IN
writing books on the problems of industrial relations became a growth industry. Ex-Labour cabinet ministers, one-time
union bureaucrats, "learned' academics and needless to say Fleet Street jornalists, all jostled each other in the
queues outside the publishers to get in on the act. The price for their expert opinion was the rate for the job, which
narurally was a hell of a lot more per hour than the troublesome workers they were writing about ever hoped to
Their conclusion varico. One lot might favour a more
consulted you before they gave you the sack. Others opted for
get
The
enlichtened management - they were the employers who
rough management. But almost without exception, they all came down against the extremists - that "bloody- minded minority' - who they insisted were leading the sane, sensible and essentially
moderate tha horny !
conflict. It seemed to escape their notice that ever since there had been bosses and
workers, class conflict has gone
Now from the other side of the track, Alan Thornett, 25 years a car worker at Cowicy. Oxford, and 21 of those a shop steward, has written about building the union in the car industry, Unlike the former authors he makes no
concessions to academic derachment or so-called impartiality. He is a
socialist and a Marxist' who knows that the class struggle
committed PUP ISKEN
knows that the class struggle determines what goes on in
industry and society, and insists that what determines the outcome of conflict between management and state is the reactions and
attitudes of individuals to the
He rightly pays tribute to
what I suppose Messrs
Kinnock and Hattersley. would now describe as the
lass
He n
what I suppose Messrs
Dony lett 36 people who "built and
Alan Thornell, From Militancy to Marxism, Left View, £9.95.
Trimshop women join the strike, July 1959
1956: crossing a picket line
From militar
developed the trade union movement in the Morris plant at Cowley'. As he says: 'Some of them are still there today. fighting the same fight and defending the same principles.. who faced and face every day, not just the pressures of the track, but both the struggle to organise
acks from ient He chronicke
how these "unsung heroes" organised the union in the
Victimisation was like a Damoclean sword that bung permanently over their heads.
plant. It was never easy
normanenuy Tr ene hurtin
was owned by the union- matine Willias the union was almost
sack
n Mn
tantamount to asking for the
Nor were the carly post-war years exactly haleyun days for trade unionism. It was 1956
before management were forced to stop using redundancies as a means of arbitrary sackings. A strike in the Brinsh Motor « -opor: albeit at Cowley and Lonebridgr anly suppu.... a minority, but given the powertul toust of - BMt- cars w TGWT! forced the bosses to the negotiating table.
Management w to concede son. to consultl..
took place.
But positions like shop
steward and convenor still remained high risk
occupations, people like Frank
Horsman the TGWU convenor were victimised, and although the workers took strike action.
the national union leaders accepted a solution that whilst stopping him losing exiployment meant be was
an a waterdlar
hody nar•
next donr, redoring his cffectiveness as a trade union militant.
* 'ne tirst, the rast tr
not nav thi
rine collabnratinnisr •The maid officials
* show.now. time. and
ne union militants
on the shop floor did not just
need to keep their eyes on the
management, but also needed to keep glancing over their
nat their ollicas
He Don"
out how They were happy for
the branch to spearhead the initial union organisation of the plant and send them
thousands of pounds every
month from membership dues: but when this resulted in a militant fight with management they were not so keen.
The officials wanted
mUst 1987
REVIEWS
USA, and atacked the
Strikers 1956
significant of the Trotskyist
groups
about the St.t., and the same
thing appeared" number™ worker militanre at th
number of other serious
was us determinanor its intellectuals and students towards vuuang a ho
movement. F
more is insistence that the crisis tor the working
" crisis of lcaderin» very much with his own
experience and thar of the
Vietnamese peoples against the
complicity of the Wilson government in this shameful war. Unlike the reformists, the Trotskyis in Cowley did not tell the workers "leave things to us" they argued for the workers to take the auchority into their own hands.
Naturally this carned them the undying hatred of the bosses, the union burcaucrats, the right wing Labourites and the press — such policies hear the
icy to Marxism
consultation and negotiation with the employers, which meant they saw their role, not
as representing the worklurce in taking over control of conditions in the factory, but
as mediating between capital
mund labour.
What emerges from the story of Cowley and this holds true for every other workplace, be it factory or office, is that the unremitting battle against management, and the struggle to bring the unions under the control of the members is a herculean task. It is not something that can be left 10
chance, nor can it be dependent on cither workers or stewards spontancously Even militancy, desirable and
reaching the right conclusions. Even militancy, desirable and necessary as it is, on its own is
always in the author's words the constant need to link the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/Augur 1987
not enough. There remains
day to day struggles on the shop floor to the struggle for a
socialist programme.
Thornett recognised that
noed quite early in his trade
union life and it was nor long
after starting work ar Cowley
that he joined the Communist Party. It was not long cither
tommunist ww.either
before he realised that the
Parts
mat the
did not bas micthods... the
class struggle and he also began to recognise that many
of its members in the unions,
particularly those in full-time or leading positions, were themselves enmeshed in the union bureaucracy.
Unlike many who have left
the Communist Party he did not finish up sat behind the desk in the personnel office or make his accommodation with reformism. Instead he joined
lelt ad
the Socialist Lahour Irague at
that time the largest and most
hallmark of subversion. other stewards in the factory.
Eventually, an unlioly They only had to look at
alliance berwcen the media, Transport House and the anties of the Labour leadership and the union officials, assisted to know that was certainly
hy the bosses, was used to
undermine the militants at
In rime he was to leave the
Cowley. In 1982 Alan
Thornett was framed and
sacked. Today management is
back in the saddle and thanks
COrreCT.
SIL not because he rejected Trotskyism, but because he
was convinced it was not
inte to those reasonable people working class and had become bureaucratically degenerate.
who believe in realism' the unions are weakened, the workload has been intensified and the threat of victimisation
Cowley stande as a testimony of what can be
organisation on the shop floor and equally it bears testimony to the treachery of the union bureaucracy. This is why From Militancy le Marxism is a book to be read. It shows die potential that existed during the upsurge of militancy in the sixties and seventies, and brings out how that militancy
Despite its malformations and it undoubted sectarian and ultra-left practices, the SLE
is again in the air. had provided accesss to the Transitional Programme and the
worke of lear.
it Alan 1 a4i LE
were able to educate nemselves and wer
disarmed wnen lacer political ellensive In
..... the Ti
Labour governments. Nor were they drawn into the trăp of the class collaboration advocated by the union officials
This cabled them to lead a fight ar winwley against wags restraint, and against anti- trade union laws whether they
lawe waltero
achieved by political
hetrayed by the labour
burraucracy, thus making Thatcher's anti-union crusade
that caser F class the price of TUC
originated from Labour's Barbara Castle or Edward Heath's Tory government. Unlike many militants who
could not counter the bosses' arguments that falling sales
'realism is indeed a heavy
Furthermore the bonk shows
that employers can be defeated
and the bureaucracy can be swept aside, providing the
and rising costs meant redundancies, the Trotskyists at Cowley would demand open the books" and call for a shorter working week with no
marxist movement has won a base in the mass organisations of the working class,
particularly in the workplace and in the unions. Unlike the 'experts who want to interpret industrial relations, this book is a serious attempt to show how — with the methors of the class struggie and the use
- we can actually change them, so the working
Juen the
loss of pay.
Beine Marxi
restrict their campaigns to factory issues or the issues of
British politics. They renegnised the threat of
factor Hritis"
of marxism imperialism and supported the
liberation war of the
class can rule society. 37