Wild at Heart
by David Lynch
Starring Nicolas Page
Reviewed by Beverly Byrne
Sailor and Lula are a modern couple with an antique problem; Lula's mother doesn't approve of her boyfriend.
This is no surprise as the opening scene shows him smashing his friend's skull open. However, there are indications that Lula's mum is implicated in this gory action and it is this which provides the mystery in Wild at Heart.
Lula's manic mother sets out to put a spoke in the young lovers' relationship by having Sailor killed. The young lovers drive hither and thither to avoid apron strings and assassination.
Littered around this lightweight plot are several disparate characters who are lukewarm lookalikes from previous Lynch films. They don't contribute much to the plot, which is not surprising as its barely there anyway.
Their sole purpose is to illustrate a repertoire of themes and qualities which David Lynch finds fascinating and/or attractive. So just why is it that this film Wild at Heart won the Palm D'Or at this year's Cannes festival?
This accolade immediately raises a number of questions about the film. Is is a 'wild at heart and weird on top' art movie, is it hype for the self acknowledged cogniscenti, or is it merely a Lynch formula? Certainly it could qualify as an 'art house' movie on the ground of generic and temporal confusion.
It is at once an old fashioned Hollywood thriller, a so-called road movie and a bit of a thriller with black magic and wizardry (of Oz) thrown in for good measure.
Lynch likes to play around with Hollywood styles, and he manipulated them beautifully in Eraserhead and Blue Velvet to produce two profoundly disturbing and visually arresting movies. Wild at Heart looks attractive, but is unmemorable, and ultimately seems as vacuous as its two protagonists, who smoke, fuck, dance and talk in banal cliches, amusing at first and irritating later.
Lynch also tampers with time. He uses contrasting sounds and images to create an ahistorical vacuum for the action; this works well in a scene where the gyrating lovers frug out to a live band who look like Motorhead. On cue the heavy metal freaks metamorphose into a gentle backing band for Sailor's Elvis impersonation complete with screaming 50's fans. The music acts as a temporal red herring but Lynch fails to link this to any narrative cause.
There is of course the now ritual disregard for narrative continuity. Flashbacks fill in the missing pieces of the flimsy story. Sometimes the flashbacks are no more than a one shot insert, a lighted match for example, is of layered significance; the post-coital fag, the reason Sailor is being hunted, the cause of Lula's exaggerated bimboesque behaviour.
By throwing in the flashbacks, the timewarps and a few designer peculiar characters who stand in for Lynch's thematic passions; the mad mother, the seedy, inept private detective, the morally and physically repulsive hit man, the erotic and sensuous woman, two sexually perverse cripples and so on he manages to concoct just about enough enigma to keep you in your seat.
However, the ultimate failure of this film is Lynch's inability to provide a coherent unity in the form of the plot. As a result Sailor and Lula have no real reason to exist cinematically: they are just not 'real' enough to care about.
So it might be said that on the grounds of style, narrative and time, Lynch is playing the old game of buggering around with the Hollywood classic movie. This will certainly satisfy those aesthetes who find Lynch films original, artistic and deeply meaningful.
One thing is for certain; David Lynch will be pleased. He has found a style which can make some of the people think that the film is intellectually stimulating whilst others believe it is a politically sound statement relating to mid-American society, the remainder will think its art and one or two of course will love it for the repetitive sex and the promise of violence.
All in all that's quite a lot of people. However, despite a couple of flashy ideas, Lynch has made a film which is like a piece of formica, smooth and slick on top with the promise of real wood underneath, but when you peel back the veneer all you find is compressed pulp.