Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

German socialists debate the way forward

· Socialist Outlook no. 24, May 1990 · pp 13-14 · 2,083 words

Germany War and peace

FEATURES

vard

441

Ohne

verde

"Even people who built workers' councils in the factories voted CDU"

way

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK recently interviewed three socialists from East and West Germany on the meaning of the elections in the GDR.

PATRICK BAKER spoke to BJORN KRUGER, a member of the Fourth International and the United Left (VL) in East Berlin; ANNETTE SEESE, a member of the VL in Leipzig: and LARS STEINAU, a member of the United Socialist Party (VSP) from Mannheim in West Germany.

for

SO: First, why do you think the Chris- tian Democratic Union (CDU) ended up scoring so much higher than the Social Democratic Party (SPD), when a few weaks bafore the opposite result was predicted?

BK: There was no general difference be- tween the election programmes of the SPD and the CDU. The only difference was that the CDU said that unification had to be car-

ried through as soon as possible. People tended to think that the only way of solving East Germany's problems was to unify with

waS.

West Germany in order to get their standard

get ther tamar of living. So they felt that to acheive this they had to vote for the party in charge in West Germany - the CDU. They had a very clever election campaign - saying 'If you vote SPI), you won't get a plennig to invest in the GDR

UL..

West Germany in order to get their standard

economy

AS: TI

AS: The right also campaigned around the

were

members of the Socialist Unity Party (SED - the East German Communist Party); so if you vote SPD. you are voting for your previous

SO: Didn't the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS) - the renamed Communist Party - do quite well, considering their image?

BK: Since February fears have heen grow

ing over the cost that East Germans are going to have to pay for unification

ADIE CHI

•y Part, (SEr Party Ir

LE

such as the

high cost of foodstuffs. For many, voting PDS was a way of expressing their fears of the fu- ture.

SO: In the media you could see a lot of these Page 11

fears being expressed: unemployment, rants going up, property being repossessed; given that, which seems quite a popular feeling. It's still quite surprising that more people didn't vote for the parties that made some pretence at trying to defend previous gains.

AS: I think that there's a certain amount of irrationality at the moment: there's a very popular argument that said "We must gu through this bad period, bocause then our economy will be healthy, and than should be logical and vale for the party that can carry this through. We shoukin't make the mistake af prolonging this agony Even people who built workers" councils in the fac sories also voted CDU.

BK: I think the result of the election simp- ly shows the extent of polarisation in the population. Most people who voted CDU didn't do so out of devotion for Christian democracy but simply because they thought that they had to accept some short-term nega- tive effects to get a West German standard of living in the long term. But these people are not an electoral base that could he counted on in the long, or even medium, term. In the next cloctions 1 think that we can expoct hig swings.

SO: Why do you think New Forum did so badly compared with the level of support that it had in October/November during the big demonstrations in Leipzig? Opinion polls

1n

then gave tham 40 percent support, but they won only 2-3 percent in the elections.

AS: They didn't do much work around the

• mine work around the

elections - they didn't have good slogans like

the CDU or SPD. People said "Yes, New

Forum is good, but if they won the elections

they couldn't get our country out of its crisis.

Also, at the beginning of the demonstrations,

the name New Forum could mean many

things to many people - a discussion forum,

dn't get our

-m. New Fores

in many people ~ governmer:

Al ihe first meetings in the factories when thicy were invited, workers asked What is

mic poucy. and they replied We don't have one - we want to work one out

with you." Workers were incredulous - they vit take scridsly a group which did not have an economic programme. What New

ell-activity - and

BK: There was a view that New Forum

had no political profile at all, they are too

heterogencous. Then as people swung increas-

ingly in favour of unification, they felt that

they had to vote for West German-style par-

ties. The ones who didn't agree with that

tended to vote for the party that opposed

unification and had the strongest apparatus -

and that wasn't New Forum, it was the PDS.

This also affected the VL - people said it might have a good programme, but it's too weak, so we'll vote PDS.

was not... ..2л.

BK: There was a www

.. proti

w. har.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990

FEATURES

SO: In terms of the results of the elections, It seems as though some form of govarn- ment led by the COU will be the result, whether it's a coalition or whatever. What do you think the results of this will be?

AS: I think the process of unification will be speeded up. However, although the CDU

•h ThA CDU have won the political leadership, they haven't built up a proper political structure nation- wide. The Social Democrats have more of a real base. I think that the CDU and the SPD will work together to ensure an efficient cconomic in tegration - that's why the CDU need the SPD in coali- tion; they have the ap- paratus, but they didn't have 50 much influence before.

BK: I think this is a question that is difficult to answer - even for the CDU: the pace is too rapid even for them. We now have two Germanys, one with a standard of ving and productivity half as high as the other. In order to prevent a mass exodus. standards of living have to be raised through a massive investment in the infrastruc- ture. But you won't find many capitalists that want to invest in projects which are Insecure.

