Local
government:
Neil Kinnock - wouldn't you
In the March/April issue of International (a predecessor of
ss0r0l DAVY JONES
o local
.. Toresanc
reviewed eight years of local governmen ur asked the question, Is there a
future tor town Now. ne sars.
Is there a ww..alismr
much •
THATCHER MADE it clear on election night that one of her few regrets of the first eight years was her failure to ade- quately deal with Labour councils and
gramme to radically
= = 50 E
The Tories
government and remove any possibility of Labour authorities implementing pro-
In =
Southwark council leader, An council leader Linda Bellos, de a united Labour campaign - i with this squat-proof door
ne Matthews, and Lambeth monstrate the benefits of against homeless people
Inc.
whien the annesper
a dualitatively dreglee series at be aweetient than to it vears financial squceze Economically, these attacks will lead or recastribution me weatre Food sto the rich. from the workar ne capitalists — notably.thri» nsion of privatisation. "e cr
and the continuing c
Econt
iF !
in local authority spending. Socially, the measures will break up working class communities in the inner cities by splitt- ing up council housing estates, raising
government sions in the working class idculogically
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 Septumber/October 19B7
rents in the inner cities, weakening the
trade unions, and
drastically cutting services to those most
weake
unic
THISI» ing the
deeper the
TOWNHALL SOCIALISM
bour group to no cuts in jobs and ser-
vices to the implementation of a vacancy
freeze. termination of all temporary con-
redeployment of
statt, and the sacking of those committee
and economically, winning support for
individualistie notions of "freedon' and choice and fanning opposition to equal
political goal is to force the rclatively popular Labour local authorities to tho- roughly discredit themselves in the eyes
of the working class by being the agency
through this barrage of
opportunity policies.
polineal =
populi. Li
Their crowning tracts,
«tall. ..
com id the
Islinglon, for example, faces projected deficit, hased on no growth, than I110m for 1990/91, which is more than its entire current annual expendi-
exercises,
of more
ture шо ma nocu po The inimediacy and scop • has al least ailercel
2202315
the
accounting or tinkering at the edges of these delicits are mcaningless. huge cuts in jobs and services will bridge
Efficiency
creative
Only
workforce, community groups and ser-
these projected "gaps"
Unfortunately it scems that many of the local Labour Icaders arc only too wil-
ling 1o oblige. The end of an era is
Unforme
councils were scr trom the vid stite La
committea progressive pre
the cri
„wur sifferen: H* CAY
cils: committed in varying degrees to progressive policies; expansion of ser-
a1...
saltar
equal opportunities; the
Tories and to traditional labourism. however inadequate from a Marxist viewpoint. If the next round of the Tory onslaught on local government is not re- buffed the era of town hall socialism'
will be over.
a manual ...
a Marxist of the Tor-
role ot
government unions will be
vital'
Even before many of the planned Tory structural changes to local govern- ment are introduced, many Labour-
controlled boroughs are faciny imme- diate financial crises in the latter half of this financial year or for the next vear. Many Labour authoritics miraculous- ly survived the past cight Tory years by resort to creative accountancy. These measures have now been all but stopped by the government. The Labour coun cils are now paying the price in more ways than one. First, they tace the col- lapse of leaseback deals with the City
th.
Miny Tab
measures have now been all but stopped
als
far
n more
which were crucial in balancing this
year's books, and the need in the next few vears to begin the massive repay-
deferred purchase
which
ments on whose mcome has.b. the last lew years.
deals - their
rest lew
Second, and just as importantly, they face the crying woll syndrome'
workforces and local communities have heard the apparently empty threats of huge job losses and service cuts in past
councils have always somchow muddled through due to creat-
the
appar
years, yet the
show
ive accountancy. They are simply not
The most publicised case of an imme
believed any more.
post-clection financial crisis is Camden. In one whirlwind month the
council moved from a public commit- ment on I July of its entire ruling La- SOCIALIST OUTLOOK rs.3 September/Ocober:1987
Camden that thi
council isn't crying wolf.
Other Labour authorities in London. Manchester, Oxford and elsewhere around the councry are locked in dispure
As the councils brace themselves for these cuts, the government are following
up with other devastating attacks: • privatisation of whole areas of coun • ending contract compliance methods • oulawing any form of political cam- • encouraging tenants to opr out of council estates, and massively raising council horse rents.
cil scrvices. of local mouncils.
massi
•ising
cation Authority.
