SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
ITS
UP PLEM ENIT
HEALTH
HEALTH
IN
THEIR
merton Hospital
HANDS
Graeme Cookson
LONDON
TAKING INDASTRTAD
WEIGHTING
ACTION In serlous need of solidarity: health workers fight for the whole of the working class
The Socialist Movement has just published the draft policy statement which is to be dis- cussed at the conference for socialists in the unions being organised in Sheffield on Novem-
ber 11 and 12. ALAN THORNETT reports. "On the one hand, the five years build solidarity with those in struggle adoped since 1982. What they intend of retreat which followed the and with those victimised in the to keep amounts to far greater attack miners' strike has now given way process"
on the trade union movement than
These extracts from the Introduc- was contained in In Place of Strife - to the more confident mood as
expressed in this summer's in- tion to the draft policy statement for Labour's anti-union laws defeated by
the Sheffield conference sum up the mass unofficial action against Harold
dustrial upsurge, with its series of bold purpose that makes it so impor- Wilson's goverment twenty years
remarkable strike votes expressed tant for trade unionists: it is above all ago. in the strength of the strikes that an attempt to organise and regroup a
It is this situation which makes followed. ... But on the other class struggle current that will take the conference for socialists in the hand, recent struggles show that up the battle for a wholesale shift of trade unions, called by the Socialist many of the features which have policy inside the trade union move- Movement for November 11 and 12,
been so destructive in the past are still present. The London Under- ground strike in classic fashion ended with a deal agreed over the heads of the rank and file by their leaders. The British Rai. strike
reducts, lut onusu kau sink¢ could have won much more by getting completely rid of the strings that were attached, and in
mannergy mamar our view the defeat of the dock- ers was due, in major part, to the failure of TGWU leaders to adopt a policy of defiance of the Tory anti-union laws".
«We have to reject compromises
and rebuild trade union strength on the basis of militant struggle to im- prove the wages and working condi- tions of trade union members, and
ment.
At present it is clear that, despite the important industrial upsurge in the summer and the likelihood that such action will be repeated in com- ing months, new realism remains the
dominant political torce in the Labour and trade union movement.
It was new realism which allowed the dockers to be defeated, and it was
new realism which pushed the Policy Review document through the Labour Party conference last month, with disastrous implications for the trade union moment.
Under the policy review, Labour, if elected in two years time - a
prospect which looks increasingly likely despite the Kinnock leadership - will keep (and seek to enforce) the bulk of Tory anti-union legislation
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 19, November 1989
so important. Recent struggles have showed fresh layers of workers join ing the fight against the employers and the Tory goverment; but there is no organised current to channel this development along political
lines, and offer an alternative line of leadership.
All previous initiatives for politi- cally-based rank and file organisation
in the unions have ceased to be effec- tive. The oldest, the Liaison Commit- tee for the Defence of Trade Unions (LCDTU) formed in the 1970s under the then united Communist Party, never achieved any real inde pendence from the 'left' trade union
bureaucracy, and has now dwindled in size, with its politics tied to the breakaway Communist Party of Britain (CPB). The Broad Left Or-
"Tony Benn still has a big
base of
support
amongst the
trade union rank and file
... the weakness has been that this
support has
not been
organised in between union conferences -
but the
Socialist
Movement initiative could mark a change
in that"
Page 15
3500
"We cannot accept the continued criminalisation of trade union activity. We must campaign for the complete repeal of all anti-trade union legislation adopted by the Tories since 1980 and for full restoration of immunities"
"The success of the conference must be judged by its ability to take further initiatives that will consolidate a class struggle left and strengthen the implantation of the Socialist Movement in the unions"
Page 16
SIU PPLE MEN T
ganising Committee (BLOC), always dominated by Militant and never gaining anything like the LCDTU's implantation in the unions, has ceased to function at a national level. The various 'Rank and File' initiatives which the Socialist Workers Party used to sponsor in the 1970s have also long been abandoned as the SWP, embracing the theory of a 'downtum' in class struggle has pulled back from any real challenge to the bureaucracy in the unions. There is clearly a vacuum, and the Socialist Movement, which is itself a political response to the development of new realism, is by far the best placed to take the kind of non-sectarian initiative to fill it.
