Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Slovo's retreat from stalinism

· Socialist Outlook no. 24, May 1990 · pp 11-12 · 2,001 words

Stalinism South Africa Russia and the USSR Trotsky

FEATURES

The release of Nelson Mandela has generated a new debate within the anti-apartheid forces on the framework and objective of talks with De Klerk. In this context, the changing political line of the South African Communist Party can prove a decisive factor in the politics of the African National Congress. CHARLIE VAN GELDEREN reports on the latest pronouncements by the SACP's leader, JOE SLOVO.

The South Aircan Communist Party (SACP) has, for most of its existence, firmly and uncritically adhered lo the general line coming from Moscow. Until very recently, its successive programmes were either dictated by Moscow or sub- jected to veto there. The Path to Power. adopted at the 7th Congress last year was probably the first "native" programme in its history.

The whole of the present leadership of the party and its predecessors alter the expulsion of R.P. Bunting in the early 1930s were in doctrinated with Stalinist, revisionist concep- tions of Marxism, the first principles of which was that the Soviet Communist Party (CPSU) were always right in doctrinal and practical matters. What it said had to be accepted without question.

In the 1920s, when Trotsky and the Left Opposition were being persecuted in the Soviet Union, the SACP expelled everyone who even mildly hinted of support for Trotsky. After the Sixth Congress of the Com- intern, when Stalin proclaimed the Third Period' which signalled a sharp turn to ultra- leftism and presaged Stalin's break within Bukharin, it started a witch hunt for "Right Oppositionists'. Where none existed they in- vented them. Thus, ultra-loyal stalinists, like the trade union leader Solly Sachs, were sum- marily thrown out of the Party. Under the Jeadership of the Moscow-appointed Douggie and Molly Wolton, oppositionists wete even

Page 9

MANDELA MUSTRUCEDUR,

ZOUNTAI

SACP politics have always bean a kay factor in the line of the African National Congress

physically assaulited.

When war broke our in September 1939. the SACP correctiy declared it an imperialist war, and were even prepared to work joinily with the Afrikaner nationalists to resist South African participation. Fascism, it said, had to be fought at home. This all changed on 22 June 1941, when German troops crussed the Saviet frontier. The Party now called for the defence of the socialist homeland, whose vic tory would bring about the destruction of las- cism, the liberation of oppressed nations and a rapid transition to world socialism.

The SACP was used by Moscow to signal its break with Popular Frontism after the war. Later came the 1950s show trials of Laszio Rajk and Rudolf Slansky, the invasion of Hungary (1956) and the exccution of Imry Nagy; the crushing of the 'Prague Spring (1968) by Sovict tanks; all were endorsed with the same enthusiasm with which in the 1920s they acclaimed the trials and murder of the Bolshevik leaders Zinovicy, Kamener. Bukharin and others.

Backing glasnost

It is against this background that we have to look at the pamphlet Has Socialism Failed? by Joe Slavo, the current General Secretary of the South African Communist Party. In this document, Slovo unreservedly lines himself up with Gorbachev, perestroika and glasnost. The question we have to ask ourselves is: is this a genuine and decisive break with his self-confessed stalinist past? Or is the SACP just running true to form, and once again fol- lowing the Moscow line?

It is, of course, impossible to give an in- controvertible answer to this. As Lenin once temarked, a "sincerometer' has not yet been invented. To discuss his motives would be un- profitable, so we will confine ourselves to ca-

amining just how far he has gone and what this means for the future of the SACP in the South African political scene.

Slovo titles his document Has Socialism

Failed? which would seem to indicate that he

still equates stalinism with socialism. This

theme recurs throughout the document. Thus

he constantly refers to 'existing socialism':

produced a Stalin

lone produce

Ceaucescu" and on page 3 he defines

"Stalinism' as 'the bureaucratic-authoritarian

style of leadership (of parlies both in and out of power) which denuded the party and the practice of socialism of most of its democratic conteni...' What he does not yet grasp is that where there is no democracy in state and party, there can be no socialism.

Stalin proclaimed the 'complete triumph" of socialism as long ago as January 1931 and the SACP dutifully echoed this, as did all its fraternal parties throughout the world. The lying statistics emanating from the stalinist school of falsification which depicted the ever-growing prosperity and happiness of the Soviet people was swallowed wholesale not only by Party members but by a host of fel- low-travellers like the Webbs and Bernard Shaw.

inism

Slovo now recognises that even where

there was growth in the Soviet economy, the

methods employed resulted only in human

misery. Slovo could have saved himself years of travail if he had the moral courage to break from iron stalinist discipline and read, among other. Trotsky. who wrote. in 1936: *Socialism is a structure of planned produc- tion to the end of the best satisfaction of human noods; otherwise it does not deserve the name of socialism" (The Revolution Betrayed p.64).

Slovo writes that self-pity is not enough.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990

FEATURES

Slovo's document is of course to be wel-

say "we were why were we

not enough to deceived' hut also to ask

deceived?. He accepts that the decades of stalinist-bureaucratic rule brought horror and misery to the Soviet people and to the people of Eastern Europe. But he puts it all down to the subjective factor. The wrong people, wick-

stalinism, the utopian, revisionist

• Wach #Martist 2i...us

the

Slovo's document is of course to be wel- comed, although it should be appreciated that it is not an official statement of SACP policy.

arse to be wel- ne appreciated that

•SACP poliev.

