hokum
In Race and Class, Volume 31, Number 3
January-March 1990
By A Sivanandan
Review by David Grant
"New Times is a mirror image of Thatcherism passing for socialism. New Times is Thatcherism in drag.
Challenging the pernicious in- fluence of Marxism Today, and its New Times agenda, is one of the most pressing of contem- porry tasks facing the marxist left. To take on the self-ap- pointed saviours of Labour's electoral fortunes, to confront them directly on their own ter- rain, may well be an onerous and difficult task. But it is nonethe- less necessary and increasingly urgent.
In this light, Sivanandan's withering critique is timely. With the media crowing triumphantly about the "historic failure" of Marxism-Leninism, crumbling along with the Berlin Wall, Sivanandan reminds us that it is not just East European stalinist marxism that has failed to stand up to the onslaught of capitalist ideology-
Our home grown variety, it- self of course a not-so-distant relative of that in the cast, has been struggling for years to ac- comodate itself to the right-wing libertarianism of Thatcherism. In this dubious task it has been en- tirely successful.
Of course, every form of refuge has its price. Theorising the drift to the New Realist right,
giving it a left cover, sticking
marxist labels it, seems fine
when Thatcherism is rampant.
But with the decline of the
Tories' standing in the polls, the
forward march of Labour no
longer seems quite as stalled.
Not surprisingly, the tune has
changed. Indeed, there seems to
be an element of former fellow
travellers falling out as Sivanan-
dan dedicates his article to "those
friends with whom, out of a dif- ferent loyalty, I must now open- ly disagree."
Sivanandan doesn't mince his words. The theoretical prac- titioners of New Times and their forays into philosophy, linguis- ties, semiotics, psychoanalysis, post-structuralism and deconstruction, are slammed. They have given us, he says, merely, "the consummate and conclusive finding that reality it- self (is) a matter of interpretation, construction, presentation - of words, ideas, images. "Philosophers", they might have said with a nod to Marx, 'have in- terpreted the world; our task is to change the interpretation.'*
Sivanandan's savaging of the preposterous "marxism" that New Times offers, would no doubt be applauded by many on the left. But then there is more to political criticism that making a rather small number of people smile,
For despite re-asserting that "the economic" does determine "the political" in the last instance, a welcome and well argued point, he accepts one of the fun- damentals of the New Times agenda. That is the view that capital has somehow eman- cipated itself from labour. He seems to accept the validity of the post-Fordist industrial/social model but baulks at the con- clusions that the proponents of New Times wish to draw from it.
For if it is true that the in-
dustrial working class has been nullified as the agent of historical
change through the effects of the technological revolution, that capital has indeed freed itself from labour, what will take its place? Where are the social for- ces with nothing to lose but their chains, the social weight and ob-
jective interest in revolutionising
society?
The theoreticians of New Times put forward the 'new" (what else?!) political move-
ments based on race, sex, gender,
KILL
APARTHEID
NOT
DETAINEE
and more recently peace and ecol- more in common with the think- ogy. Sivanadan begs to differ.
ing of the New Timers than he But what would he put in the gap might imagine. that remains, once the proletariat
Indeed, much in common disappears from the scene ?
also with catholic liberation
This question is never entirely theology, an organising force
among the third world's poor answered. He seems to prefer an
and dispossessed, who, like alliance of the dispossessed, the have-nots, those outside of the
Sivanandan, make a moral
choice to be "for" the poor and systems of choice and con- sumerism so beloved of Marxism. disspossesed. Not that there is
anything wrong with this in it- Today. But, alas, just as there is no reason why an amalgam of
self. But it hardly solves the
theoretical problems of dispens- the oppressed should necessarily be objectively anti-capitalist, out- ing with the historic role of the side of an alliance with the work- proletariat in negating capitalisn
Has capital really eman- ing class, neither is there any
cipated itself from labour? The reason put forward by Sivanan-
last ten years in Britain might dan as to why an alliance of the dispossessed should or could be.
lead you to imagine so. But At the end of his article, it seems marxism has, since the beginnin
of this century, been arguing for to come down (in the last in-
a global starting point for any stance?), despite his insistence,
analysis of trends within not to the economic, but to a
capitalist society. Part of question of - wait for it - choice.
Sivanandan's critique of the in-
Sivanandan prefers the in-
ward looking, self-obsessed tegrity of the poor and dispos-
theoretical meanderings of Mar- sessed to the new social
xism Today is precisely that they movements, which, he suggests, may be "corrupting of socialism. ignore much of what is actually
happening in the world. so self-obsessed and pre-oc-
How does the development of cupied are they with their own oppression. In making this latter the Brazilian labour movement,
which last year organised the point, he ascribes to these social
movements the narrow motives and interests assumed by the New Timers. This one-sided in- terpretation downplays the posi- tive impact of these movements and the insights they have brought to the wider struggle for socialist change.
But we never find out the how and why of the role of the poor and dispossessed as a replacement for the organised
working class as the agent of his- torical change within the Marxist system. In this, Sivanandan has
largest ever industrial general strike in history, fit into the post- Fordist model which Sivanandan accepts? Where does the develop- ment of the South African trade union movement, the power be- hind so much of the recent change in South Africa, find a place, after Henry?
These are issues that the left. needs to continue to debate. Sivanandan's contribution, witty
and concise as it is, tends to indi- cate that we have some way to go yet.
Page 32
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 22, March 1990