Although the Socialist Movement has been weak in the unions it has the potential to develop. Tony Benn still has a big base of support amongst the trade union rank and file - as can be seen by the size of the fringe meetings he attracts at trade union conferences. The weakness has been that this sup- port has not been organised to fight for policies and in support of trade union struggles in between union con- ferences - but the Socialist Movement initiative could mark a change in that.
The draft policy statement published in adavance of the Novem- ber conference presents four central themes:
• developing a political struggle against new realism;
• confronting and defying the anti-union laws;
•i solidarity with those in struggle;
L the fight for democracy in the trade union movement.
These are clearly the key themes around which a fight-back against the right-wing should be organised They draw a line of divide between be. tween those who are for collaboration with the employers and compliance with the law, and those who argue for a class struggle line in the unions in opposition to new realism and class compromise.
Any sectarian attempt to narrow down the basis of the conference, and what comes out of it, to a list of "pure' propaganda demands acceptable to revolutionary socialists should be rejected. The task at the present time, with new realism in control of the bulk of the trade union movement, is to strengthen and support those fight- ing new realism in the unions and to build an organised new realist current.
The draft policy document puts it this way:
'The main purpose of this con- ference is to strengthen opposition to new realism at every level and to
begin to rebuild the unions through successful struggle against the employers and the government. The key to this is the democratisation of the trade union movement itself, par- ticularly through the maximum invol- vement and participation of trade union members."
It is also strong on the anti-union laws, saying:
"Socialists have to re-establish 'defiance not compliance' as the policy of the movement. The defeat of the dockers demonstrates once again that this is the biggest single problem faced by the trade union movement. One of the tasks of the Socialist Movement is to campaign to create the conditions which will make "defiance not compliance" a reality, because the trade unions will continue to be defeated while these laws are obeyed".
"It cannot be credibly argued that a trade union movement of nine mil- lion members affiliated to the TUC has no alternative but to comply with the Tory laws. Every time these laws are complied with, new ones are brought in - new legislation is being introduced in the coming years to challenge unofficial strikes and abolish the closed shop".
And it is clear on repeal the repeal of the laws by a future Labour government:
"We cannot accept the continued criminalisation of trade union activity. We must campaign for the complete repeal of all anti-trade union legisla- tion adopted by the Tories since 1980 and for full restoration of im- munities".
An important feature of the con- ference document is that it backs up its substantial section on trade union democracy by itself adopting democratic procedures - something which has not always been the case with previous such initiatives (where the final outcome has often been decided by the dominant political fac- tion well in advance, and bulldozed through by bureaucratic procedures and action from the chair). The Shef- field conference has been organised by a committee elected at the June conference of the Socialist Move- ment, and, significantly, the draft statement submitted (prepared by a sub committee, and circulated in ad- vance) can be amended at the con- ference.
The scope of the statement, 7,500 words with 22 sections, also breaks new ground for such a conference. It contains a substantial section on the employers' offensive aganst the trade
unions and the workforce, detailing many of techniques which have been developed over recent years, includ ing 'workers' participation', and new working practices and agreements. It has sections on solidarity, rank and file organisation, the changing nature of the workforce, new technology un- employment and training, low pay, privatisation, the NHS, and the attack on education and the education unions.
Probably the most important breathrough the conference makes over previous such initiatives is its treatment of a range of social issues as central themes for the trade union movement. These include issues facing women, black workers, and lesbian and gay workers in the unions. These are key themes for the conference, linked to workshops or- ganised by Women For Socialism, the Socialist Movement Lesbian and Gay policy Group, Trade Unionists Against Section 28, Labour Party Black Sections, and the NALGO Black Workers Group
The integration of the issues runs into the opening plenary where as well as Tony Benn, Betty Heathfield and other well-known speakers, the platform will include a speaker from the NALGO Black Workers Group and an out lesbian women speaking for the Socialist Teachers Alliance. It is the first such conference to have an out lesbian women on its opening platform.
The policy document also has a lengthy section on environmental is- sues, which it insists must be a part of the trade union agenda:
"Socialists have to reassert that protection of the environment is a trade union issue. The adoption of a wide-ranging document on ecology and opposition to nuclear power by the 1989 TUC Congress opens the possibility of building action on the ecology question in the tank and file of the trade union movement. Such action will build upon existing trade union action and policies"
Health and safety issues are also taken on:
"Health and safety, both in the workplace and in the public domain, has now become a major political issue. It can no longer be denied that Tory policy and philosophy, and the resulting drive for profitabilty at whatever cost, lies behind the series of tragedies witnessed over the past year in Britain".