SO: One question this raises is that of NATO and the Warsaw Pact. A few months ago there was a poll over the idea of a neutral Germany which showed majority support in the West and 90% in the East. NATO is now in a much stronger position with a sym- pathetic government. Has this been taken up in East or West Germany by the peace movement?

BK: In East Germany there is no force which is capable of mobilising powerful op-

position to the project of a unified Germany in position wi the prajec.

NATO yet Of course the Russians will op pose it but I'm sceptical about whether they are in a position to do anything about it - and I don't chink that the project of a neutral Ger- many will be a particular focus. Of course in the next period there will be many struggles, but I think they are likely to be straightfor- ward workers' struggles - workers have other issues to care about hefore disarmament.

LS: I think that the question of disarma- ment will be very important. I think that there could he a new peace movement in West Ger

As: The GDR extreme right an import from the Republikaner - we have our own fascists! In December and January there were attempts by the SED/Stasi to rebuild their base, using our anti-fascist tradi- hons. Many people reacted by dismik.

nAVE

demonstrations, women began to play an im- portant role and organised a women's group in New Forum. Then they formed an inde.

pendent organisation, participating in the

round table discussions and putting forward

pendent organisation, participating in the round table discussions and putting forward

extreme right as solely propaganda. But there is a real danger young whites have certainly been physically attacking the "Autonom" squatters' movement, and other young left-wingers; they have also

SED election

quite left-wing policies.

But popular consciousness around the

issue isn't very high - the groups are mainly

composed of academics, However I think there are possibilities of growth. In the elec- tions they allied with the Greens - but because

the Greens were at the top of

cach list, they got all

deputies, and refused to allot

any of these sests to the

women. The warmen have left

the alliance as a result

Women's

sue 1ST " VETV

the alliance as a result

Women's groups from

Berlin have joined the United

Left while still organising in-

dependently. Lesbian and gay

groups exist - independent,

and linked to the church or

the

very consistently. Under the

SED lesbian and gay groups

weren• prescribed, hut

couldn't campaign publicly -

now they're becoming mare

oper.

SO: What has been the reac-

tion of the left in West Ger-

many to the elections? What

is the VSP's perspactive?

LS: The movement of Oc-

tober/November caused quite a lot of

demoralisation - much of the West German

left had a 'campist position - not just the CP.

but ex-maoists, Social Democrats, the Greens.

They tended to defend the East European states in gencral - not just against capilalism.

but also defending them as a whole. hureaucracy included. The movement in the GDR destroyed this picture - and now there is capitalist restoration, the growth of the tas

cists, the perspoctive of a new "Greater wests the perspoctin Germany". and so on. At the start of the mass movement against stalinism in the GDR he

lei didn't really react - didn't give much sup-

port. Now there is a discussion over whether

.. over whether

the PDS will organise in West Germany -

some of the Greens hope in organise with them and win influence!

East German COU leader Maziere: cannot deliver on electoral promises

many, much more radical than in the carly 1980s. I think that it will be important for the East Germans too - maybe it's true that at the moment people don't see it as the main issue. hut I think there's an opportunity to build up an anti-militarist consciousness.

SO: is the extreme right, which seems to be fuelled by the Republikaner, a real threat? SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990

tried to take over demonstrations. Still, we're not in a 1933-type situation - they don't have the economic situation to fuel their support in

the same way.

SO: What are the perspectives of the United Left after the elections?

BK: The clection results had disastrous ef- Eccts on the VL. From the beginning it made the error of orienting almost exclusively to the clections. The results of those elections left those nat had workea aroun demoralised. But the strategy hasn't changed

now the VL is concentrating on the May 7 local elections, which will have the same result - with a real danger of splits or dissolu-

tion. T think it's important to adjust our ac-

tivity towards real movements - in the

workplaces, around peace and ecology, and so

on - lowards grassroots activists.

AS: In Leipzig we have heen meeting with other groups - New Forum, Democracy Now.

tion. I think

workolac

01534/1

women's groups - to discuss how we can work together on a local level. Most workers aren't open to left groups, so 1 think we need to try to work with other groups around par-

ticular issues?

SO: Can you say something about the women's and lesbian and gay movements in East Germany?

AS: Before there was only the DFD - the

Women's Democratic Alliance - which only

organised coffee mornings, and small groups

round particular issues. But dun

• atrecica inc support unis move

ne wrong side reaucracy as well

snare was some

hesitation, and lack of clarity. I think some of the VSP will want to build an organisation with the United Left: it remains to be seen on what programme. We need to prepare for the

InK some of an organisann

to ne seen on prepare for the unk there are

ann-militarist

struggles that will come - I think there are particular possibilities around anti-militarist

work - perhaps something like the Swiss cam-

paign to abolish the army:

Swiss cam-

Page 12

← Slovo's retreat from stalinism · Crisis in Jerusalem as Bush turns on the pressure →

Something wrong on this page?