Many people inside the Labour Party accept that support for anti-sexist and anti-racist policies deeply hurt Labour's electoral chances. Here JANE WELLS argues that leftwing anti-sexist and anti-racist policies were
AFTER
JAN
ELECTION
not the fundamental reason for Labour's defeat, and that it would be tactically and morally disastrous for
Labour supporters to drop these issues.
much of the lef) is on the delensive on these THEsE nAss poople in the Lubour Party nod
wisely when you say that Labour lost the
While the major pressure on Labour's, cinction because it was too interested in its
he blamed equaliry policies in the coming years will be own inward-looking ohsessins, and in "ge
the struggles of women, black people and les-
The right answer to the kind
Dians aud gays, and the demands which they of poll-peering and soul-searching signalled
raise in the class strugele, the ability of the he questions about political onsessions and
From the len. Campaign: group member Brian Sedgewore has weighed in. Promoting interest in the cronomy at the expeuse of con-
sture politics.
rights.
Livingstone, and (most ironically) Kinnock too for doing just the opposite. More percept- ive pulitical commentators might think that
gestures is that it is our alleged obsession with equal opportunines, with anti-racist and anti-sexist policies. that our gesturs' on leshian and gay rights and, though ma lesser extent, our "tokenstic" support for people with disabilitics is the problem. In short, our concern with all those issues thar interest us
— hut uf course don't affort the clectorate — much less the working class, lost us the elec- tion, Out there, people are only interested in getting their rouncil house repaired or sold
On the right, the most ourspoken expo- nent, along with Gavin Laird of the ARU. IS Joe Ashton MP. Before the election bie was joining in Fleet Strect's chorus of condemna- don of the London Labour l'arty's interest in equal rights for leshians and guy men, in par- ticular. Since Labour lost the election he has turned his hand to pursuing the class smuggle in parliamen — by setting up a social club in the House for the 'working class members (white, male manual workers prelerrod).
Predictably, the managers and the rea
Kinnuck(ist) has failed spectacularis on both counts. And of course. supporters of the
Militest can cuntinue to argue as they always
the working class is emphanically not built by
huilding support among it for the demands of
Out in the party ranks, arrivists once galv- anised to support for radical policies by the positive developments during the miners
strike, and in local goverument (particularly
during Livingstone's leadership of the Gue)
are rethinking and realigning themselves.
The deleat of those strugeles, followed by
anther Levestatung Clection detear for the
Labour Party, has left many constinuericy and trade union activists utterly demora-
611.
hraart. 28
The consensus on
ligners in lie parry leadership identifying the presentation. dire replicitly, an the problem.
thus is surprisingly
lised, The "Tondon effect'. formerly a stu- dowy possibiliry (and possibly an invention
of the media and the polls), is now perceived
MICE
fon
'did our support for
unpopular with the majority?, is hase, con-
triwersial and urgent. The Tories and their
Sawver. Hewitt), have been quick to pin the black poople in particular (encouraged by tie blame 1oo — if a linte more carefully, by successful high-profile racist element to their
if not the poli
the
clertion campaign) and on lesbians and gay men, while the Labour Party (including
uns-
these demands and advance demn politically
DURING THE MINERY strike great political divides soomed to have been travelled, cer rainiy ar a rank and file level, with women
against pit closures, lesbians and gays sup- port the miners groups and the black delega- Lous to the mining communities forging
whole (and with all the
is crucial.
links that shorly befor would have seemed impossible. The developments sent shock- waves throughnur che SUM, the political landscage there at least scemed to shift and all surts of possibilities open up. But in a pr- riod of political retreat, and when the focus is: moved from a section of politically advanced workers in struggle to the working class as a
Thatcheriam: has wroughr in it), the task is all the mom dilficult, and the opportunities
Arriviss, fresh from an election defeat where they were told on 1oo many doorsteps by voters that labour seems to care abour everybody but them and that hlack lesbians get to the top of the council housing list, are fast concluding, with the encouragement of the prese and the party managers, that the best thing to do with unpopular policies is to ditch them — at least until the "bread and
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 September/October 1987
more limited.
Its torpe
З0N VeIRE
shcick
poliucat
hift and
Da 18 changes that
butter issues can be tackled, presented pro perly and (in local government) "basic" ser-
vices delivered.
There are others in the movement mninly those people who wouldn't support progressive measures on equal opportunities anyway — who go further Dropping our commitments on equal opportunities and anti-racist is not simply argued as a damage limitation measure: it is elevated to the point where it is seen as a soluton to die party's ills, almose as if it was the one thing holding La bour back in June.
Twn main issucs. closely connected, are central to the dehare: the facts about the ex
lent of support for, or opposition to. particu- lar policies, and the political arguments about priorities, and how to build support for Labuur.
As far as the facts are concerned, they re notoriously dillicuit in establish and now-
ir polic
As far as the facts are concerned, they re notoriously dillicuit in establish and now-
věllw| Lillome wne fidl London, with onlya 1.65 swing in its favour (compared to 17e nationally), but then again
riously casy to bend London, with once
…naredmo. not as vadlv as
not as badly as in did in the south cast as a
whole. And a number of left candidates gor
particularly Jeremy Corbyn,
whuse Islington North constituency is part of
the socialist republic of loony left Islington,
where he increased his majority by 10%.