And on international issues:
"The Socialist Movement believes that it would be necessary for a
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
SUPPLEMENT
socialist government to control the operation of financial institutions and large private companies. This policy is even more significant in the case of multi-national corporations - many of which are involved in the super-ex- ploitation of labour on a world wide scale. A socialist government should have power to confiscate assets or tax the operations of all muti-national companies and their operations".
It is clear from the amendments al- ready appended to the policy docu- ment that the issue of the European Community and the single European market in 1992 is going to be a major debating point at the conference. The main draft of the document, correctly sees 1992 as precipiating an attack on the working class across Europe as the big employers rationalse to adapt to the new conditions and take full ad- vantage of them. An amendment from Leeds gas workers fighting the 'Battle of Wortley Bridge'
a minority on the drafting sub-com- mittee however propose as amend- ment which says:
"The coming of the single European market in 1992 presents the trade union movement with a whole range of new threats and oppor tunities. On the one hand, the con- centration and socialisation of capital symbolised by the market represents a move forward in the organisation of production, creating new structures and links across national boundaries which can only be to the ultimate
Back to Basics
Trotskyism: the
politics of class
benefit of workers sharing common ur me me seen "As schools of war, the Unions
are unexcelled. In them is class interests...".
All these things are key debates developed the peculiar courage of which have to be taken on by the English" socialists in the trade unions as a part This is how Engels in the mid of the preparation of a political cur- 1840s summed up his admiration for rent which can confront new realism. the militancy and self-sacrifice of the The final version of the policy state early workers' movement as it battled ment when adopted may be published for existence in the teeth of brutal as a pamphlet, and the Socialist state repression. His Condition of the Movement's own structures will need Working Class in England chronicles to be strengthened to relate more repeated pitched battles between strongly to the trade unions.
strikers and troops, and the open -
In the longer term the success of often lethal - violent attacks of the conference must be judged by its strikers on scabs, including throwing ability to take further initiatives that sulphuric acid into scabs' faces. He will consolidate a class struggle left shows how the early unions were and strengthen the implantation of the formed because for week after week, Socialist Movement in the unions, year after year a reservoir of workers and build its influence with broad could be found who were prepared to lefts and sections of workers entering risk life and limb and to flout not only struggles. Our aim should be to en- anti-union laws but almost any law in sure that every bureaucratic order to mount their challenge to the manoeuvre and sell-out is exposed power of the employers. and combatted, and that sections However Engels did not idealise entering battle know that they do not these early union militants: he consis- have to fight alone. The Sheffield tently pointed to their political weak- conference will not achieve that in nesses, and the one-sidedness of trade one step: but it could be the crucial union struggle, which confronts
employers at the level of the starting point along that road.
workplace or company, but which
ggle
does not confront the ruling class as a whole or its state machine.
From these very earliest stages of working class organisation there has been a political tension, a contradic- tion within trade unionism which con- tinues as a major issue in today's ap- parently very different labour movement. The wing of the move. ment which looks to pursue an out right and uncompromising class struggle against the employers - a struggle which could, if politically developed and generalised, lead logi- cally to revolutionary conclusions - comes under constant pressure from the economic facts of life (the need, in the absence of an immediate revolu- tion, to cam sufficient to live from day to day under capitalism and from the larger section of workers who for the most part seck only to use trade union strength to secure certain con- cessions, reforms within the framework of capitalism. For this, normally majority, section of trade unionists, there is little or no thought of overturning the power and owner- ship of even one capitalist, let alone the whole system.
