SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
Page 29
REVIEW
Dynamics
of an
Unfinished
Revolution
by
Alan Benjamin
BOLal
LOS DanEROs
CAMPESINOS
LIRAN
RASTAEL FIN
as that in Nicaragua.
Though the use of the market
(to one degree or another) is by
no means excluded as a tactic,
particularly in an under-
developed country such as
Nicaragua, this is not the same as
a strategic alliance with the bour-
geoisie.
Benjamin's work is informed
by the marxist notion that, par-
ticularly in such circumstances,
it is only the working class, in al-
liance with the poor peasantry,
that can be relied upon to free
such a country from the hold of
imperialism as a part of the strug
gle for socialism.
As such this book, though
fairly short and thus not entirely
comprehensive, contains a
wealth of information as well as
marxist analysis, and will prove
very useful to all those in
solidarity with the Nicaraguan
revolution.
Nicaraguan
crisis
Nicaragua - Dynamics of an Unfinished Revolution by Alan Benjamin (Walnut Publishing, San Francisco, 1989).
Available from Socialist Outlook at £5.50 including
Reviewed by Patrick
Baker
This book is a welcome contribut- tion to the debate among socialists around the develop- ment of the Nicaraguan revolu- tion. Largely based on primary research and extensive contacts with indigenous social research bodies - particularly the Managua-based ITZTANI in- stitute - the book analyses some of the key aspects of Nicaraguas development since the 1979 revolution.
The author, a leader of the US marxist organisation Socialist Action, is neither an un- critical cheerleader nor a simple commentarist. His critical ap- proach has led to unusually sharp polemics from some other US marxists - such as Paul Le- Blanc, a leader of the Fourth In- terationalist Tendency - who claims, among other things, that *Socialist Action comrades ap- pear to believe (in contradiction to Trotsky) that a socialist economy can be brought to Nicaragua and solve the country's most pressing problems without the spread of socialist revolution... '(1).
Such a comment is difficult to reconcile with the key con- cluding passage of the book 'Ex- tending the revolution: Key to Survival', in which the author • surveys the other Central
American revolutionary struggles, and concludes that "The fate of the Nicaraguan revolution is inextricably tied to the outcome of these struggles' (2).
LeBlanc's critique also ignores the main strength of Benjamin's analysis: his detailed ac- count of the Sandinistas' policy of class alliance in their attempt to shore up the ailing Nicaraguan economy, and the politi- cal and economic conse- quences of this policy.
From the beginning, Ben- jamin recognises the incredible strains and pressures that have faced this tiny, underdeveloped country: the Contra war, financed by the world's strongest imperialist power; the crippling economic consequences of this war, combined with the effects of the economic blockade, and minimal aid from the USSR.
Benjamin's does not argue that all these adverse circumstan- ces could be reversed simply through a voluntaristic turn by the FSLN leadership. However, he does argue that in such cir- cumstances the Sandinistas' policy of reliance on, and there- fore extensive concessions to, the Nicaraguan bourgeoisie, often at the expense of the work- ing class and poor peasantry, has not and will not improve the dire political and economic situation that the Nicaraguan people face. In addition, it has led to some friction between the Sandinistas' base in the rural and urban unions and the leadership.
Benjamin catalogues the various circumstances in which the Sandinistas have turned to such policies: in relation to the
agrarian reform; in response to pressure not only from the USA, but also such 'allies' as the USSR and European Social Democracy; and in relation to the Arias/Esquipulas 'peace plans'.
On each occasion, the Sandinistas' pleas for investment in the Nicaraguan economy on the part of the 'patriotic bourgeoisie' have fallen on deaf ears, and been met instead by decapitalisation and the flight of billions of dollars of capital to Miami.
Yet it is not only on a domes tic level that the Sandinistas have, on occasion, chosen some strange friends: they have hailed the re-election of the PRI in Mexico, despite their cancella- tion of vital oil supplies to Nicaragua; and the crushing of Solidarnosc, though they may have reconsidered when the Kremlin bureaucracy cut their aid programme.
The point of such criticisms is not to wave the Trotskyist Transitional Programme at the Sandinistas, but to point out that the bourgeoisie as a class cannot be relied upon - concessions not- withstanding - to shore up an anti-imperialist revolution such
NOTES (1) Understanding the Nicaraguan olution - P.LeBlanc, BIDOM 67, p. I5. (2) Dynamics pp169-170
Page 30
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
REVIEW
Livingstone: looking right or left?
Review. Aiming
against the
domination of
finance capital
through the Tory
government, he
ST counterposes
DON INDUR
Labour as the
party of produc-
tion - a phrase
which brings
back more
memories of Wil-
son and 'the
white heat of the
technological
revolution'.
Is industry Ken and Neil agree Labour is the party of production
straining, year-
ing to get out
from under under the iron heel
of finance capital? Or are they mostly members of the same multi-national corporations? At the end of the day, the old ques tion keeps coming back: what about the workers?
The failure to devise a truly socialist economic strategy based on public ownership and workers' control leaves the good intentions of both this book and the Party drifting rootlessly in the wake of a govemment which has increasingly set its own ruth- less agenda for the economy.
While we're in nostalgic mood, we should remember that even the 1974 Labour govern- ment came to power promising an irreversible shift in wealth and power in favour of working people. Ken doesn't even go that far.
Just some
reformist
rubbish?
Livingstone's Labour By Ken Livingstone, Published by Unwin Hyman, £12.95 hardback
Reviewed by Mick
Woods
The title of this review is Ken's inscription in my copy. Refor- mist - yes: