Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The Question of German reunification

· Socialist Outlook no. 21, February 1990 · pp 15-17 · 2,676 words

Stalinism Germany Russia and the USSR Marxism

SUPPLEMENT

more and more reduced just to economic competition, then the USA is in a much weaker posi- tion vis-a-vis West Germany and Japan.

While Bush has personally supported moves towards faster European integration, this is not necessarily the position of US capital as a whole. In any case,

caught between penetration of castern markets by the EC as a whole or simply that of West Germany, the US is faced with two evils between which it is dif- ficult to decide,

In general, again with the par- tial exception of the West Ger- man leaders, the main response of the imperialist leaders has been to stress order" and "stability". While the discomfiture of the Stalinist leaders may be pleasing to them, the mobilisation of the

Czechoslovakle: the Stalinists tried and falled to invoke workers against students

masses contains a potential which is deeply disturbing. Thus the visit of US Secretary of State Baker to Hans Modrow, giving support for "orderly" change, is an obvious sign of US con- cems. This is also the source of Thatcher's insistence that the Warsaw Pact must remain, and the process must not go "too fast".

The historic stakes

In the medium lerm there are evi- dently three possible outcomes of the present upsurge, and they might not be the same for each country. Either capitalism will be restored; or the political revolution will win; or bureaucratic rule will be consolidated. But in an overall historic sense the choice is between the restoration of capitalism and workers power.

In part the outcome depends on the close interaction between the events in East Europe and those in the Soviet Union. If the crisis of perestroika were to result in the fall of Gorbachev and the restoration of a hardline Stalinist leadership. this could well spur a counter-offensive by the bureaucracy in the East European countries. But this seems an unlikely development, and any sharp attempt to restore the previous system of bureaucratic domination, especial- ly one based on force, would result in a gigantic explosion, with incalcul- able consequences.

More likely, the events in Eastern Europe which have now overtaken those in the USSR itself, can easily flow back into the Soviet Union, fuelling demands for an end to the Communist monopoly of power. Such a development would really place Gorbachev's position in jeopar-

dy: the CPSU's monopoly is central for the continuance of bureaucratic rule in the Soviet Union itself.

Leaving aside some unexpected and momentous event in the Soviet Union, the outcome is much more likely to lie in a protracted triangular struggle between restorationist forces aided by imperialism; the bureaucracy, or rather those sections of it which want to defend Stalinist rule; and the working class.

In practice, as most dramatically shown by Poland, whole sections of the bureaucracy will aid the process of trying to defeat the workers economically and politically in order to prepare the ground for Wester in- vestment and the restoration of capitalism.

The main obstacle to the restora- tion of capitalism is the working class itself. The working class in each country must be defeated in a series of frontal battles if property is to be re-privatised,

domestic bureaucratic-bourgeoisie established, and the social gains of the masses wiped out. Two obviously related questions are at issue here: the level of mobilisation of the masses, and their overall political consciousness. Both are presently in deep flux.

While a spontaneous fight against austerity can delay the restoration of capitalism, only a conscious fight for a democratic socialist order can lead to the victory of the political revolu- tion. Two central problems raise themselves here.

First, it is an open question to what extent the discrediting of any form of "socialism" and collectivism by the Stalinist rulers has succeeded in driving the masses into the arms of

capitalism. For example, while ins East Germany socialist and collec tivist values seem to be strong, the pull of Western prosperity on sections of the population is also strong.

Beyond that, even those like Vaclev Havel in Czechoslovakia who are suspicious of the West, and even most of those committed to somel for of democratic socialism. generally remain committed to "marketisation" as the sole form of possible cconomic restructuring. This is an historic gain for pro-capitalist ideologues, and a mammoth problem for building a genuine socialist op position.

Secondly, while the restoration of capitalism implies the defeat of Stalinism and an historic vindication of all currents that argue for socialism with democracy, nonetheless the res toration of capitalism in Eastern Europe - especially if combined with a similar outcome in the USSR would be a world historic defeat for the working class.

In this respect it is absolutely ir- responsible to ignore - as do statel capitalist and bureaucratic collectivist currents - the weight of the deformed workers' states in the world relation- ship of forces. With their defeat, the continued existence of the Cuban workers' state and of the revolution- ary government in Nicaragua would be in peril.

