Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The decline of Scottish capital

· Socialist Outlook no. 2, July–August 1987 · pp 41-42 · 1,057 words

Scotland

JIM NIBLOCK

John Foster and Charler Woolfson, The politics of the UCS work in, Laterence and Withart, 29.95.

FIFTEEN YEARS after the

event, it may seem strange to comment that this 1s a timcly publication. However, the relevance of the book becomes clear as the authors — both expelled members of the British Communist Party — seck to go buck to the future by re-establishing the political authenticity of the party line ar

the time of the work-in

As such, they polemicise

est Par

communist orthodoxy, But it

is indeed ironic, and indicative of the crisis of the Cr, that the appearance of this book should

appearance of this book should coincide with the rwo main leaders of the work-in — Jimmy Reid and Jimmy Airlic

- expressing themselves to be opposed to the politics that they stood for at the rime of UCS.

In May of this year, Airlie as

Icuder of the AEU in Scotland pressurised the Caterpillar workers into calling off their occupation. Reid joined

Rupert Murdoch's stalf at the

Rupert Murdoch's stalf at the

San in June.

Still, the authors cannot be

blaned for this and both clearly remain unshakenly

committed to the politics of the

"anti-monopoly alliance". But

then, what is interesting and

so timely abour the book is not so much its politica but the

... the Il te facto

unal

The authors trace the

independence and the

consequent decline of its

influence at the level of the British state Scottish industrial capital was basod on the maintenance of empire; shipbuilding, steel, coal and heavy engineering accounted for forty per cent of the malc workforce at the turn of the century as against (wenty-five per cent in Britain as a whole.

The dozen or so families that contrulled these sectors

(Colevilles, Lithgows,

Tris te

Yarrows, Tennanis, Stephens,

Weirs) were based on the Clyde and, through inter- marriage, combined holdings

holdins Their ur

on the Scottish economy was unchallenged. On a British

scale they were able to dominate shipbuilding and a number of heavy engineering

sectors. But the disintegration

of Britain's imperial rule after

the second world war left these

the second world war left these

leading sectors of Scottish

capital in a particularly vulnerable position.

Although weakened, heavy engueering remained

dominant in Scotland. It used its political influence to fight

against the introduction of a

strip steel mill to service the consumer durahle gonds

sector. Bur eventually even the

monopoly of steel production in Scotland based on shipbuilding plate, was forced to capitulate when faced with the threat of an outside company being brought it to set up the strip steel mill. The establishment of Kavenscraig combined with the Roots car plant at Linwood marked an attempt to shift the balance away from heavy industry

In practice, heavy industry was in irreparable decline and the much vaunted new growth industries did not emerge to permanently replace it. By 1960 the Tory vote

began its inexorable slump. By 1964 the Scotrish Nationalist Parry (SNP) hegan to emerge

as a credible force

Towards the end of the 1960e: Sir Wilnas attempted to reassert the

control of heavy industry through Oceanspan: A maritime-base

strategy for a european

sentland 1470 Scottish OF Drolcat and in Home header Vane commiss reD

elected Scottish assembly

But the 'l'ories were more concerued with entry into the

The Oceanspan project for an integrated steel complex at Hunterston clashed with FFC membership which would see demand for steel contract. With their main project for industrial revival

Eurupean Economic

sacrificed to the capitalist rationalisation of European steel production the Scottish

Conservatives exposed their lack of pulitical influence ar

Community.

te Scou

the level at which it mantered

Under the stimulus of ERC

membership Scottish capital

rapidly concentrated and

sought refuge by integrating

itself ever-more-closely into the

British stare. The price it paid for this was the severing of its localities which in turn weakened Tory mots in Scotland. The drive towards

period, together with attacks on local government, have

centralism during the Thatcher

called into question the credibility and possibly even the very existence of the Scottish Tories.

A timcly (and pricey!) book

even if all it does is remind us

d 1u

of what yesterday's "heroes"

have descended to. The

authors" political conclusions leave a lot to be desired but their analysis makes this book worth the read.

39

40

Muti in 'Chronicle of a dea

a rather disappointing film.

The use of a "derective format seen in Rosi's previous films and the eminently cincmatic qualities of the Colombian

location should have combined

with the theme of Marquez's

novel — the complicity of a

whole village in a murder for

"honour'

victim knew of it — to occur. Unfortunately, it is politically sult. Many of the biting

observations from characters

in the novel are absent from, or lack significance in, the

film. Most importantly, the

- to great effect.

ad n

searing indictment of the values which caused the social

paralysis that allows the death - so fortold that even the

complexity of the emotions: and morivations of Marquez's women characters are flattened into predictable (and therefore somewhat reactionary) stercutypes.

Thus, Angela Vicario, the woman whose 'bonour" is "redeemed through murder and death is seen in a vicious

Marqur.

flarten

fight with her sisters. This is in marked contrast to the passage in Marquez's novel which sees Angela and her sisters discussing ways in which she can utilise the predictably drunken state of

o hishang to ke

........i hidden

the lin upens eIli... enough. A paddle

steamer chugs slowiy away from a glass-fronted cityscape. Slow tracking shots follow the

steamer on its journey up the

sluggish river - black smoke

sky. The music carries an uminous note as the sicamer

sluggish river - black smoke belching into a harsh white

approaches the village — isolated in space and time — a

microcosm of the continent in which the tragedy is to be played our. The river and its human cargo are the only source of change for a town that 'never changes'

But the film lacks the savage irony of the novel and even

goes for an ending which is

Fans of Rosi and Marquez will be disappointed. Those who have still to discover their

respective work should not let this film prejudice them in

seeking it our. SOCIALIST OUTLI

← Ain't no black in the union jack · Chronicle of a death foretold →

Something wrong on this page?