UPDATE
No human face
for Thatcherism
THERE MAY have been punch-ups in the Commons tea-rooms between the Thatcherites and the Heselteenies after her resignation was announced: but their political disagreements are not by any means fundamental, argues JOHN LISTER. A cabinet led by John Major will easily accomodate Michael Heseltine while leaving most of Thatcher's policies intact
THATCHER'S GOVERN- MENT represented the most sus tained and brutal attack on the working class in Britain since the 1920s. For over eleven years it look sides ruthlessly and consis- tently with the rich, the young. the fit, the employers and the racists against the poor, the elder- ly, the sick the unions and the black communities.
It handed billions in huge tax concessions to the wealthy - bil- Lions it had stolen through slashed benefits and service from pensioners the un- employed, claimants. and homeless.
It shackled the trade unions with every conceivable legal restriction and financial penalty and armed scabs with police and High Court protection, while employers were encouraged to smash the strength of the shop stewards movement.
As it mercilessly robbed local
goverment of its powers and
aulonomy, culminating in the im- position of the Poll Tax, the Thatcher government handed vast new powers to the police. and shamelessly protected cor rupt cope and incompetent judges. None of this was serious- ly challenged in the leadership contest: and little of substance is likely to change.
There was little to separate
separale the views expressed by the three
contenders who challenged for
Margaret Thatcher vacated throne.
Only on the questions of
European policy and (possibly)
the Poll Tax was there any clear
disa which could ves dest: now Major goverment.
Page 2
bilior
The Gulf
Though many have nOw realised that a war with Iraq would he no casy re-run of Thatcher's short, nasty (and ex- tremely lucky) victory over Ar- gentina in the Malvinas, only Ted Heath in the Tory Party has openly broken ranks to question the drive towards military con- frontation
Heseltine's bellicose endorse- ment of the Thatcher line on the Gulf has been an echo of his period as Defence Secretary. when he attacked the Greenham Women and CND, and posed in combat fatigues and clapped-out army tanks (now breaking down in the Saudi desert).
The new govemment might marginally adjust its line, to draw a little closer to the more cagey approach of the European bour- geoisie, and pull a little further hack from the US front line. But there is no prospect of it withdrawing the 30,000 British troops or failing to use them in the event of a shooting war.
The economy
Major's own economic policy will also remain unchanged under Norman Lamont as Chan- cellor - and indeed is now large- ly dictated by membership of the European
Exchange Rate Mechanism, which requires high interest rates to keep the British currency within the fixed
guidelines. Hopes of an interest
rate cut appear to have been
dashed by the German Bundes bank pushing in the other direc tion.
Nor is there much prospect of
intervention to al
oming recessIon
already slashing job‹ hy
Thatcher attamnis lo nuron num
the thousand, forcing employers once more onto the offensive after a period of seeking to buy off militancy through higher than expected pay offers, and drawing from the "new realist" Engincer- ing Union leaders a defeatist abandonment of their half- hearted campaign for a 35-hour week.
seif had supported the idea.
Heseltine - as an advocate of properly training the workforce for the needs of capitalism made much of choing Labour's "big idea" of education and train- ing. and Major, too, in a sap to the powerful education lobhy. pledged to review teachers' pay: but short of a substantial increase in public spending (which would require an unlikely conomic U- tum by John Major himself) this will remain hot air (as indeed it is in Labour's programme!).
Or the NHS, newly-ap- pointed Health Secretary William Waldegrave has found himself saddled with a monumental crisis, with around 5,000 hospital beds closed for cash reasons across the country during 1990, and more to go next year, while waiting lists soar upwards.
He has little scope to resolve this problem, unless Major is prepared to sanction a big in crease in spending this year and next - having only just fought against such concessions in this autumn's spending round.
Waldegrave also has to decide
how many of the 66 applicant hospitals and units he allows to
Social policy
On the welfare state and so cial issues, there is room for some slight adjustments, but little sign of any embarrassing about- face reversals of policy.
The recession, and a new lurch upwards in numbers of un- employed, will intensify pressure on the cash-limited Social Fund and the whole Social Security system. while reducing the government's income from taxa- tion. It is by no means clear how Major plans to cope with this problem: benefits have already been brutally cut back and restrictions tightened to minimise the numbers eligible. The colos- sal increase in numbers of people living in poverty seems certain to increase under the post- Thatcher regime.
Sigmificantly. before resignation, Thatcher's newly ap pointed Education Secretary Kenneth Clarke had dismayed the No Turning Back group, and shown a rare flash of defiance when he contemptuously brushed aside the right wing's cherished plan for education vouchers only a short while after the lady her
"opt out" ax Self Governing
Trusts - with the real danger that
most of them will he in dire
financial straits or even hankrupt
within 12 months. With the pres
sure relaxed hy Thatcher's depar ture. mere • an outside chance that these augely unpopular
reforms may be slowed down, or
at least the opt-out list pruned al leas SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 29, December/January 1990/91
UPPAT
character of the Tax
means that even if he
DATO
did try this, many sen-
SAYS "
sitive areas would still
wind up paying much
more than others.
