Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Morning Star: desperately seeking readers

· Socialist Outlook no. 22, March 1990 · pp 31-32 · 1,735 words

Trade unions

FEATURES

plete control - refuses to significantly extend

the action.

Only a tiny proportion of the two million

workers previously affected by Confed

negotiations have been called upon to take

any action at all.

Meanwhile, an employers" offensive is pressing ahead on most fronts. In the car in-

dustry, the pressure remains on for flexibility and for participatory techniques such as team leaders.

In the media, the National Union of Jour- nalists (NUJ) faces a massive onslaught. In practically every national newspaper manage- ment are forcing in individual contracts, while resistance has been collapsing following bribes and intimidation by management. The same process is taking place in provincial newspapers. One of the major groups - United Newspapers - has told its journalists in six of its papers to sign individual contracts. Here the fightback is stronger, and the NUJ has become embroiled in a series of long-run- ning disputes. The Union as a whole is on the rack: last year it paid out only £30,000 in strike pay: now it is paying almost that much every week. One such long-running strike is at Robert Maxwell's Pergamon Press, where 23 union members have been sacked for sup- porting an official 24-hour strike. The NUJ is to hold a special conference on fighting derecognition in March.

Behind the employers" offensive is the bat- tery of anti-union laws. The outcome of the industrial struggles last summer was a degree of breakthrough on the wages front, but also the successfull use of the law against the dockers, which put the government in a posi- tion to introduce a further package of legisla tion - Unofjicial Action and the Law designed to tackle the kind of unofficial action, and self organisation, which emerged in the rail unions last summer.

It contains in many ways the most drastic proposals yet, and is essentially an employers' "victimisation charter". Is is aimed against shop stewards and work place reps. The new measures would legally require trade union leaders to take action against unofficial strikers, and disqualifies those sacked for taking part in an unoficial strike from going to a tribunal. This may not seem serious given the lack of powers of the tribunals; but in reality it will encourage employers to vic- timise militants. It would also become illegal to take any kind of action in support of some- one sacked for taking part in an unofficial dis- pute.

There is not a word from the TUC on these develpments let alone any kind of campaign against them. We have to demand that the TUC campaigns against these laws and we have to challenge the Labour leadership to pledge their repeal by a future Labour Goverment.

"Grim truth about Morning

Star'

The troubles afflicting the ruling Com- munict Parties in Eastern Europe have found a faint echo in Britain. While Mar- xism Today has embraced marketisation and pulled the Communist Party of Great Britain with it, the sickly Morning Star looks closer to death than ever.

The Morning Star has announced plans to sack 25 workers and reduce the number of pages by one third in an attempt to survive. The irony is that it is a 50% cut in the paper's "sales' in the USSR which has dealt the latest blow when, in the divisions in the party, a key issue was its commitment to supporting the "socialist countries' uncritically.

It was in the Popular Front period (after 1935) and during the second world war - periods of extremes of class collaborationist policy in which the CP advocated alliances with the "progressive", "anti-fascist bour- geoisie, and then lent their support to Churchill's National Govemment in its war drive after 1941 - that the CP and its daily paper, established in 1930, saw their greatest growth. Since 1945 both have been locked into a long decline, membership of the party falling to less than a seventh of its peak level.

The paper had less than a fifth of its peak sales even before the cut in the Moscow order.

There was only the occasional hiccup in the downward trend, and the apparently trium- phant adoption of the latest British Road To Socialism was associated with a deepening of the crisis. The BRS mixed rhetoric about class struggle and socialism with a stress on democracy, reliance on parliament and the election of a left Labour government.

Both sides in the subsequent dispute have claimed to be the inheritors of the tradition of this programme. In reality the BRS passed in 1977 was a compromise, and was eventually supported by "democrats" like Marxism Today editor Martin Jacques and party bureaucrats like Mick Costello so as not allow the party to fall into each other's hands. Only a small minority remained in outright opposition.

It was significant that the CP Executive Committee was defeated at Congress for the first time ever in the same year, and the issue was the Morning Star. It was attacked for in- sufficient sharpness politically in its coverage of events in the labour movement, It was also insufficiently critical in its approach to the "socialist countries" and, increasingly impor- tantly, failed to give sufficient attention to

COMINGENT

LIGHT THE

STARVED

LUW MIL

ESTAN CONLE

YOUTH

LE CONTINCENT G

STARVATION?

