Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Keeping the Dresden fires burning

· Socialist Outlook no. 19, November 1989 · p 34 · 577 words

Dresden

fires bur

Singalonga WarYears! By Max Bygraves Parkfield Music, on record, video, tape and CD

Reviewed by David Grant

There is something truly appall- ing about this musical compila- tion of popular songs from the early 1940s. No, its not just the sound of Max Bygraves' voice. Neither is it only the monotonous tempo blending the first verse and chorus of one song into the next, nor the lyrics - which are a redefinition of the word bland.

If this was wartime entertain- ment aimed at keeping morale high, its no wonder everyone hoped it would be over by Christmas. Style and delivery of the music aside, there is some- thing genuinely disturbing about the content of this particular piece of fifty-years-on memorabilia.

In May 1945, JB Priestley wrote of Britain and the British during the previous six years:

«We had a glimpse then of what life might be if men and women freely dedicated themsel ves, not to their appetites and prejudices, their vanities and fears, but to some great com- munal task.'

The view, carefully nutured by the British ruling class, that the war had been a time of joint sacrifice, even egalitarianism, in the face of a common foe, remains the myth it always was. Despite changes brought about by the mass evacuation of inner cities and large scale recruitment of women into the wartime economy, the class structure of Britain, along with its petty- minded chauvinist ideology, remained firmly intact.

The testimony of many children who were evacuated to middle class families that treated them little better than drudges or the racism that greeted black US soldiers stands in sharp contrast

bing

to the senti- ments expressed in the White Cliffs of Dover.

Nonetheless, the myth of a classless Britain at war is a surprisingly en- during one. The unashamed TV advertising of this compila- tion, the photo of Max Bygraves on the

to be saying 'It was great wasn't

front cover - in which he seems

it?' - right down to the song with the chilling title, Let's Have Another One, reflect the unchal- lenged view of what the second world war meant to the British.

The fact that 55 million people died in the camage, that countless millions were uprooted, smashed physically or mentally is never even hinted at. Infact, it was all rather civilised, even fun. Sales, not protest, greeted the release of this tawdry little collec- tion. Why is this?

The crisis of humanity being, in essence, a crisis of proletarian leadership, is a notion that sup- plies one answer to this question, although doubtless Max Bygraves could turn this into a mind-numbing concept album too.

The first world war, fought be- tween 1914-18, was an inter-im- perialist war in which the working classes clearly had no in- terest in participating. The left knew this because Lenin, with the authority of the Russian Revolution behind him, said so. A gun was a metal tube with a worker at each end. The first world war became known as the imperialist war.

But only Trotsky called the war of 1939-45 the second im- perialist war. It became seen as the struggle against "fascist' Ger- many, or, according to Stalin,

earnest

awakening

Dead Poets' Society Film starring Robyn Williams

Reviewed by Valerie

Coultas

Dead Poets' Society is one of the few recent films that I've seen twice. Set in a disciplinarary American preparatory school in the early 1960s it portrays the

← Just some reformist rubbish? · Days of earnest awakening →

Something wrong on this page?