EATURES
Ish
Two issues in the last six months have
XXX
risis in Jerusalem as
brought the crisis within Zionism to the fore. The first was when news broke of a mass immigration by Jews from the
USSR 0 Isracl, which the Zionists
heralded as a rebirth of what was fast be- coming a dying project.
However, the cuphoria was quickly muted
after the second major new event the collapse
th
of the coalition goveriment of the Labour and
Likul Parties, as a result of the failure of the two bloes to reach agreement on conditions for
1 El arar
ekic Purtm
Israeli-Palestinian talks scheduled to open in Cairo with American and Egyptian: backing This highlights the crucial relationship be- twcen the Zionist State and US imperialism, as well as sharply illustrating the squahhlex be twcen the main factions of the Zimist leader ship over who will best defend Israel's in
The temporary unity of the two ruling par ties, which extended through the whole Zionist camp. was the consequence of great expecta
will A: tegrity as a Jewish state.
tions over the influx of Soviet Jews; some analysts have estimated that there will be around 300,000 new arrivals in the next three years. But discord arose when Likud Prime
Minister Yitzhak Shamir declared that "a large
By Benjamin Cohen
Ot . erar miero.
most the Soviet Umon
threatened to change its emigration policy, the
US wared that it would not finance settle- ment beyond the 1967 green line', and the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). together with the Arab states, announced a campaign to oppose the immigration.
The link made in Shamir's mind is ob vious: he thinks that the Soviet Jews are the means by which the occupsed West Bank and Gaza Strip can be annexed, the two and a half
"intifada")
year old Palestiman uprising (the
crushed, and Israel's regional strength con-
solidatod. Additionally, the threat of 1 mass
transfer of Palestinians to neighbouring Arab States, an idea which has gained ground over
williSI
immediately,
the last two years, is increasingly real.
But Shamir's hardline stance was never
enough for Industry Minister Ariel Sharon, ar- chitect of the 1982 Lebanon invasion and
1 the
Likud's arch hawk. who quit the government
in protest at Shamir's readiness to negoliate with personally selected representatives of the Palestinians. Ironically, this came in the wake of Labour Minister Ever Weizmann's dismiss- al irom the cabmet for unauthorised contacts with the PLO. Sharon, who has made his dis- gust at the "moderation' of the eccupation
Likud's arch hawk. who quit the government
231176N
his came Woreman unauthoris who
regime in its handling of the intifada quite
clear, argued that negotiations would lead in-
evitably in a Palestinian state.
Labour, meanwhile, stepped up the pres- sure on Shamir to come to the negotiating
tahle Unable to reach agicement sacked Labour leader Shimon Peres from the government. whereupon the other Labour cahinet ministers resigned. Two days later, a
vate of no confidence was passed in the Knes-
set (parliament), transforming Shamir into a
caretaker Prime Minister. On April 11th a
special session of the Knesset was held to
ratify Peres's government, which he formed
after several days of bartering with the
religious fundamentalists and the right. At the
last minute, two rabbis withdrew their voles. and Peres was back to square one.
It was American pressure which tore the
coalition apart; the government was unable to
reach agreement on acceptance of the Baker
plan for Isracli-Palestinian talks. The US is
keen to maintain the stability of the Zionist
state and neutralise the Palestinian resistance,
ugh a diplomatic process framed in
Washington and Jerusalem that requires hefty
concessions from the Palestinians.
An Isracli government actively involved in helping to secure these aims would he a ter-
Pi
Page 13
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
FEATURES rific boost ta the Bush administration, which
full advantage of the crisis of
has taken -talm
som their Palestinian wowm
.Deraz iving standards an.. w in Pisnism (m the last unirteen vears
neen expreseed In a vou tho ..zhr
and the religious parties). However, -ompar..› the situation of Ashken it become» wiear that working cla»» have had a rough dear chrough...
•.. the Zioni.. stat- With unem in Israel now standing at 120,000, the Oriental Jews am mginnina to exorer vano-
entry visas, campaigning instead for direct flights between Moscow and Tel Aviv. In
keeping with the demands of Zionist colonisa-
tion, Israel is not interested in fighting anti-
semitism, whether it comes from Pamyat
whose thugs only recently assaulted a Jewish
woman in Moscow, carving a Sur of David
onto her breast with a flicknife, or from within
stalinism to reassert US glahal dominance. Im- portantly, this does not mean bypassing the PLO, with whom the US has engaged in shaky dialogue since late 1988, when Yasser Arafat declared his acceptance of the "two state' solu- tion. The US State Department has realised that there is no alternative Palestinian Icader- ship to the PLO. Whether the PLO will accept a pax americana is already a subject of debate for the movement inside and outside Palestine: the US is chiefly con-
PLO, with whom the US has engaged in shaky dialogue since late 1988, when Yasser Arafat
i'vE ser Arafar
thee
when
In Moscow..-
iet harass with -". the state apparatus.
