REVIEWS
Soviet tanks and troops crush the Prague spring in 1968
is
Edited by Carf Finamore, Walnut Publishing 1989. Avail- able from Socialist Outlook, £6.75 inc
This unique collection, published by the US marxist organisation Socialist Action, provides an in- teresting insight into the history of, and prospects for, political revolution in the Soviet Union.
The book is divided into four sections: an analysis of Gorbachev's reforms, authored by Socialist Action itself, two sec- tions on the relevance of Trotsky's ideas and the recent retum of Trotskyists to the USSR, including sections by Es teban Volkov, Trotsky's grandson, and Pierre Brou, Trotsky's biographer; and a con- cluding section on the sig-
nificance and rise of nationalism in the the soviet republics.
The political mainstay of this collection appears in the form of a resolution "The Crisis of Stalinism in the post-Stalin Era. Here Socialist Action attempt an analysis of the historic sig nificance of Gorbachev's reforms. As the title suggests, this analysis locates the root of these reforms in the crisis of the command economy, the legacy of decades of Stalinist rule.
The conclusions that are reached as to the purpose of these reforms are unequivocal: not just a new historic compromise' or a partial marketisation, but the restoration of capitalism.
Volkov's short contribution consists of a forthright defence of the Trotsky's role in the leader- ship of the infant Soviet state,
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990
and his later leadership of the Left Opposition and the Fourth International, reasserting the relevance of his ideas to the rapidly evolving situation in the USSR today.
Pierre Brou, author of a recent, and much acclaimed, biography of Trotsky, recounts the remarkable experience of speaking to a meeting of hundreds in Moscow, demanding the rehabilitation of Trotsky. He was joined by relatives of Trotsky's companions, such as Nadezdha Joffe, 82 year old daughter of Adolf Joffe, a leader of the Left Opposition.
Finally, a number of contribu- tions explain the relevance of the national question, looking at state repression in Armenia under Gorbachev and at the his- toric tradition of revolutionary nationalism in the Ukraine,
among others.
This is a useful book, that looks at the relevance of Trotskyism and the ideas of political revolution to the Soviet Union from a number of view- points. Though the variety of con- tributions perhaps detracts from the cohesion of the collection, the numerous contributions from leaders of Socialist Action provide a political framework that runs through the different sections of the book.
Though some of their con- clusions may be controversial among marxists, it is increasing- ly clear that the historic altema- tives for the Soviet Union - of capitalist restoration or political revolution are no longer a long- term prognosis.
Patrick Baker
Page 31
REVIEWS
All that melts into air
is solid: the