Imperialism would be much freer to engage in adventures, not only, for example, towards Vietnam. but against the whole third world. Im- perialism rampant would rapidly lead to resurgent militarism, especially in Japan and Germany. New inter-im- perialist wars could not be ruled out.,

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 21, February 1990

"the main

obstacle to the

restoration of capitalism is the

working class,

which must be

defeated in a series of frontal

battles if property is to be re-privatised, a

domestic

bureaucratic

bourgeoisie established, and the social gains

of the masses

wiped out"

Page 13

"in east European countries women are completely integrated into the workforce, but in general real equality does not exist. In several countries abortion and contraception rights are de facto restricted"

Page 14

SUPPLEMENT

The reimposition of the im- perialist yoke in Eastern Europe is a nightmare scenario.

An opposite scenario, the possibility of the emergence of new democratic socialist states, or even a militant fight in that direction, could have an explosive impact on the, working class in every country, but especially on the This workers of the advanced capitalist world, including Europe. The danger for im- perialism is not just that of Fighting ecological catastrophe in Siberia the attractive power

democratic socialist states if they are

emocrane sociaust stares it tney are established, but of the lessons of mass mobilisation. Already there is no doubt that political freedoms are greater in East Germany today than they are in any advanced capitalist state. The right to demonstrate is un- trammelled, and everyone can inspect their own police file - if it hasn't been destroyed. The power of the secret police, including the right to surveil- lance, is completely destroyed. The dangers of these lessons spilling over into Western Europe are immense.

To maximise the opportunities for the working class in this situation re- quires the construction of a revolu- tionary political leadership - there can be no political revolution without it. We do not define such a leadership as necessarily explicitly Trotskyist; but it must engage in a struggle around the main themes and demands of the political revolution, on the axis of socialism with democracy.

This must include a rejection of marketisation as the main form of economic restructuring, and the build- ing of organisations of workers' power at the level of the factory and throughout society. Through the fight to build organised bodies of support, revolutionary currents and parties in every cast European country, and, and through ceaseless contacts and political intervention, we and our co- thinkers internationally can make a major contribution to the creation of such a leadership.

The programme of

political revolution

The programme of political revolution which we advocate must go beyond attempts at 'reform' of the system and the establishment of par- liamentary-type democracy. Key to our demands must be the fight for the self-organisation and political inde- pendence of the working class from Stalinist and bourgeois forces. While we do not write off reform Com-

terms of childcare or the socialisation of domestic labour. In several countries abor- tion and contraception rights are de facto restricted.

The fight against ecological catastrophe assumes particular force castern Europe: Stalinism's absolute priority to ex- tensive production and large-scale industry has created some of

the worst ecological

1247261 14 BCEX

munists at the base of the Stalinist parties, history has already answered the question of whether they can be transformed into instruments for socialist democracy; by and large they are finished; their working class base will increasingly look elsewhere.

The fight for workers' self or- ganisation must involve the fight for independent trade unions and workers" councils independent of the Stalinist parties. The most important example of developments of this kind was the mass working class move- ment and an extensive network of workers councils which characterised the emergence of Solidarose in Poland. Under these conditions the working class, as an organised force, were the driving force in the process of political revolution. It involves the fight for new political parties based on socialist democracy and the programme of workers self-manage- ment.

Socialists must combine the fight for socialist democracy with a strug gle around transitional demands in defence of the material interests of the workers which will everywhere come under attack. Key among these demands are a sliding scale of wages to protect the workers against the rampant inflation in several East Buropean countries, and the fight for a 35 hour week against the long working hours and growing un- employment. This fight must be com- plemented by the demand for radical egalitarianism and the end of all ves- tiges of bureaucratic privilege.

Integral to the fight for political revolution is the struggle for real, as opposed to juridicial, equality for women. In east European countries women are completely integrated into the workforce - in the GDR for ex- ample they are per percent of the labour force. But in general real equality does not exist, either in terms of employment opportunities or in

in

problems in the world. Thus the programme of political revolution must include the demand for a workers' inspectorate to supervise the environment and the transition to ecologically-sustainable economic growth.

In several parts of eastern Europe the national question increasingly raises its head. Socialists demand the right of national self-determination, including the right of separation, for oppressed nationalities.

