"There ain't no black in the union jack'
belies the work of significant
Gilroy relics on this analysis
SHAHID TILLEY
Paul Giry, There ain't no black in the union jack,
Hubhinsun,, $7.95.
IN THIS BOOK Paul Gilroy analyses Britain in the past two decades through the prism of 'race and racist
On the way, he explores the 'crisis in Marxism which 15 highlighted by, and possibly produced by, the rise of 'new social movements'
Jerisoning the dominant view of racism which
constructs black people in a problem/victim" couplet, or carriers of a discrete and fixed cultural hagage, he constructs a more political definition of 'race/racism as a procees
intrinsically linked with post-war political and cconomic crisis. 'Race" is brought in from the margins where it is presently thought
by sections of the left to be 'bad ideology" and explored in its relationship to the rise of
notion of race and "black criminality is analysod as a key component of the drift
towards authoritarian stanism.
Race underpins much of the
the new right and the authoritarian state. The
'common sense around which industrial and nationai decline is understood not only by the
establishment but also
popularly:
The fusion of nations/race popularised by the ideologues of the new right has become su dominant that Labour's trew realists jealously want to reclaim the popular
parrintic flag. Kinnock, and theoreticians such as EP Thompson and Raymond Williams are casting around for a 'left' and "fairer' patriotism thar will appeal to all that is just and good in the
English/Brirish tradition. But for black people and Trish the relationship between the union jack, racism and imperialism
is too close for comfort. And, as recently in France, the cainted language of patriotism is bound io fail paving the way for a further shift to the
of nation and rare to explain the success of the of the Anti-Nazi League (ANT) in
- ele of the National Front by
suppos
labelling the latter as Nazis
against whom Britain fought
All good Britons
could not be Nazis. The
danger of such arguments in
playing upon nationalist
the war.
resonances was that the rendered anti racism
discussion of rare was puller
away form the centre. Ir also
vulnerahle to fascists such as
Tyndal to announce their opposition to Nazism and
their affirmation of patriotism. Gilroy contrasts the strengths
of Rock Againsr Racism —
nineth
deemed to be a more
dear in its down-up development and its distance from the
velopme
opportunistic language of patriotism. Ir also allied with and encouraged genuincly anti-nationalist movements/youth cultures to develop (punk music, for
inconcy
instance). of the Greater London
les equal opportunity
mines ut
The book also critically regards the anti-racist efforts
Council (from 1981 to 1980).
rolation to administration and
only applied successfully
within bureaucracies were
hastily generalised by their
foisting onto the wider
community with insufficient preparation or any
understanding of the
2X01E ourside county hall.
nua whit..
racism as power plus
discrimination not only alienared many black people
not have any power.
but also white Londoners - the vast majority of whom did
This book's central
weakness is its striking
"strategic silence on the labour and trade union
movements. There is no discussion of the potential to
be gained from socialist militants working within them. What in realiry has
No ens
list
been their failure to cogently oppose the forces of the radical right after the collapse of the relative consensus
politics of the post-war period
is diagnosed as intrinsic to the lahour movement. The
SEE CaN nature of ine las Hivement are
MECES Bliss a halleneed bit
deeply embedded that any
opposition is deeted to be
UDSiTOn I
hopeless task
This coupled with Gilroy's conception of the lell as 'reductionist" or 'economistic
socialist currents within both the labour and trade union moveinents who have refused to privilege
pass".
voluntary organisations, churches. Tabour parties and
unions to the left in
challenging the state over the political presence of fascists
marching on the streets. In
contrast, the Communist
Party's more anti-racist and popular-front orientated
campaign one race Lie
the divisiveness and racist
failure,
"shop-loor" struggles at the expense of others such as anti-racism. women's equality and peace.
In face the formation of both the ANt and KAK was initially secured by socialists active either in the trade unions or political parties. The ANL was a comparatively successful project in its attempt to challenge the risc of the National Front. Formed as a united-frunt against fascism ir was a broad based alliance operating under the banner of they shall not
Anti-fascist demos forced
n ita
human race which focused on
adcology of fascism was a
Gilroy also fails to provide a sufficient explanation for the failure of anti racist and black autonomous politics to cohere
into mass movements over the
past decade. In fact their slide into fragmentation must be
understood within the context of intra-class divisions, tbe
rightward shift in British politics and the failure to build a socialist bridgehead within the labour and trade union movements on the question of race. The bitter harvest of this has been the rush into the restrictive
politice of "equal opportunity"
within, and of, local government services: the employment of a professional layer of "ethnic specialists" whose aim is to culturally
rais
118 B clients.
the consolidation of black churches or groups often
X00
Valen veer
along reactionary and dead-end axioms of religious
fundamenralism and hlack
capitalism". The suhstantive
ayenda for black liberation und anti-racism (an end to state oppression, improved
housing, health, education and employment) have heen
put on ice for the time being.
Linked to this partial
retreat is the pernicious rise in the politics of the "hierarchies
of the oppressed' (where one "uppressed group attempts to
gain a larger share of ever
decreasing and meagre services at the expense of
another) which in reality is a
logical extension of many existing cy.-
programmes.
The other danger of Gilroy's analysis which privileges social movements
which are often against the state' is the question of
criteria. If historical
materialism and the class struggle as methods of analysis are to be severely
restricted in their applicahiliry, as the book scems to suggest, then by
what other criteria do we
oock nen by
jarge the progressive nature
ur otherwise of autonumous struggles? Even the
Ictt, tor asTA Wi
ild. Me. - limous schools -.wynary.as.well
uswant to
REVIEWS
mobilisation and spontaneity with socialist currents within the labour and trade union movements locally and nationally. This would provide a stronger loundation on which to build broader working class alliances to expand the bases of struggles
define their own boundaries of solidarity and identity in their
specific attempts to deconstruct modernity.
Autonumous movements need to be interpreed within the framework of class
struggle. So often they promise radical challenge to
and reduce the vulnerability the values of modern capitalist
which is often associated with socicty only to collapse back.
the isolation of autonomy: specially in times of crises,
While the book is tawed into the class from which they
there is much in it which is uriginated.
Gilnw challenging for the left. In
particular, it offers a timely emphasise tie importance of
critiquie of many "anti-racist? progressive autonomous
and equal opportunity movements ourside the boundaries of corporate
initiatives and instead will
help to develop a coherent structures. But for these to
and critical strategy Int succeed there is a need to
fighting racism • unite their strengths of
colla:
specially in times of crises, into the class from which they
emphasise tie importance of progressive autonomous
The