Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Just some reformist rubbish?

· Socialist Outlook no. 19, November 1989 · pp 33-34 · 814 words

rubbish - no. This book represents that very rare creature - an integrated world outlook from a left reformist viewpoint. It deserves to be read and its component parts debated.

Labour lost the last election because it was unable to con- vince working people that its shopping list for the welfare state could be financed from anywhere but their pay packets. The disarray of the party spokespeople as support col- lapsed in the last two weeks of that campaign back in 1987 still lingers in the mind.

This weakness must have been reinforced by the memories of those cursed enough to be able to remember such phrases as 'the pound in your pocket has not been devalued' and referen- ces to the IMF along with Phase 1, Phase 2, and so on of wage controls. If Labour confines it- self to the same old game (capitalism) and plays it by the rules, then many of the Party's natural constituency will opt to back those who invented the game in the first place.

Starting from the need for a radical economic policy, Ken writes convincingly and plausib ly on the need for a complete review of policies- economic, social, international and environ- mental - to empower and create a natural Labour majority, drawn largely from sections of the population at present marginal to the labour movement.

The central theme, strength and weakness of the book is the attempt to analyse the stagnation of the British economy and

prepare an economic strategy which goes beyond classical Keynesianism.

Britain, argues Livingstone, is the embodiment of a nation based on finance capital (much of Lenin's seminal work im- perialism, Highest Stage of Capitalism was based on the work- ings of the British economy. Con- scious decisions were taken 150 years ago to use the strength of the British economy (based on the 18th century slave trade) to create large free trade area within the empire. This cap tive market and source of raw materials cushioned industry and shifted the balance of economic power towards the City.

Both nineteenth and twen- tieth century investment patterns have been characterised by a

flight of capital away from

domestic development, which yields a lower return than foreign investment in low wage areas or completely 'unproductive' speculation.

The remedy proposed is to force the City to invest in domes- tic development, cut defence ex- penditure to the levels of other West European nations, thereby releasing £9 billion to create jobs via a programme of public works which would stimulate domestic demand. Allied to this would be a programme of skills training and research and development- an area where Britain has laged behind its competitors since the late nineteenth century.

Leaving aside such debates as "can we support any level of arms expenditure?', the question is can such a strategy work? What is absent from the book is the issue of ownership.

Nationalisation is usually men- tioned in the same sentence as "Morrisonian bureaucracy'; con- trol is seen in terms of planning agreements at the "carrot' end, while the heaviest stick proposed is that of punitive levels of taxa- tion.

To this extent the policy is less radical than the Alternative Economic Strategy of the mid 1970s. It is however a good deal more radical than Labour's Policy Review, which represents no challenge at all to the entrenched power of the City.

At root it is a populist appeal which ken poses - to some ex- tent as great a symptom of the rightward shift as the Policy

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

Page 31

VIEW

MAX

Days of

BYGRAVES

SingaLonga

waripars!

TART

15

Antrari tonil

* 11

TYL

BDD Songs

(after the end of the Stalin-Hitler

Pact in 1941) the struggle to

defend socialist Russia. There

was no suggestion from the Com-

munist Parties that this inter-im-

perialist war should be turned

into a civil war against the bour-

geoisie.

The class struggle at home

was suspended to fight the Nazi

threat. Class collaboration gave

the Communist Party its biggest

ever membership in Britain and

Labour swept to power in the

1945 General Election. With the

ideological ground effectively un-

challenged, it is not hard to see

why sugar-coated, sanitised

songs met with a success they

have retained ever since.

But then perhaps it is unfair 1o

heap yet another crime onto the

head of Joseph Stalin, even

though this is seemingly the most

popular new board game in Mos-

cow at the moment.

Max Bygraves may not be en-

tirely Stalin's fault: he could,

after all, be just another one of

those aberrations peculiar to

Britain's class structure and his-

tory of class struggle. Or maybe a

phenomenon, like fascism, which

the ruling classes only make use

of when all other political options

have been exhausted. It hardly

needs to be added that our slogan

for both should be 'Never Again'.

← No easy remedies for Nicaragua · Keeping the Dresden fires burning →

Something wrong on this page?