Peres himself admitted as much when he
said that the issue was not anti-semitism, but
emigration. This statement
came a lew days after
Panva threatened
pogrom against the Jewish
community in Leningrad.
It may soem odd, in the
light of the compression of
more than two years of
crisis into threc weeks,
that the issuc currently
mobilising Israclis is elec-
toral reform. Peres's iran-
tic efforts to build a new
government aroused
huge public protest against
the country's system of
proportional tepre-
sentation, which grants a
scat in the Knesset to
every party that gams onc
percent of the vote.
On April 8, 100,000
people gathered in Tel
Aviv to demand a new electoral system - Israel's biggest demonstra• tion since the Peace Now Tally condemning the massacres at the Sabra and Shatilla refugee camps in Beirut in 1982, and much bigger than any of the demonstrations held in solidarity with the intifada. Certainly, the large parties would have much to gain if clectoral reform was realised: but the protests are not expres sions of support for either Labour or Likud. Rather, they signify the anger fell by Israelis; the majority of whom are secular, at the dis. proportionate influence of the religious parties, whose support the main Zionist biocs have desperately been trying to win.
Yet abolition of the one percent tiresnoid would, in all likelihood, lead to the disap- pearance of the Arab national lists from the Knesset. In essence, it is not electoral proce dure that is at fault, but the institutionalised power of the rabbis in the Zamist state.
Whatever the outcome of the next few
months, two basic facts will remain un- manged. Firstly, the tension between diplomatic and revolutionary solutions to the
question of Palestine will continue to
disrupt the equilibrium of Zionism.
Secondly, as long as there is a Pales-
tinian people there will he a demand
for a Palestinian state: every day that
passes in the West Bank and Gaza
Strip is a reminder of this.
tism, whether it comes som ie thugs only recently assaulted un in Mrerow: carvine a Star
Palestine: the US is chiefly con- cerned with gaining support from its Zionist alV 10° Sin such diplomatic moves. Pores has always been keen to present himself as a trusted friend of the US, although Washington is hesitant as to whether he will deliver.
The unfolding crisis in the'/ionist State, which is accentuated by its in creasingly uncasy alliance with US Imperialism, simultancously opens up new vistas for the class struggle in the region. The most important factor is. of course ine intifada which, despite periodic warnings to the contrary in the media, shows no sign ve letting .. Also of sig- nificance is the growing resentment felt by the underprivileged strata in
Isracli society towards the Soviet Jewish immigrants.
diet see Soviet
STATE Celebrating the first year of the initifada: demonstrators in London
ments could well transform the na- ture of the conflict in Palestine beyond the nar- row framework of diplomacy. The very fact of the intifada means that Palestinian statchood is not something which can be compromised. In- deed, the structures that direct the intifada ate those of a state in the making; a state, moreover, whose citizens, through the struggle of the last two years, will have ample oppor cunity to consolidate the popular institutions of direct democracy which they themselves have created.
The intilada is also the principal energy source of the PLO, and it has served as a model to the working class in the surrounding Arab states (witness m vear's uprising against IMF imposed cuts in Hashemite-ruled Jordan, and the mass demonstrations, brutally crushed, in Algeria in 1988). Yet Isracl has remained intransigent, and the principle ques- tion now facing the Zionists is how long such
/ Inno a stance can be maintained.
One indicator is the internal struggle in 1s rael itself, which gruphically exposes the con
tradictions of Zionism. Most perceive it as an
ethnic battle, between the dominant
Ashkenazi (European Jewish) minority and the subordinate Oriental majority
In fact. it is a class struggle, albeil with
strong cthnic overtones, and it is one
enoses the cor
- Meer De-
influx of Soviet Jewish immigrants. Matipen. the newspaper of the Revolutionary Com munist League (Israeli Section of the Fourth International), notes:
The massive immigration from the Soviet Union will arouse an outburst of fury from the inhabitants of the distressed neighbourhoods and the devclopment towns...
Unrest amongst the Oriental Jews, which would follow in a militant tradition that goes back to the 1950s, is the last thing the Zionists need. But that in itself will not solve the prob lem of Soviet Jews. It should be remembered that in the 1970s, Soviet Jews, facing a fresh wave of anti-semitism. provided the US with an important bargaining chip in its dealings with the stalinists. Gorbachev's leniency on emigration is, though. a consequence of the new foreign policy required for perestroika;
the issue is not so much whether the USSR will allow Jews out, as who will let them in.
Despite the fact that most Soviet Jews want
to go not to israel but to the US, the Zionists
have succeeded in persuading the Amencans to maintain the racist policy of not granting
SONg wan which disprays nature of the Isracli working class.
As a working - ass Nom colonial Drocess Ista.
"the structures that direct the intifada are those
of a state in the making; a state, moreover,
whose citizens will have ample opportunity to
consolidate the popular institutions of direct democracy which they themselves have created"
passer Strin:
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 24, May 1990
Page 14