ULU, Malet Street, London'

Law * The Struggles * The Strategies

Speakers will include: *John Hendy QC, *Ronnie Me Donald (OILC),

*Micky Fenn (sacked Tilbury docker)

The 1990 Employment act is the latest in a long line of vicious anti-union laws. Its effects will be felt throughout the movement. Shop stewards and union officials at all levels are directly under threat. In order to defend jobs and pay they will find themselves in direct conflict with the law and legal restrictions on their union's ability to defend them.

Come and hear from leading trade unionists and employment lawyers the details of the Act and how it links into previous legislation.

There will be the opportunity to attend meetings with those from your own industry or union and workshops on the various aspects of the legislation, its effects and how to oppose it. A briefing pack provided by the lawyers will be sent out in advance to help the discussion.

If your organisation is prepared to sponsor and/or make a financial contribution to this event please fill in this form and send it to the address below.

We are prepared to sponsor this event on the issue of the Tory anti-union laws, their effects on the trade union, and how they can be opposed.

Name of organisation.

Address of organisation We enclose a donation of £..... towards the costs.

Please send us a form for the registration of O delegates at 65 waged, £3 waged per delegate Send to Carolyn Sikorski 53a Geere Rd, London ES

READ SOCIALIST OUTLOOK EVERY MONTH

1 years subscription (ten issues) for E10 inland, £15 Europe, E20 outside Europe (surface), £25 outside Europe (airmail) Multi reader institutions E20 inalnd, £35 overseas. Name...

Address.

Subscription to start from Number

← Unstable yet durable – the paradox of Indian democracy · Introducing Socialist Outlook →

Something wrong on this page?