Above all, the programme of political revolution must be centred on the fight for a democratically centralised planned economy, under workers' control. The first stage of this is the fight for workers" veto over central economic plans and a regime of workers" control at the level of the factory. This programme does not ex- clude all marketisation initiatives - for example the creation of small firms in the service sector with profits supervised by the state, or agricultural and other co-operatives. But the key to regenerating the economies is the unleashing of the creative power of the masses, around production objec- tives democratically decided.

Rational democratic planning as- sumes not autarky, but an internation- al division of labour. That is why the fight for an international federation of democratic socialist republics, in east- em Europe and the Soviet Union is vital. But the key to regenerating production historically is to link production and markets east and west - in particular to unify the economies of the Soviet Union and Germany. This is the centre of the demand for a United Socialist States of Europe.

In particular the programme of political revolution involves the struggle for democratic workers" councils (soviets), the separation of party and state and the smashing of Stalinist control of the police, military and secret police.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

SUPPLEMENT

01 -

Western 'democracy' in practice? West Berlin cops rough up demonstrators, while East Berlin workers look on aghast

German reunification is a ques- tion that cannot be evaded by marxists. The division of Europe was jointly imposed on the work- ing class by Stalinism and im- perialism. The bloc system, of NATO and the Warsaw Pact, was a system of clamping the working classes of Europe under respec- tively American and Soviet hegemony.

As internationalists we are in favour of the unification of the European working class, of building stronger fighting links between its component parts as part of a struggle for a united socialist Europe. The division of the German working class is at the heart of the division of Europe. Thus we are for the right of unity of the German workers, and for the removal of all foreign troops from German soil. But quite obviously the national question in Germany is inter- twined with the social question in a quite unique fashion.

Concretely, the issue is posed as to whether the unification of Ger- many will be achieved by the integra- tion of the GDR into a powerful Ger- man capitalist superstate, with the destruction of the social gains of the GDR workers, or by the generalisa- tion of those gains in an anti-capitalist direction throughout Germany. At the present time, this poses itself as the question of the self-determination of the East German workers.

We raise this slogan not because

we think that there is an East German nationality, but because the East Ger- man workers have enjoyed historic social gains, embodied in nationalised property and an advanced welfare system, which would be under direct threat if unification were imposed against their will.

Articulating support for German reunification and the self-determina- tion of the GDR workers in this way can only be advanced in a perspective of permanent revolution. It is not a demand that makes a precondition of the destruction of capitalism in West Germany; the condition is that the East German workers have the oppor- tunity to defend and extend their so- cial gains.

While sections of West German capital have been quick to seize on the demand for reunification, others have been more cautious. It is not just a question of the possibility of ex- tending capitalist production relations eastwards; there is also the possibility that a working class committed to collectivist and socialist values could be incorporated westwards - with massively destabilising social results. The German working class, and its political organisations, including the West German SPD, is one of the most powerful and organised working clas- ses in the world. It has one of the longest and most militant traditions of any working class. Its unification under any conditions would be, at best, a mixed blessing for capital.

Capital in West Germany would

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 21, February 1990

only accept reunification on its termsy - including the defeat and atomisa- tion of the East German workers, the ending of their mobilisations, the destruction and asset-stripping of whole sectors of GDR industry, and the destruction of the state welfare system. While supporting the historic goal of reunification, again as a step towards a socialist Europe, we demand the GDR workers have the right to say "no' to the plans off Western capital.

Demanding the right of self-deter-

mination of the GDR workers, in- cluding their right to maintain the present state boundaries, does not mean yielding an inch on the demand for the withdrawal of Soviet troops and the GDR's right to withdraw from the Warsaw Pact. Marxists op

pose the joint Gorbachev-Thatcher

demand that the present bloc system must stay intact to ensure "security'.

Insofar as the West German Greens, Left Alternative and sections of the SPD base have raised the demand of self-determination for the GDR workers against the 'free social market in West Germany, their response is entirely correct. But marxists cannot in any circumstances mix our banners with those, whether Stalinists or influenced by the con cems of British and French im- perialism, who oppose reunifications Germany on principle. On principle, we are for reunification.

"marxists

cannot in any circumstances

mix our

banners with those, whether

Stalinists or

influenced by the concerns of

British and

French

imperialism,

who oppose

Germany on

principle. On

principle, we

are for reunification"

Page 15

← The implosion of East European Stalinism · Eastern Europe: Where is the left? →

Something wrong on this page?