• breaking up the Inner Tamdon Edu-
anil
di intr
section by the hack door by allowing
schonis to opt out of local education au-
roducis allowing
- all-
thority control!
*the Tories aim to break up
Labour's base in the inner
devclopment
Dase T
cities' • setting up more unaccountable urban take away power from clected local an-
Die curporations (UDGs) 10
thorities
• and, finally, a massive redistribution of wealth from the poor in the rich by the almost modieval poll tax/community
To successfully resist this daunting
programme strictural change to local
would nced a mighty,
united movement of all those threatened
by these Tory proposals - nants. communuy organisations, service users.
n oy tae
charge.
government Carlo
and crucialis, the council workforce. In-
stead the Labour councils" response to
their immediate financial crises does precisely the opposite — pitting tenants against council workers, voluntary or- ganisations against other service users, and one section of council workers
ay non to meet huge tenan sh
in next ycarle buggers. wit
government to ban them out
fis
Har or
"caring cuts" the new
against another. watchwords of those Labour
councils which have
capitulated
no more creative accountancy "miracles'
on hand. A: Icast ten Labour boroughs
on tace deficits next year of
€30 million or more (E60m in the case of
Camden and more than E100m in Man-
chester). The projected deficits in future
years are completely uncontrollable -
ten Labo
aSE. i Mi
uncontrollable
THIL MOST COLERENT explanation of the new strategy of the Labour councils came frum Margaret Hodge. Islington council leader, in a paper to the Associa- tion of London Authorities just after the election. Previously she and other "soft left council leaders had accepted the
"dented shield strategy - better to stay in office and prevent cuts in jobs and ser-
vices by any method (raising *ales.
creative accounting, and so on) than to
TOWNHALLSOCIALISM
and the important London Bridge or-
ganisation of shop stewards taking a
principles stance of unity of all those
fighting the Tory attacks. Local com-
risk confrontation with the government. After Labour's clection defeat therr is no pretence of a commitment to no cuts; ruther jobs and services are to be 'defen- ded by being.. cut! By a humane La-
bour council, rather than a Tory one.
Hodge explained that there were three options: defiance, 'which has been tried,
and discredited';
cuts package involving +.000 voluntary
redundancies. And in Tambeth, Linda
Bellos introduced a cuts budget for the
1987/88 financial year, and has voted
against no cuts motions in Labour group
discussions in next year's budget. More
surprising has been the behaviour of
supporters of Socialist Action in Man-
chester, Lambeth and Islington — refus-
ckag-
DE the
ISSE TU EI srisins "
OBE CLOUN munity
established ne beh dour
•т M:... boroughs.
and council workforce-based committees against the cuis have been
in a number of London
Labour Briefing supporters have plaved a central role in building and leading the opposition in Camden. Lambeth, Haringey, Brent and other
which irresponsibly leaves the way open for the Tories to do the cutting; or 'stay-
ing in office and using all our resources
resignation, And to be more pre-
ing in office and using all our resources
and imagination'. cise, this latter meant that 'services must
take precedence over trade union inte-
rests or even jobs'. Surprise, surprise,
The alternative, in Labour controlled boroughs, to Hodge's kind curs and capitulation" is "defiance'; which has never been seriously attempted except by Liverpool and Lambeth. It succeeded
one year for Liverpool in extracting
more government cash. In the sccond
councillors
and in the council chamber. year
London boroughs, both in the unions
boroughs, to Hodge's kind curs and
capitulation" is "defiance'; which has
never been seriously attempted except
by Liverpool and Lambeth. It succeeded
rests Margaret Hous course of action:
This une 15 -
• Labor
aster for Labour in local government. It
is already leading and will increasingly Icad to Labour councils implementing terrible ruts in jobs and services, which
surcharged
mich
(though they have not yet personally suf-
fered the financial effets due to labour movement collections) but jobs and ser- vices were protecied just as well, if not
labnur
in turn will undermine any capacity for united resistance to the next round of Tory attacks. Having done the Tories' dirty work for them they will fall victim to the Torics' social engineering in the inner cities and their own new unpopu- larity, and be discarded at the polis.
