Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Adios, Tariq Ali!

· Socialist Outlook no. 28, November 1990 · pp 33-36 · 749 words

Russia and the USSR Labour Party Asia

Redemption
Tariq Ali
Chatto & Windus
13.99
Reviewed by Charlie van Gelderen

This is a book which should never have been written. It is so out of character of the Tariq Ali the world has known up till now, as to be almost unbelievable. The question, to which we shall return, is why did he write it?

Tariq is riding very high right now. He has become a media personality. The TV series, Bandung File which he co-edited was an excellent introduction for Western audiences to the problems of the 'Third World'. His current production Rear Window is well worth watching. He is joint author of the play Moscow Gold currently staged by the RSC at the Barbican. These are prestige productions which could only enhance his reputation.

But now we have Redemption. This is supposed to be a satire on Western Trotskyist 'groupuscles' and the strange behaviour of their eccentric leaders – and there is not one of them who is not eccentric or worse.

The art of satire is a difficult one. It is best when applied with a touch of understatement. Tariq is gifted with many talents, but satire is not one of them. There is no subtlety in this book. Nearly every character is a gross caricature of the original. Some of the women are portrayed sympathetically, and Tariq appears to have a soft spot for Renard, who tried to raise finance to support Trotsky by co-operating with a prostitutes' collective.

Only the cognoscenti will recognise most of the characters in the book. Who, but an old-timer will know who the description 'the twin evils, war and fascism' was applied to in the thirties, and the 'four-lines-only-per-page-of-foolscap'?

Tariq has spared no one in this book: not his old friends from Black Dwarf and Red Mole days; nor the members of the editorial committee of the thinly disguised New Life Journal. Despite the change of sex, most people on the left will recognise the prematurely white-haired editor. Even the editorial collective of Labour Focus on Eastern Europe is not spared.

Apart from the politicos who will read this book to see if they have been included in the dramatis personae, the sexual antics described might attract a more dubious type of reader.

Even the chief character in the book, Ezra, with whom the author seems to have a love hate relationship, is 'obsessed with sex'.

Of course, the book contains some bitter home truths. As Ezra, the leader of the World Party surveys what is happening in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. He refuses to believe that the 'reel can run backward', and that a counter-revolutionary restoration is taking place without violent resistance from the proletariat. Ezra's optimism remains undimmed as is illustrated by his letter to his daughter, with the quotation from Goethe, the last verse of which reads:

Build it again,
Great child of the Earth
Build it again,
With a finer worth
In thine own bosom build it on high
Take up thy life once more:
Run the race again!
High and clear
Let a lovelier stream
Ring out than ever before.

This is the sort of message which an Engels or a Trotsky would have given the working class in these days of retreat and defeat.

Apart from the undue attention to sexual activities (even on his death bed, Ezra had a 'partially erect member'), there is an unnecessary emphasis on the Jewishness of many of the comrades. Tariq knows very well that the accidental fact of their Jewish births played little or no part in the political or social life of the leaders of the movement.

So now we have to try to answer the question we pose above. Why did Tariq Ali risk his reputation and the goodwill of his friends by writing this rubbish?

Perhaps the explanation is to be found in the profile in the Independent of 29th September. Until his media debut with the Bandung File and Rear Window he 'seemed to have passed into the shadows of British life...expanding into his new age of yuppiedom, Tariq Ali prospered and grew stouter...'

But perhaps there is another explanation. With his new-found prosperity, and acceptance by a wider circle than in his street fighting years, he probably wants to make a complete break with his past. What a pity that he has chosen such an undignified way to do it. Adios, Tariq Ali!

← Flashbacks, timewarps and hype · Tory crisis →

Something wrong on this page?