BETA STUFF proposals for
Hereltine vague
relation to income and
PUFFE
"ability to pay have
TAX 3 all the admunistrativ
a POLL TAX
LONDONE A
headaches of a local
STIRE income tax wren mone
of the advantages (im
PATING aging trying to get Poll
Tax non-payers 10
declare details of their
income!).
Jolin Harris NUJ The Poll Tax non-payment - key to Thatcher's defeat
Secretary Kenneth Baker in linc
with European restrictions on im
migration in the run-up to 1992.
The unions
Though Heseltine was widely
derided by the Thatcherites as a
"corporatist advocate of govern-
ment intervention, and a blast sales of council houses, and has
from the had old Heathite past of since advocated various dramatic
concessions to the unions, he, as proposids to dipose of the ..UCh as Major and Hurd, was an remnining stock of puhlic sector
active pty to the onslaught on housing - such as simply giving
the miners and printworkers and council houses to their present the imposition of Thatcher's hat- tenants.
tery of anti-union laws.
The appointment of Heseltine
The crawlers of the TUC
back to . selec. mardlu. least likely in go m tenn
Housing 15 v.. un which Heseltl... comstenı " den.... Thatchent- appet:.. Io lon. He mustermu de
dosa star
ae Raviminment Se
little change for the homeless government which will be work- tight limits on spending. and which Thatcher's hostility to any wel
17 Passes
shares
fare state provision and any inde- pendence of local governient.
Racist laws
The Thatcher govemment set out in the late 1970s to steal the mantle of Britain's racist party from the rag-lag fascist groupings
of the day.
Since then the door has been slummed shut on black immigra- tion, callously dividing families, sunucting thou -ands visitors to humiliating checks and prolonged detention deporting thousands of black "illegal im migrante A n back thousands more refuges.
policics
have been upheld hy the liberal" Hurd as Home: Secretary, and by cahinets including the 'man of the people Major and hy the 'European Heseltine; they will be further tightened under new Home
slummed shut on black immigra-
tion, callously dividing families,
• hours
uneras Hum as
hureancracy might conceivablv believe they stand a better chance of establishing a collaboration with a Major government (they recently offered Thatcher talks on a new "social contract", only to be rudely rehuffed): but the hest chance of forcing any conces sions from the new government
_ be trom a position of strength, based on industrial ac-
580788
Only under such pressure can workers draw out what differen- ces of approach do exist in the new Tory leadership.
Poll Tax
Michac! Heseltine is up against limited options in hix new hoohy- prize job as Envimment Secretary. If he succeeds in find- ing a new formula for Poll Tax, John Major will take the credit: if he fails, he will be on his own.
With public spending nailed firly down as Major has tried to squeeze out inflation, there in lit-
the hope of using large subsidies to cut the level of Poll Tax bills: indeed the inherently regressive
"banding" • miation ..
Tax In we and
Have
maximise Major's freedom of ac- tion in relation to Europcan monetary union. He knows that the rifte in the Party on Europe
could yet create new crises: he
also knows that the "pro-Europe'
wing are skating on thin ice - be-
cause had Thatcher been able to
carry out her threat to take ber policy - rejecting a single
European currency to a referen-
dum, she could have counted on a
substantial majority, linking old- fashioned
Sun-reading
chauvinists with those who reject the waste and bureaucracy of the EFC.
Errope..
An carly clection victory would give Major greater
option
sy we impose ms poucy or Cautions
progress towands monetary union.
Labour
flat-footed
It's no surprisc Neil
Kinnock and his cronies were delighted that the Thatcherite Major won rather than Michael Heseltine, whose policien on education and the economy are so close to the latest "new realist' nonsense served up from Walworth Road.
Yet Labour has little to celebrate. The Tories have ditched Thatcher as an clectoral liability and
Graeme Cookson
scrapping the Poll Tax altogether, and returning to some form of rates systen. wouid pruve humiliating in the exireme, or even trigger a new Thatcherite backlash inside the Tory Party
Another problem is that none of the options, other than pump- ing in new money from central government, could be imple- mented quickly enough to affect Poll Tax bills for 1991, leaving the issue a serious embarrassment up to the next election.
The best scenario for Major I seems to be to exploit his few months "honeymoon" penod using Heseltine as a decoy to trick voters intr believing a wholesale Poll Tax review is hap pening, and to go for an early clection, possibly exploiting the first jingoistic echoes of a war in the Gulf, before public revulsion grows as the body count rises.
Europe
An early election would also
crealed the (temporary) impres sion of a new government. Major will be a much harder target for a labour leadership that has almost
no attractive policies of its own to offer, and has relied instead on becoming the biggest 'moderate" opposition to Thatcher's ex- tremism.
In this situation, even sections. of Labour's right wing are now waking up to the fact that Kin- nock as leader is a liability, Ac- tivists who had gone along with the Policy Review will become more aware that in ditching con troversial policies, the Kinnock- iten have thrown out the haby with the bathwater, leaving little to attract the extra votes they need.
The hard left will find new opportunities to follow through the struggle against new realism. and the fight for a socialist alter- native to Thatchensm and its latest variant - the Majorettes.