The tension between these com- ponents of the workers' movement is
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 19, November 1989
"Engels
consistently pointed to the one-sidedness of trade union
struggle,
which
confronts
employers at
the level of the workplace
or company,
but which
does not
confront the ruling class as a whole or its
state
machine"
Page 17
"it is self-deceiving to turn to an idealistic conception of the working class "rank and file" as some kind of fount of ideological purity ... It can be simply a glorified way of urging the rank and file to stay at a political level they have already reached on their own"
Page 18
SU P PLE SM IN T
by no means a simple or mechanical one. There is no 'pure' revolutionary class struggle wing to line up op posite a rival body of unadulterated reformists and class conciliators. On the contrary, trade union and other struggles over the decades have shown us that the same workforce under different conditions can be capable of swaying in either direction. Workers who at one point - given firm leadership - can be roused to peaks of class consciousness, self- sacrifice and militant action, can at other times vote reluctantly or other- wise to accept shabby compromise deals rather than pursue what they see as a hopeless or useless fight.
The pressures towards com- promise are most frequently developed into argued politics of class collaboration and a systematic line of confining workers to reformist demands by bureaucratic layers of full-time union officials and repre- sentatives, detached from the bitter realities of exploitation in the workplace, and finding a privileged position as professional go-betweens in dealings with the employers. But the same political and material pres- sures also bear down and find their reflection in many shop stewards committees and among the union rank and file as a whole.
This should not surprise marxists, who argue that in class society, the ideology of the dominant class is reinforced by material relations of power and material institutions shap- ing the conditions of daily life, and is therefore itself dominant unless con- sciously overturned through the development of an alternative ideol- ogy.
This is why it is self-deceiving to tum to an idealistic conception of the
working class "rank and file" as some kind of fount of ideological purity or
any automatic political answer to the
bankruptcy of bureaucratic trade union and political leadership. While
rank and file workers feel much more
acutely the pressures that drive them into struggle, only a fight to develop a
new political leadership in opposition
to their existing bureaucratic leaders
offers any way forward.
Anything else is simply a glorified
way of urging the rank and file to stay
at a political level they have already
reached on their own: indeed political
currents today whose political mes-
sage centres on a largely non-political
reliance on the trade union "rank and
file" tend to counternose this to any
serious fight within the unions or the
wider labour movement to expose and
replace bureaucratic leadership. Ultra-left denunciations and phrases can in this way conceal an abstentionist political line (of which one obvious symptom is a refusal to stand against the right wing for office for fear of winning and then becoming contaminated by class col- laboration!)
The marxist method consists in building on the inherent tendency to class struggle, the constant and recur- ring clashes of class interest between the union membership, the employers and the ruling class, and within this context raising demands and political analysis which generalise from but go beyond the experiences of those in struggle, to point towards revolution- ary political conclusions.
The politics of reformism emerge most strongly as an obstacle to class struggle at the moments of sharpest crisis. In economic recession, the reformist leader meekly kow-tows to the 'right" of the employers to safeguard their viability at the ex- pense of their workforce, urging workers to "tighten their belts' and abandon resistance to redundancies and speed-up. Likewise in war time, the reformist rallies to the defence of the capitalist "fatherland', patriotical- ly boosting the profits of the ruling bourgeoisie.
It was the reformist degeneration of the formally 'marxist' parties of the Second International, leading to their total capitulation in 1914 to the patriotic hysteria of World War One, which convinced Lenin and the Bol- sheviks of the need for a new, Com- munist International that would con-
sistently uphold the politics of class struggle and internationalism.
The new 'Comintem', formed in
1919 in the aftermath of the vic- torious Russian Revolution, recog-
nised the centrality of trade union
struggle, and went on to develop
detailed discussions and documents
on tactics for work in the trade unions
and wider workers' movement. These
tactics went back to the marxist start-
ing point, building on the class strug
gle dynamic within the unions, and
seeking to raise demands which could
form a bridge between the day-to-day
reformist consciousness of the large
majority of workers and the revolu-
tionary politics needed for the strug-
gle for power.
These demands, elaborated and
explained at some length in the
Cominter's Theses on Tactics, begin
from mundane trade union issues
such as defence of jobs, pay and
living, but lead, through struggle,
towards the reorganisation and revolutionary mobilisation of the working class at factory and neigh- bourhood level, raising the issue of socialism and state power.
Such demands were intended as a transition from fighting for improve- ments within capitalism to fighting for socialist revolution, and became known as transitional demands. They ran alongside a developing awareness among the early leaders of the Com- intern that the mass of workers who still remained tied to reformist trade unions and Social Democratic parties could only be won to revolutionary politics through a process of struggle. Their own experiences would teach them political lessons in a way that no amount of Bolshevik propaganda leaflets or lectures could hope to achieve.