The Labour and union leaderships have no great sympathy for the Hodges! Blunketts and other former local govern-
Denh Doret
Defiance may Newham refuse collectors - how secure are their jobs?
il not
better, than by the creative accounters'
dangerously uncertain, but the alterna- tive is absolutely certain to lead to huge cuts in services and jobs. means a strategy of maximising, locally and nationally, the broadest untied op position of all those facing Tory attacks - counil workers, tenants, the volunt ary sector, community groups. and ser- vice users — into a campaign of mass ac-
Defiance
wal
ment lefts' However hard they try to present themselves as born agam new realists' they are deeply distrusted by the labour hureaucracy. who will be only 10o happy to see them discredited and dis- carded. Even in the local government unions little more than token opposition
Ix monon 1n Manchester district party debate on the uncil's amanuel crime, and in indo borougns characterisin. tho- tions calling for no cuts in jobs and ser-
isis
tion lo force the government to back din, on some or all of its propreads,
Such a strategy relies not on indi vidual councillors bur on mass involve- ment. It entails a united campaign of mobilisation to establish thr real social
needs of the borough/ City and the de- mand for the council to expand jobs and!
and to grant more money. But there is growing opposition to the
idal une ofthe council and
•ups. primarus from wa but also within the Labour groups themselves. In Haringey, the group has been split exactly down the middle all summer over how to respond to the crisis, with 20 councillors support
ing a 'no cuts stance. In Camden, nine councillors opposed the drastic measures
introduced by the council, supported
to the Tories can he expected from the union hierarchy. Already in landon re- gional bureaucrats are plaving an ex- tremely divisive role - TOWL officials advising stewards in Bremt io defend their own jobs by culling mickey mouse NAICO jobs, and NUPL officials in Greenwich putting forward a named ser-
defend their own job.
services through a (deficit) budget in.
meet those nceds, funded by extra gov
ernment cash and/or the cancellation of the huge debt repayment charges which conneil pay cach year. Links can be made with other groups involved in similar and related struggles against the Theirs, especially trachers and parents defending education. Demands must be raised for the defence and extension of local democracy and accountability with the expansion of community. users and council workers" control of
Building wrong links with the com munity is vital for council workers to sensc the support they need to take the industrial action which will undoubtedly prove necessary to stop the Tory attacks.
NAIGO's resistance, and were sacked
rom their group positions. In Lambeth,
eight councillors opposed the 1987/88
cuts burger and eleven are now com ideologically collapsed into overtly rac- tionary and divisive policies on local mitted in opposing next year's curs
budger. The existence of a minority government. Former hard Ieft" figures such as Rernic Grant, Graham Stringer rouncil opposition against the cuts. has
ics of NAL.GO posts to be cut in order te banthas NOR Is Ii just the "soft lefi" who have
In Lam
and Linda Bellos have all gone down the humane cut" mad. In Haringey. Ber- nie Grant MP, now in the Campaign group, led the Tabour right wing into voting with the Tories to defeat the La- bour group's motion opposing cuts in jobs and services proposed by the new council leader, Steve King.
In Manchester Graham Stringer led 32 the Labour group into proposing a huge
bad an important effect in stimulating
and supporting the key resistance of the
ckt those services mising opposition within the community
as a whole
Within the unions at local leve! especially NALGO, the response has been quite encouraging with a number of
NALGO branches, and jomt umon com- Patient explanation and consistent pro mutters in Brent, Islington and Lambeth paganda on the extent of the couneil's
50D AUST OUTLOOK ne3 Secrember/O/tober 1992
TOWNHALLSOCIALISM
financial crises and the scope of the Tor government is to be repelled, opposition ies planned attacks on local government to the line of the union Icadership has to will be needed to persuade council be built up in co-ordination with local workers that such a response is needed. ndl Many local councils are cynically intro-
Breaking the resistance of the public ducing their financial curs piccemeal. and with great stress on their continuing
back in local government will therefore
be a central issue for the whole labour
movement over the next few years. It
will provide a key test for all currents on
the left of their seriousness about build-
sector unions to cheir plans, to slash ing a class struggle current in the labour
public spending is a key plank of the movement. Failure in the struggle will commitment to defending johs and ser Tories straiegy. Organising the fight- bring "town hall socialism" to an end.
