Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Civil servants pay battle fails

· Socialist Outlook no. 3, September–October 1987 · p 18 · 1,407 words

CP SA

16

would thus end the campaign.

campaign lost

THE CPSA pay dispute has now ended. The

the right wing who clearly believed that a ballor on all our action would be lost and

The motion was defeated. The soft left BE 81 and their political silics in the leadership of the scis (the middle management uninn with whom the campaign was being jointly run) capitalised on uncertainty which existed

arguing that the time was not right and what was required instead was more confidence-building selective action In. reality they had no intention of ever sappor- ting all out action. Like the straigy of the

STEVE FRENCI problems for the left in the

in CISA. the soft-left strategy.

result of the national ballot to escalate the dispute to all nut indelinite strike action was cont of the union's members supported the

strike call and only 50 per cent bothered to

vote. A defrar of this size presetits serious

CPSA.

ment's own figures put the initial strikes at 85 percent solid.

The inirial action, however, also led to two

very important mistakes, The strategy was one which involved every region of the coun try taking one week's strike in rotation le lasted six weeks and covered the period in the nun up to the CPSA conference in carly At the time activists were primarily concerned with delivering successful action in their own region. As a result the union

scan. parcelleu ub - reg from each other. This was com- pounded by the right wing NEC who were and givin. no natinnal leaderm. press who gave no national coverage. It was

therefore the role of the Broad Left which

was cffectively running the campaign on the

before it was due to hit london.

figures but d

suft-left in local government they were bunk- ing on a Labuur victory to hail them out.

The irony was that after losing its postion at the conference the Broad Left then won contrul of the union gaining an 18:6 majority

un the executive, and was left to carry out

From the point of defcar of the all-our

problems for the leit within CPSA and ir is important to analyse how and why it occurred

CPSA is dominated hy three political fac- tions. First is the Broad Left (BL) — which is

the other major groupings on the hard left, including Briefing supporters

Sccond, the national moderate group, a righr wing grouping with members in the conservative trade unionists and the sir (The group receives regular support from

such as Bernard Lavin Woodrow Wyatt. It is led by veteran "anti-

arr

CPSA is dominated hy three political fac-

is tne Brant Le dominated by Militon but also conrains all the other major groupings on the hard left,

2l.. e1 (BL) -

strike stralegy the campaign began spiralling downwands. Virally nothing happened for amonth. The Broad Lelt NEC was presented from taking oflice by right-wing maneuvr-

The following week the defeat of Labour in the general election caas-

demoralisation membership which was exuggerated herause

When the selective acrion did resume ic was sabotaged in a spectacular fashion by the SCPS leadership who pulled our of it two days

jusrification that CPSA bad broken uniry (the new NEC had committed the union to an all cut strike ballot oner the selective action was

regains became ing until 3 June.

ed

- thic among The

Then

communist Kate Losinska.)

Finallv. Br

THE h- Lete w

massive the Tories are uso thie employer.

ing of Communist Party and sult-left Labour Party memhere which split from the Broad

Lell in 1984 in the wake of the 5 month long DHSS Newcastle central office dispute

There is no such thing as an independent' in CPSA Virtually all committees at cvery level contain only members

itia national dittiet.

didn't. That was the first mistake.

md mistake «

ween aware anar selechr

would not move the Torics and was merely

of the ahove

WEET THR high level of visit

designed to build confidence for an all out

confruntation, the members were not

The I Le

completer) did not wash with their member- ship who rained censure motions on them. Tr was clear that the primary motivation was to undermine Lie new Binad Left leader bip.

The immucdiate ctferr was to deal ure killer blow to any hope that the civil service pas campaign could be sived The choker open.to the cilsa was then capitulation or to con- tinue to pose the valy solurion, all our action The leadership correrrly chose the later

Sections of the hand left (most notably die sWP) are already saying that tie Broad 1 ci leadership are responsible for losing the ballot by nut putting sufficient resources or commitmeut imo it This view cannor be sustained by the farts. The ballot was not posed in a way which merly got the leader- ship off the hook. It was seriously campaigh- ed for; it was however already too late for

The size of the deleat presents problems

groups. The individual workplace halinting system which has been in place since 1981

politicisation anong rank and file members. If is central to any understanding of the sometimes hizarre politics of thie umon thar

pay campaign originated with special conference in November 1986, As a

floor of conference the claim was the one pur

In - week long p famihar to u mem

m were i sch waw. the roie of th

means that there is a very

sometuues." this puint is understood.

Th~ pay

hammer those lessons home and to destroy any illusion in the power of selective action

Win We D neglected:

i word hea

THOSC I 41*030 035

colone This task was also

Tr would be an uversimplification to make

a hlanket condemnation of the Broad Lelt

leadership for (hese mistakes. There were ge-

nuine logistical problems in organising a

campaign of this size. However, it should be recorded that there was nor one nativna!

such a ballor to be won.

course

Le

wadersti.

lorward by the BL. The strategy was devised

The right wing. who controlled the NEC at the time, were left to carry it vut.

1 papa.

The first question is therefore why the can- paign was not strangled at birth.

The answer is wolold. First, there was a

Broad Left Icatict during the first six wecks

of the action. This should be set against the massive level of activity around the three campaigns to have John Macreadie clected

as general secectary of the union.

'The answer probably lies in Militant's belief thar the problems of the union, and

genuine mood among the membership that enuugh was enough". however existed in previous years and hus not been sufficient. The second and more important reason is thar the right wing had a project to end collective bargaining and to move to a settled pay system. In order to do this they had to smush any beliel in the puwer of industrial action by trying it our, sabotaging it, and thus "proving that it does not work. Unlortunately for them, industrial action in CPSA, as in any other union, has a dynamic of its own. tivists wok control and delivered the best support in the union's history. Manage-

preten. This mood has

important reason is thar the right wing had a project to end collective bargaining and to move to a settled pay system. In order to do this they had to smush any beliel in the

Once started, the ac

thus the problems of the pay campaign.

could be the

was therefore

Both the Tories und the right wing within CISA will be on the offensive. The result

imposition of regional and "men pay within the civil service and thos an end to national pay bargaining. The defear also undermines the contidence of members involver in other struggles. for ex ample the fight against limited period ap

the bliss. Ultimately the

future depends on the lessons that the Broad Left draws from the experiences of the past

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 3 Seprumter/Dietaber 1987

Ivan'

given the majur priority. Events, however. proved chut this was mistaken. The watersh ed in the dispute came during the CPSA con- Terence in May. Against a buckground of

un animi

May

massively successful selective action.

Broad left mbmitted a model resulution calling for escalation to all out indefitite strike action. The motion was supported by

the pointanents in all

four montiis

← Miners' agenda for action · Washington behind closed doors →

Something wrong on this page?