It was not enough for marxists to preach the evils of capitalism and the virtues of socialism: it was necessary to fight with and alongside the broad mass of the working class, to forge a united front between the Communist Parties and the mass reformist or- ganisations on issues of key impor- tance to the workers; in which through common experiences the marxists could show the bankruptcy of the reformist leaders and prove their own credentials as an alternative leadership ready to take their place.
Unfortunately this method of working was derailed almost before it began, firstly by the early sec- tarianism and inexperience of many
of the new Communist Parties, and then by the bureaucratic degeneration
of the Bolshevik Party itself under the
influence of Joseph Stalin in the mid
1920s. Stalin's notion of the united
front was in this early phase to seek
cosy links with sections of
"sympathetic' trade union
bureaucrats.
Thus in Britain the promising
beginnings of a class struggle left
wing regroupment in the unions, the
Minority Movement, which formed a
national framework involving mass
support in 1924, was steered under the influence of the Communist Party towards a soft relationship with a group of TUC "lefts', especially the group which began to speak out in favour of unity between British and Russian trade unions and lent their names to the Anglo Russian Trade Union Committee.
The bureaucrats cultivated by Stalin significantly kept the Minority Movement at arm's length, and were to join the TUC right wing in the betrayal of the 1926 General Strike:
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
SUPPL
M E IN T Trotskyist-led Teamsters fought pitched battles in Minneapolis, 1934
but the Communist Party line right up to the point of the sell- out was to demand "All power to the General Council". As George Hardy, Communist Party member and secretary of the Minority Movement ad mitted:
"Although we knew of what treachery the right wing leaders were capable, we did not clear- ly understand the part played by the so-called 'left' in the union leadership. In the main they tumed out to be windbags and capitulated to the right wing. We were taught a major lesson; that while edevloping a movem to the left officially, the main point in preparing for ac- tion must always be to develop a class conscious leadership among the rank and file."
(G. Hardy: Those Stormy Years)
Of course the treachery of the TUC 'lefts' had not been entirely unexpected. Leon Trotsky, in casting a critical eye over the politics and orientation of the British CP had con- sistently warned of the danger of overestimating the TUC 'lefts' and underestimating the British working class. But he was even more ener- getic in combatting the next phase of Stalinist policy, which from 1928 o- wards switched abruptly from cud- dling up to 'left' (and not-so-left) reformist leaders to an extreme sec- tarian denunciation of social democrats as "social fascists'.
The root cause of Stalin's policy switch was not, as he proclaimed, the beginning of a new phase of world politics, a so-called "Third Period' of all-out confrontation of 'class against class' in which the reformist leaders were simply agents of reaction within the workers' movement: it was the onset of huge economic, political and social crisis in the Soviet Union itself. to which Stalin responded with brutal repression of the most prosperous section of the peasantry and a sudden switch to a crash programme of in- dustrialisation.
As a political rationalisation for
this about-face, Stalin announced the
"Third Period", and a bureaucratised Comintern imposed suicidally sec- tarian policies on Communist Parties in every country, which were directed to form breakaway 'red' unions and to abandon any form of united front with 'social fascist leaders. The policy of the united front was rewrit- ten to insist it could only apply 'from
below. , excluding the main mass leaders of the reformist organisations, and therefore on such a small scale as to make no impact on the broader layers of the social democratic workers.
The most catastrophic conse- quence of this 7-ycar phase of Com- inter policy, against which only the Trotskyist Left Opposition dared to argue consistently, was in Germany, where a massively organised, power- ful workers' movement was left cyni- cally divided in the teeth of Hitler's drive for power, and then crushed after the Nazis' preventable victory in 1933.
The bitter lessons of this historic defeat for the working class were learned only by the Trotskyist op position, which recognised that a Comintem which had followed such a bankrupt policy so blindly and un- questioningly, and which even after the German defeat made no attempt to analyse the errors it had made, was hopelessly bureaucratised and dead for the purposes of revolution. A new international movement would be needed to raise once more the banner of revolutionary marxism and offer Icadership to the working class.
