Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Oppose the Bill, fight for women's choice

· Socialist Outlook no. 22, March 1990 · p 12 · 1,081 words

Women

The problem is that unlike with previous attempts, they haven' got the option of voting against the whole Bill at the end of it. Q. What are the next steps for the cam- paign?

A. Firstly, there's the week of action, which seems to be going well.

Then there's the issue of writing to MPs, petitioning. This will have an impact because a lot of MPs don't know what to think as yet.

Then we've discussed the question of a national demonstration when the bill gets to committee stage - we're aiming at some time in May I think - though I wasn't at that meet- ing.

Q. What is the state of the local groups?

There are groups in most areas now. They are either STAC or NAC or CADI. Only two groups that I know of have a position on the Embryo Bill itself, and I think that's right be- cause it's divisive at this stage to take a posi- tion on the whole Bill, like they have in North London and Leicester. But I think STAC groups should link up with CADI and if there isn't a CADI group then they should take up the other amendments.

Q. What about the national demonstra- tion - do you think that should be on the

Issue of DI and abortion rights?

A. Yes, I think the demonstration should

be joint - on reproductive rights - and I think

we could get backing on that basis.

Q. What is your own personal view on the

Embryo Bill itself?

I think people have made a mistake in

FEATURES

American women demonstrate for Choice

a licensing authority does not necessarily

benefit women, it lays them open to exploita-

tion and individual clinics can and do dis-

criminate. The problem with the Bill is that it

has no positive rights for women, for the

consumer.

To a certain extent this will be dealt with

by the amendments. If you have an amend

ment saying that treatment will be restricted

to married women and it fails, then this will

affect practice after the Bill if passed and

women will be able to go to the courts if they

suffer discrimination. But this is not adequate

- we need positive rights. The only grounds

for restricting access should be medical.

conflating the amend- ments to the bill with the Bill itself - as if they were already through.

I believe that the Bill is an improvement on the Warnock Committee report: it specifically uses the words "if the woman is married" - not assuming that she is. We should put our energies into improving the Bill rather than opposing it.

But it does give the secretary of state too much power to appoint the statutory licensing authority - it is too bureaucratic and they are not accountable enough to parliament.

Also the licensing authority has to be self- financing which means that the cost of treat-

ment will go up because they will have to charge for licensing.

But having said all that I think it has a

good definition of what a parent is, it has

good rights for children, and the correct type

of restrictions on research. It avoids wrangles

over stored embryos like they have had in

Australia over inheritance etc.

The Bill also provides for counselling. I

think non-directive counselling is very im-

portant in such a new field.

In the US they have found that not having

Tory thinking behind the

Embryology Bill

was defeated 61:60 in the House of Lords

Superficially the Embryo Bill may appear to cover an ill-assorted collection of sub- jects, from embryo research to surrogacy, from highly scientific In Vitro fertilisa- tion (IVF) to low-technology Donor In- semination (DI). However, it is a coherent legal and political project for the Tories.

It represents an attempt to group together all forms of reproduction other than heterosexual intercourse, and place them under govemment control. It even attempts to plan for future, as it brings the forms of re- search most likely to develop new reproduc- tive techniques under similar regulation.

Within this range of reproductive methods, it is DI that has excited most attention so far. Ann Winterton MP tabled an Early Day Mo- tion at the end of October last year, asking the goverment to ban provision of DI to lesbians and single women. Lady Saltoun proposed an amendment to the Embryology Bill to prohibit access to Di for all unmarried women, which Page 10

Committee stage last month. Further dis- criminating amendments are promised for the House of Commons.

The debate in the House of Lords made it quite clear why DI has been the main target for these attacks - because Di is seen as being furthest outside the framework of the nuclear family, particularly given the actual or social fatherlessness of children born as a result of DI. As the Earl of Lauderdale so bluntly put it *AID (Artificial Insemination by Donor) is the farmyard, like it or not, but AIH (Artificial In- semination by Husband) is the house'.

Lord Ashbourne underlined this in a very explicit speech about the "family as the fun- damental unit of society" which must be "but- tressed, supported and built up'. Lord Gis- borough found it bizarre that artificial means should be suggested to encourage lesbian couples or have children ... It takes me back to the 1960's, when licence was given which, in my view, has done immense damage to this

country.

It is important to stress given these attacks and the reasons and forces behind them, that access to DI is an issue for all women, not just those who want or need it. For at the heart of Lady Saltoun's and Ann Winterton's amend- ments, and indeed underlying sections of the Bill itself, is the wish to control who can and cannot have children. Some groups of women

single women, lesbians are to be categorised in law as unfit mothers; a measure that can only encourage further prejudice and discrimination in wider society.

This is a fundamental denial of women's rights to control our bodies, just as restrictions on abortion rights are, and must be opposed by all women on this basis. We need to ensure that campaigning over Access to Donor In- semination is supported by feminists and socialists and taken into the labour movement as part of the fight for a Woman's Right to Choose.

Rebecca Fleming SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

← Fighting the amendment · Gorbachev plays Bonaparte →

Something wrong on this page?