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

Page 29

FEATURES

women and 'new social forces" who were important to the party's strategy. To cap this, it was badly presented.

Tony Chater, the paper's editor, remained unresponsive to criticism, but, after the BC had been defeated twice at successive party congresses over the paper, other elements of the leadership including Gordon McLennan were persuaded that it must change.

In fact it was the Morning Star which provoked the public dispute between the CP's warring factions, by promoting an attack on Marxism Today for publishing an article that was mildly critical of "traditional' trade unionism.

Later the Morning Starchal- lenged the right of the CP to put forward a different policy for the

Management Committee of the People's Press Printing Society, the nominally independent body which owned the paper.

The paper has claimed to promote "class politics" as against those presented by Mar-

xism Today. Yet its columns at the time the

conflict broke out showed that this was not

reflected every day in its news or even in fea-

tures. It attacked the British ruling class far

more often as bad stewards of the economy

than as defenders of their own class interests.

Thus Bert Ramelson, a defender of the paper, condemned the Tory economic strategy as:

"bound to pull us further in the

economic mire, to keep us at the bottom of the

3rd division of industrial countries"

It also supported campaigns for import

controls even when they were simply

nationalist or led by Tories.

Official organisations of the labour move-

ment, the Labour Party and the trades unions,

and, above all, their leaders, have been the

paper's central preoccupation. Labour MPs

and union general secretaries could frequently

be found writing in its pages and their public

comments were a major part of its news

coverage. Even Sid Weighell, then right wing

rail union leader was allowed the use of its

columns in the year in which his members got

rid of him.

Typical was the concem with the split in

the Tribune group of MPs which led to the

formation of the Campaign group. The Morn-

ing Star echoed the line of those who wished

that the split could be undone, and therefore,

implicitly, that the differences of the Labour

left were less. This was part of a wider interest

in labour movement 'unity' on some un-

specified basis.

The implication was that the party and the

TUC, with their existing leaderships, could be

won to a new programme. 'Labour" must

won to a new

build the mass movement for radically dif-

ferent policies':

Such an objective calls for clear policies free of all traces of class collaboration. It means mounting a major challenge over a wide front to big business. It means fighting to shift the balance of wealth and power in favour of the working-class.

The Morning Star's approach was close to Militant's in its abstraction from the actual conflicts of the moment, but lacked the ambi- tion to put forward a specific programme.

A further key element in the paper's politics has been its commitment to the idea that conflicts can be resolved by negotiation, and many of its attacks on employers and govemments were for unwillingness to negotiate honestly. This attitude covered eveything from trade union struggles to, for example, coverage of the Falklands / Malvinas war, in which the United Nations was to play honest broker. A series was carried by Dave

Page

Priscott suggesting that if Poland had a proper parliamentary forum and the leaders of Solidamose had learnt negotiating skills like those in the British unions, the unpleasantness of martial law could have been avoided.

Finally it is clear that the Morning Star and the leading figures associated with it have not been honest. Not only did it seck to avoid the real conflicts over strategy and tactics in the working class movement but bureaucratic methods were used to keep control of the paper. The arguments used to prevent the CPGB taking back control through the PPPS in the first part of the 1980s were stood upon their head in 1988, when Tony Chater delivered it into the hands of the newly formed Communist Party of Britain and tried to suppress the dissenting views of the outgo- ing Management Committee.

The rescue plans of the carly 1980s depended upon sales and print contracts in the union movement. That the paper still has friends was shown by the statement issued at the time of the last Socialist Conference by Campaign Group MPs, including Tony Benn, urging sales and support for the paper.

Yet with the recent collapse of the old- guard Stalinist regimes and the traditional "tankie' politics on which the Star has always been based, it is difficult to see any labour movement or Stalinist cavalry with the ener- gy, resources or political confidence to ride to the rescue: much of the apparatus and the (largely opportunist) goodwill it once had have been lost. What remains is a group of desperate bureaucrats and a desperately boring reformist newspaper with a miserable political past and no political future.

Paul Hubert

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990

← Employers turn the screw · Gorbachev's USSR: Is Stalinism Dead? →

Something wrong on this page?