Also encouraging was the result of Chris Smith, the only our gay SiP, whu was re turned in the southern balf of the same
DATIN ST ENDAR!
borough, more than doubling his slim 1983
nits in Londun — nor surprisingly — were
had imposed massive rate rises, — as in Ea
And support for Labour in Manchester. where the city council has a much publicised Jerbian and gay unit with high profile poli- cies, increased by berween 1.5 and 59%
Jing and Waltham Forest.
Manchester is now completely
Tory-free
with five Labour Mis representing the city. Four black MPs — all black sections sup potters — were abu elected, with in most cases minimal wings recorded against La bour in their constituencies or increases to
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK ne 3 Seplember/October 1987
ER THEELE
1 ON
String unst thern
espire
mis
Whether such resnirs can be taken as an in-
dication of positive support for, or even tle- ration of prugressive stands on policies is
deharabie.
emerging consensus that "Labour can't win without misditing its policics". Labour ran "allord to be identilied with the oppressed
minoritics. The more interesting question is
be sten
The au can it afford not to be?
In find
11100.
there
TA L
badly because it failed to win the conc — scat-
istically speaking — and politically key, soc- tions of the wurking class. Women forces
SEES T
hysteria hardly met with robus opposition from the Tabour leadership. Instead of ar- tacking the press hysteria, Kinnock attacked
Bur of course there is a much deeper fal- lacy revealed in the argument thar people have gone 'too far" in anti-racist und anti- sexist policics — a fallacy revealed very
its victitus.
openly by Joe Ashton's sick joke about scut-
ing up a 'working class' caucus in parlia- ment. Joe Ashton's caucas would ul course be entirely male, white, heterosexual, with un average age of over 50. If Joe Ashton thinks that's what the working class looks
mEss hton
bok
were rarected much more successfully by the
Alliance. 14% of skilled workers have been Jost tn the Tories since 1974, and 13% of tra
narrow-minded than it socus at first sighe!
Jue Ashton and his ilk mischievously and
maliciously counterpose the inmerests of the
most oppressed to thosc of the 'wurking class
in a way which neither corresponds to social
From the point of view of socialist morality
de unionists to the Tories ar the Alliance over
the same period. Less black people vored La-
bour than ever belore: Without staining, or
rehunding its black support, Labour stands to lose its ever-more patchy base in London
as gentrification and other demographical
changes crode its traditional support there.
The fallacy of the argument that it was
Labour's obsession with the oppressed which
reality and is profoundly divisive.
the Aslton type of argument is bankrupt. Even if defending the most oppressed did cost some votes. it would still be correct to du it. Defending civil rights in the United Srates in the 1960s undoubtedly cost votes among
the elecaun nas bee
research on the m
wash to more l the boobie made wen
Bur commis
poor white racialist bigots. But few in the Demortaric Party, a capitalist party at chat, cared to raise the abjection that supporting civil riglus in the southern United States cost the votes of pour whites. That poople slivuld in the Labour Party raise the objcction that ant racist and anti-sexis policies have lost votes, shows a deep-sculed political oppor-
de
n Labour afford
identified with
oppressed?
the
There are of course hackward sectors of the wurking class who can he whipped up be
Many of these working class prople vote Tory anyway. But you can see in some inner city areas, sections of the white working cass whose environ- ment and living standards have declined, op- posing anti-racist and anti-sexist policies. These ane the kind of people who provide sume of the has of sop support in a consti- lucacy like Ilington South, or some of the bass of support for the Tabcrals in Liverport.
Oficu these sectors include many people whe esed to vote Labour hut have becom disilhasioned with Labour in government, and the inability of successive Labour gov- ernments and right wing Incal Tabour mun-
lind reactionary policies
oppressed, which is possible in London, the policies and responses of the party leudership aud thie right wing bear a for of the responsi
hility.
scope of community mobilisation over issues like rulecapping showed it. But after aboli-
tion in 1985, the right wing modia raised
campain again. in focal authorities to a new pitch af hysteria. Anti-racise and anti-sexist policies of course
figured promincarly in thus anti-loony left' crusade.
The Kinnock leadership, however, instead of confronting this right wing hysterical non-
sense. to a large degree wrot along with it.
and urilised it as an opportunity to attack left
famoux 1985 conference speech amacking
Before the GLC ael Met counties were
abolished in 1985, left Lubour authoritics were in general highly popular, Inderd the
"Inon'
cils to sulve any of their problems
But despite the prohlem of white workers
Deposed to anti-raciss and anri-sexist poli-
cis, vuu cannot create the basis for future working class unity by capitulating to their vices and ditching the oppressed. You can ouly create that basis by standing up to righr wing wedia witch hunts and by fighting your corner. The Kinnock leadership, of course,
CatEch
extremists in local government. Kinnock's
spee/
Militant's role in Liverpool was symholic of
the whole process. Morcover, the witch hunt inside the party againsr the left only encou- have done the upposite
government,
•Ih ts atllus cir
especially
its policies
women, black people, Iesbians and gay tea.
The party leadership helped to constice
the mythniogy of anti-sexist and anti racist
Mu
Te is also secessary to make anti-racist and anti-sexier policies a component part of an «verall socialis policy aimed at raising work ing rass living standards all round, a policy capable cif showing in practice that the inte rests of the most oppressed are hot in any
maion was tiw black sheep'
— for example the famous one that I taringer council had banned the singing of Baa, baa
in schools.
xinc
fundamental sense counterposed to those. of the mass of the working class. Kinnock and the right wing have nor only fallen to rin this.
29
But the lies and but are uppused to it.