As Stalin's subservient band of bureaucrats betrayed in Germany and then switched course yet again, lurch- ing in 1935 from ultra-left sec- tarianism to the crass class col- laborationist opportunism of seeking 'Popular Front' alliances with sec- tions of the so-called 'democratic bourgeoisie', the small forces of Trotskyism kept their eyes firmly on
the development of class struggle in Europe and the USA, and nailed their colours firmly to the mast of work in the trade unions. As early as 1932 a key text summarising the principles of the International Left Opposition insisted upon:
"Recognition of the necessity for systematic Communist work in the proletarian mass organisations, par- ticularly the reformist trade unions ...
"Recognition of the necessity to mobilise the masses under transition- al slogans corresponding to the con- crete situation in each country..."
(Writings of Leon Trotsky 1932-3, p 53)
In the United States, the class struggle principles defended by the Left Opposition were given a practi- cal expression by the struggles of the Communist League, led by James P. Cannon, himself previously a union organiser for the "Wobblies' (IWW, Industrial Workers of the World) and a member of the US Communist Party until he embraced Trotsky's critique of Stalinism. In the early 1930s the still tiny US Trotskyist for- ces, who had begun by concentrating exclusively on winning workers from
the Communist Party, found openings
to engage directly and play a leading role in industrial struggles, including strikes by hotel workers, but most significantly the huge unionisation drive in the trucking and warehouse industries from 1934 which tumed Minneapolis into a union town and recruited tens of thousands of low- paid workers into the formerly con- servative, craft-minded Teamsters
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 19, November 1989
"In the early 1930s the still
tiny US
Trotskyist forces found
openings to
engage directly and play a leading
role in
industrial
struggles,
including
strikes by hotel workers,
but most significantly
the huge unionisation
drive in the trucking and
warehouse industries in Minneapolis
from 1934"
Page 19
Further reading:
From Militancy to Marxism - ALAN THORNETT (Left View Books Teamster Rebellion (and three more volumes) - FARRELL DOBBS (Monad Press, New York)
Page 20
UP PLE M EN T
keenly followed by
Unity is Stre
Trotsky, who spelled
out boldly the need for
an action programme
coupled with the fight
for an anned workers'
militia to defeat the
threats from the fas-
cists.
The last issue of
Socialist Outlook con-
trasted the line of the
Trotskyists with that of
the reformist parties
and Stalinists during
World War 2. The line Fighting In Place of Strife, May Day 1969
of divide has remained
the class line in the years since the end of the war. Class battles in which Trotskyists have played prominent roles - on the Lon- don buses and the docks (1950s and 1960s), in the car industry and en- gineering (1960s and 1970s), in the NHS and hotel and catering (1970s and 1980s) - have repeatedly found the Communist Party lined up with the most conservative and right wing Layers of the trade union bureaucracy in opposition to escalation of the struggles or in implementing sell-out compromise settlements.
In Britain the Labour Party has had periods in govemment managing capitalism and periods in opposition advising the Tories how to manage it better. The unions have on occasion clashed with Labour ministers, (notably in 1969 over Harold Wilson's anti-union In Place of Strife proposals and during the winter of discontent' of 1978-79) but never embraced a serious socialist alterna- tive going beyond the pursuit of an- nual pay demands and piccemeal demands within the framework of an increasingly crisis-ridden capitalism.
The 1989 Labour Conference seems to have set the stage for yet another demoralising period in which a Labour government sets out to at- tack its own base of supporters rather than seek to overturn capitalism. It will be more important than ever to ensure that such developments are fought tooth and nail by a conscious, class struggle opposition in the trade unions.
The Communist Party of Great
Britain, which in 1951 at the behest of Joe Stalin renounced any revolu- tionary aspirations and embraced in- stead the Parliamentary policy of the British Road to Socialism, has con-
union.
The tremendous victories achieved under Trotskyist leadership in Min- neapolis and the American north west helped attract other class struggle for- ces, notably militants of the centrist American Workers Party led by A.J. Muste, who were engaged in unionisation battles in the US car in- dustry. The Communist League merged with the AWP to form the Workers Party, as a wave of sit-down strikes and pitched battles were fought against company goon squads, police and the National Guard in Toledo, Flint, Detroit and other car industry centres.
The lessons drawn from these pre- cious experiences of mass agitational work in the trade unions not only un- derlined the organic link between Trotskyist