vices", while their three year fmancial plans will in fact decimate them, in order
Camden - a test case to lull their stall into a false sense of security and to ncutralise any effective
Cantiden's Labour council agreei a
package of cuts at the beginning of
Ar each stage the workforce unions
July in an attempt to hridge a budget will have to carefully select the tactics to
deficit of C1l million. There was no respond to the councils attacks and to
constitation with Labour parties, the maximise the unity and strength of their
worklore, or the wader community opposition. Regional and national ini-
The Labour group was clected ou a
manifesto commitment to maintain tatives will be crucial for demonstrating
services and jobs and to fight for locat the depth of opposition to the finanial
demoracy. curbacks. Tt may only be a minority in
Begun to attack the basis of its support pach borough or ciry, bur regionally and
in the borough. A ficeze on all nationally that aggregate of minorities
vacancies means the loss of over 900 could be a powerful force. The planned
jobs, and the rontracts of some 300
cuts temporary matt will not he renewed. initially proposed by Anging and ralled
Workeis have already been sacked as a
result Overuue has been cur. and
butle repairs and modernation to
council housing have heen severles
London conference against the
by Endon Bridge and Carden NAtio is a grunt exampic of the instatives necded.
One thing is absolmely clear as we Ince the next wave of Tory anacks on Ical government. the mule of the local government unions wil be central in defeating them. In most baronglis will wither be Tory councils where the main stuck will come through privatisation.of local government services, or Labour authorities applying. in one was or mother, the Tory cuts. It is likely that oniy a tiny minorts of Labour councils will actually have a majority for de- fiance. Iven where a Talwar council de- rides on defiance, as the experience of liverpen| shows, this cannor proccod withour the cominued support of, and co-ordinanen with, the local govern- ment unions.
Ir has to be said, however, that despite some promising signs at local level. ma- rionally none of the local government unions have anything like a strategy which can defeat the Tory attack. As we pointed our above, in some places NUPE
and Towe offcials are trying to detend their members jobs ar the expense of NAIGO workers.
But even NATGO na- tonally, despite an acute awareness of the potentially disastrous effects of local government privatisation on its half- million local government membership. refuses to adopt a national policy of strike action. Instead it proposes "publi
and winning public support' in op- Position to government policy — finc in itself but not a policy capable of winning anything: If the new Tory attack on incal
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 September/October 1997
ile uton tATE, and 1STS (representing wurkers in Camden fundod organisations) have all voted overwhelmingly not to co operate with cuts: SEPE, however, lus opted fira sweetheart deal with the council teas is let un ullet. Even this rare sorness for the leadership is low in doubt, with home help ebop stewards zuw opposing The council has now their hranch leadership as die consequets if the alcaney frocee start to liurt Clients
Workers in SATGO are lacing thrvars oflocknur, pay docking, and (spuriosly) personal surcharge. Despite tae council's tapressed desar to protect frontline sorces, the bomeless personn snit remains closed duc to lack of suit. other sections in harsing and social services departments are operating a roduced service, and branch libraties
restricted.
The council lealership have presented this package as it stalling operation until consultation cio le arranged, With a shortfall of E40
will simpo be a smokcicroco The
voluntary on turservices is aircarly in place. with mumagers being asked to prepars budgets for 3, 20. and 40 per cent cuts, Early retimement and
in preparuion, with compulsory redundancies likely betore the end of the vear
part af the blame for thix financial
and ...
million nest tinancial year, and anger viet the matial cuts, um "consultation
machinery for dismantling council and
voluntary redundancy schemee are now
Tony Dekes, Jader of the council, has gone as far as sating pubiirls that
crisis lies with the wineil. The soft left have cobbled together an accountant s straregy, and are under pressure from a
coditiun of old and new righr wingers (the latter organised as the lahour
Co-onlinating Commince and
advertising themselves as Camden
This group is enthusiastically calling
saling
Tribune),
uts district auditor.
Nine Laboar Bricting councillors have
nriy opposer cli
services. They have been removed from
committee positions on the basis ut
standing urders, despite inaction
against diose right wingers who engaged in amicable discussions with
the distroir auditor in the spring
Carden NALOO, the building workers
for under-fivesiron the point.of collapse. P'lane have already been formulated to sell ull parts it ilie council's housing stock und olliet
many services lu the test
Lalver Briging lus initiated a
and subsogucal rounds of cuts
attempting to esplun to workplane
coumallors uppused to the abanductient of the manifesto.