No eases. Slova

When refering to these states

amsisten

und

In raising the sort of questions he does, Slovo

opens the way for the possibility of a real

debate on the way forward for the South African revolution. But his critique of Stalinism is in line with the general trend of "Eurocommunism", and part of its aim was

popular democracy (sic) and strengthen the

vanguard revolutionary party. It claims that

the victorious revolution in Mozambique and

ed people were in power. He ignores com-

Angola set the stage for development towards false thcoretical foundation of

BARTE ST

WE

AND STANU

BY BE

LEADE IDERS LEADERS

The question is where the leaders stand now?

socialist construction". Since then of course.

the

contradication

m was

SACP

on i tho

"n Pretori»

belief that socialism could be es- tablished in one country.

policy in 1926 at the Sixth Con- gress of the Communist Interna- tional which transformed the

It was the adoption of this

Comintem from влеті world proletarian revolution, as Lenin

2s Le1.... and Trotsky conceived it, into a border guard for the USSR. Its main role as an instrument of

world revolution was inevitably

background.

regime in May.

heing the

Further there is one aspect of Stalinism which rejectod in either Siova's docu-

Lic 3L0eE

one aspoc

is nol

- docu- exy programme - ~ me twu-stage

- the uncory

tells us, there has to be a 'na-

tional democratic' revolution in alliance with the nationalists. and then later. - perhaps much later - a socialist revalution. And anyway Siovo now thinks that

democratic process!.

world revolution was inevitably

the From then on, the Communist Parlies: became instruments to implement the policies and inter-

wold revi.

to

wu now

ula evolv-

through

ess of the ruling bureaucracies in the Kremlin. Local party

peacefully

111

SAUP

of a special type and which theorises the ex- istence of an oppressor while nation and and oppressed black nation. Not only is this in

with programme itself states that South Africa has a developed capitalist economy, but il also Nies in the face of the proclaimed aim of the

leaderships which did not blindly follow the line as dictated in Moscow were uncercmuniously ousted.

A vanguard party?

de

This theory justifies the

SACP's definition of South African society as colonialism

fact

Bn:

Slovo deals very well with a number of is- sues of great importance to the future of the international communist movement and of special importance to developments in Africa. He claims that in some instances the SACP

has openly ahandoned socialist path, and. just as it once proclaimed

Itself Marxist/Leninist, has now disowned the

title. The ruling clique in Benin has also decided that it is no longer Marxist/Leninist and the Mengistu tegime in Ethiopia has

that

anticipated glasnost. This applies particularly lo the conception of the vanguard role of the CP. He urgues that the programme of the SACP adopted in 1989 Palk to Power sup- ports his position thal a communist party does nut earn the title of vanguard mercly by

But is this really the case? In the introduc-

replaced Cuhan and East European mihtary

Slovo, in his document, is somewhat criti

The

cal of one-party states and wimits that "in both

capitalist and socialist-oriented countries... it

is used to prevent, among other things, the democratic organisation of working people in

advisors with Israelis.

"colonialism of a special type theory is a mir- nur image of Verwoerd's grand apartheid, which thenrised the existence of different nationalities, ind which provided his rationale for the establishment of the Bantustans.

In South Africa today, the struggle for na- tional and democratic demands predominates. But the workers, now powerfully organised in trade unions playing an increasingly leading role, will advance their own class and socialist demands within that struggle. Indeed many of the COSATU unions are putting forward tran-

sitional, socialist demands.

struggle for national and democratic

and the

socialism are not separate but com-

Apartheid in its present naked

proclaiming it:

tion to the programme, we find The national offensive is led by the African National Con- gress in revolutionary alliance with the van guard workers' party - the South African Communist Party...

Communist Party is the leading politi cal force of the South African working class."

which deals with developments in the

either political or trade union organisations

But his criticism is not whole-hearted This is not to say that all one party states in our coniment have in fact tumed out to be authoritarian: indeed some of them are headed

shi.

by the most humane leaders who passionately

And on page 2 The believe in the democratic process but ap-

"his critique of Stalinism is in line with the general demands

trend of "Eurocommunism', and part of its aim was

In that section of the programme probably to make the SACP more acceptable to join bined

in the negotiations with the Pretoria regime"

independent African states, the as-

form can and will be ended withoul

the end of capitalism. But the full

¡calisation of national and democratic

parently not passionalely enough to permit

their people a free choice of govemment. demands can only be achieved by the victory

After all. Kaunda, Joe Slovo's host in Zamhia.

is one of the benevolent heads of a one-party

state, and Zimbabwe's Mugabe, who has now

declared his Murxis/luminism and is deter- socialism succeeds or fails.

mined to establish a one party state, is a closc

sumed status of "vanguard party' is re emphasised time and again: "...though small in number the African working class is crucial to any radical social transformation bat it can only play its revolutionary role to the full if it is...organised... under the guidance of Marxism/Leninism ...depending on the actual social and political situation in cach country the vanguard revolutionary forces will assume * variety of organisational forms, the highest ally of the ANC SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990

The struggle for

of the working class: the establishment of a workers' state in South Africa. Then we will have the chance to lest out if genuine

Page 10

← A Fair Cop? · German socialists debate the way forward →

Something wrong on this page?