Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Fighting the amendment

· Socialist Outlook no. 22, March 1990 · pp 9-10 · 961 words

This article was cut at the top of the page the printed contents gives it, because its title was too short to locate in the text. Its opening may carry the end of the article before it.

Now that the Embryology and Fertilisation Bill has reached the closing stages of discussion in the House of Lords, campaigners are preparing for its entrance to the Commons. Socialist Outlook asked Leonora Lloyd, a leading member of Stop the Amendment Campaign (STAC) and the National Abortion Campaign (NAC) for her views on the issues and debates now coming up and what activists should be doing.

Q. What is the current situation in parliament?

A. The third reading will be on March 6th and 12th in the House of Lords. Then it is two weeks before the Bill can go the Commons, which will be further delayed by the Easter recess. I think that the major amendments will come up in the House of Commons.

Q. What do you think is the most likely outcome?

A. Well, there are three areas really.

Firstly, possibility that all embryo research will be banned or in the context of the Bill, permitted up to 14 days. I think the pro-lifers could lose on this. MPs have had lots of letters expressing support for research and against a total ban (nought days). Tony Benn's office certainly has.

The amendment to prevent access by single women was defeated in the Lords by one vote: this is a very open issue and MPs haven't made up their minds yet, so there's a lot of work to be done and I'm not convinced that the Campaign for Access to Donor Insemination (CADI) is doing it all.

On the abortion time limits issue, Anne Widdicombe says she's confident of winning on 22, or 20 weeks even, but I think she's over-confident. The consensus is for 24 weeks and I think we'll find that hard to stop. It's going to be a tactical question for MPs, we can't just sling slogans around.

It all depends in which order the vote is taken. If they start the vote at 18 weeks and then go up, the lower limits might get defeated. Then the anti-abortionists might vote against the 24 weeks on the grounds that it doesn't go far enough. But if they start the other way 'round, many MPs will feel the need to vote tactically for 24 weeks to stop lower time limits getting through. There are very few Labour MPs who are prepared to stick to the present 28 weeks limit.

The problem is that unlike with previous attempts, they haven' got the option of voting against the whole Bill at the end of it.

Q. What are the next steps for the campaign?

A. Firstly, there's the week of action, which seems to be going well.

Then there's the issue of writing to MPs, petitioning. This will have an impact because a lot of MPs don't know what to think as yet.

Then we've discussed the question of a national demonstration when the bill gets to committee stage – we're aiming at some time in May I think – though I wasn't at that meeting.

Q. What is the state of the local groups?

There are groups in most areas now. They are either STAC or NAC or CADI. Only two groups that I know of have a position on the Embryo Bill itself, and I think that's right because it's divisive at this stage to take a position on the whole Bill, like they have in North London and Leicester. But I think STAC groups should link up with CADI and if there isn't a CADI group then they should take up the other amendments.

Q. What about the national demonstration – do you think that should be on the issue of DI and abortion rights?

A. Yes, I think the demonstration should be joint – on reproductive rights – and I think we could get backing on that basis.

Q. What is your own personal view on the Embryo Bill itself?

I think people have made a mistake in conflating the amendments to the bill with the Bill itself – as if they were already through.

I believe that the Bill is an improvement on the Warnock Committee report: it specifically uses the words "if the woman is married" – not assuming that she is. We should put our energies into improving the Bill rather than opposing it. But it does give the secretary of state too much power to appoint the statutory licensing authority – it is too bureaucratic and they are not accountable enough to parliament.

Also the licensing authority has to be self-financing which means that the cost of treatment will go up because they will have to charge for licensing.

But having said all that I think it has a good definition of what a parent is, it has good rights for children, and the correct type of restrictions on research. It avoids wrangles over stored embryos like they have had in Australia over inheritance etc.

The Bill also provides for counselling. I think non-directive counselling is very important in such a new field.

In the US they have found that not having a licensing authority does not necessarily benefit women, it lays them open to exploitation and individual clinics can and do discriminate. The problem with the Bill is that it has no positive rights for women, for the consumer.

To a certain extent this will be dealt with by the amendments. If you have an amendment saying that treatment will be restricted to married women and it fails, then this will affect practice after the Bill if passed and women will be able to go to the courts if they suffer discrimination. But this is not adequate – we need positive rights. The only grounds for restricting access should be medical.

← The 'M' factor · Oppose the Bill, fight for women's choice →

Something wrong on this page?