Labour Bruting "freemasonry town hall, and arrusing the now
committee of queuc-jumping the
the gay and lesbian unit were threatened with disciplinary action The second allegation undermined council policy on sexual harassment. the counciltor concerned having
underway, with anti-lesbianist a feature of it.
an threatened with disure: 1rocision
The soluntary sector, amviding disadvamaged and oppressed sections of the communty: is overhelmingly opposesthe council filans. Cannen borough-wade campaigo against this Leatership and right wing coumillers have received a hustile reception when mecting and community groupe why their funding, service ur jub is young to go. and refuse tu debute with the nine
Right wing councilors are going arraight to the press with allegations of
sic) in the deprised chair of the gay and leshian housing list. In the first caxe, officers in
suffered abuse and threats because of her sextality. Clearly, a witch dunt is
assrts.
33
HILDAB
THE SEXUAL abuse of children, like all other
father). The
forms of rape, is not essentially about sexual desire or frustration. It is about the abuse ol power by a lather-ligure (a fathcror ans mon whw has the position of power enjoyed. by: a
position of children, and especially girls, in the family is oue of powcr-
Tuse power structures exist in "normal familics which are not abusive as well as via which are, and as long as fatlier-figures have this power the possibility of child sexual abuse will remain. The pro blem of powerlessness is not reversed by the medical establishment and social services when duey "deal with child sexmal abuse; in laet ticy compound the problem.
The existence of the family allows sexual shese to happen and to remain secret Sexual
REEN sussrest!
VEC-sponsored review" of women in the
without its dangers.
Trek is only one word to describe the past tweive months for women in the Labour Party dismal. We lutve been subjected to macho Ncil strutting across our tr screens alwars accompanied by Glenys — the woman we should all strive
cancelled, postponed ur just forgotten
lessness.
certain trade union leaderships, the com- position ofthe women's conference would
altered, in order to give
have to he
themselves more power.
The proposal from WAC is that the
ta be like. We
about. gor a promise of a women's ministry to fight for the interests of women. Well. Jo Richardson has been allowed into the Shadow cabinet, is minister lor women s rights — unfortunately she is the onty woman in the cabines.
Also at last vear's party conference the lads deeded we women organised in the Labour Party neoded shaking up. Did they propose a joint campaign with the unions to organise and defend women part time workers? Did they propose we set up a campaign with black women's organisarions to oppose racist and sexist immigrarion laws? Did they ask us to work with Irish women to oppoor strip
the organisation Labour women.
have our conferences
Px.... At last year's party conference ar …imk
trade unions and socialist socicties have a 50 percent bior and women from the
. the other s0 pe delevate:
the unions is tied to the number of
women members in each union, then
some unions, like NUIs, COHSH and GMB
would get proportionally more than the
abuse is particularly damaging because it happens in tbe family. The farr that the fattier-ligure has rotal access purs the child in
Reranse the child is assumed to
the father-ligure, other people are disbelieving when the abusc 1s disclosed; and because the child wants to be protected and loved by him the abuse is a
The malr-dominared family is neressary to the ruling lass and is delended by it. The existence of the lamily relies es the state of the responsibility for the reproduction of the tabour force and for the ininial socialication of children into bourgeois ideas. The power struenures wirhin the nuclear family divide men from women and adults from children. and also rostrict women and children in dicir
With die increase in mporter child seural abuse cases, thn inherent dangers for chil dren of living in families could become appa
How does the tulang
GÉ.N
constant fear
be protected by
long-lasting betrayal of mist.
AEL, EKTPU, and so forth. This would make the clection of righr wing wamen to
the NEC less likely and making the
While this change should he supported,
it is not a panacca — in the way that a see-
tion of the 1 WAC leadership believes. Ar the same time as putting lorward this
method of increasing the trade union vute, LWAC is also proposing to decrease the number of delegates from the CLIs. Ir argues this on the basis nf rationalising'
women's conference
searuling? No. they proposed to review mure respectable". This is a stab in the
and conference of back to women in the caPs 10 placale cer-
Discusion in every tain trade union leaders. We should not
ability to light. women's section, trade unicin branch and ignore the XEC's role in the review. They CLP were promised. Nut exacily die kind also want to change the women's con
lerence, Kinnock's purty fit to govern"
of the thing that would grab the arentino of women in struggle you might think — does nor include holshy feminists having you'd be right, especially in an Alertion a say in policy making
lt remains unclear ar the time of vear In so far as the discussion has hap pened, it has trustrated and demuralised writing what will happen at party con-
terence on this question.
Women in the Labour Party and the tion that was supposed tu have taken
rent to more peuple. class smooth out the contradictions between- delending the family and heing soon to rarr for children, and artually tum the growing awareness of