Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Labour's plans for unions

· Socialist Outlook no. 19, November 1989 · pp 15-16 · 1,877 words

Trade unions Britain Labour Party

TRADE UNIONSUPPLEMENT

UN I O

SU P PL

KHO"

S6:100L

SAFE OUR SCHOOL MEALS

Kinnock' bandwagon seems rolling towards a collision with the unfons under a Labour government

In Place of Struggle:

Labour's plan for the unions

Since this year's Brighton Con- ference rubber-stamped the Policy Review document, the Labour Party has become committed to introducing anti-union laws com- bining aspects of In Place of Strife (which helped defeat the Wilson government in 1969-70) and the Industrial Relations Act, which helped bring down Ted Heath's Tory government in 1974.

The adopted text 'Meet the Chal- lenge Make the Change' sets out Kinnock's - predictably vague - framework for industrial relations legislation under a future Labour government.

Labour calls for the removal of the following aspects of post-1979 Con- servative trade union law:

n The right to selectively sack strikers even after proper ballots;

n Encouragement to employers to artificially split companies simply to avoid the effects of a primary dispute;

n The use of ex-parte injuctions and sequestration to prevent/stop dis- putes.

So far, so good (just about). But they then go on to say, on secondary action, that if workers have a genuine interest in the outcome of a dispute and democratically seck to

JANE WELLS

take appropriate sympathetic action in response to those in dispute they should be able to do so within the law.' "Genuine interest, and "appropriate' action, are unfortunately not defined.

Subsequent statements by Labour front-benchers have clarified the posi- tion: sympathetic action will not be deemed 'genuine' and 'appropriate' if the media don't like it. Miners will, promise Labour, not be allowed to picket in support of striking nurses, for example. Speculating on other restrictions in the Independent, Employment spokesperson Michael Meacher assured bosses at home and abroad: 'Would it be lawful for workers to refuse to handle imports from South Africa? ... Answer, no.'

The policy review also preserves the right of government and the courts to interfere with and prescribe on internal union affairs. "Union members', says the Policy Review, "should have the right to a secret bal lot on decisions relating to strikes as well as in the election of union execu- tives ... any union member should be able to appeal to an independent tribunal if a ballot has not been held.'

What they left out is most impor tant of all.

Labour's Policy Review fails to tackle the problem of unions' vul- nerability to unpredictable and expen-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 19, November 1989

sive civil action. Under the present system, unions can still be taken to court by employers even if all the legal procedures (balloting etc) have been observed. All the employers have to prove is that a dispute falls outside the court's own narrow definition of a 'trade dispute' (which the courts can largely make up as they go along), and that union's are

guilty of one of number of civil

wrongs ('industrial torts'). Common industrial torts include: inducing breach of contract, interference with al business by unlawful means; in-

timidation and conspiracy. New onesi

can be added as judges see fit.

Unless unions are made immune to these kinds of action, the courts will always be available for employer's spoiling actions to scup- per strikes. Unions did win completer immunity after 1906, but the Tories had severely limited immunity by 1982 (building on the Labour Government's more modest success in shackling the unions in the early 1970s).

All the Labour Party has to say on the subject is the meaningless for- mula of 'employees must have the right to engage in lawful industrial action without their unions being sub- ject to the sort of court action which can see all their unions' funds se- questrated and the money of union!

"Subsequent statements by

Labour front-benchers have clarified

the position:

sympathetic action will not

be deemed "genuine' and "appropriate if the media don't like it. Miners

will, promise Labour, not be

allowed to

picket in

support of striking nurses,

for example"

Page 13

"The TUC drew an important - if modest - marker for a future Labour Government. Less than four weeks later they stepped back and let Labour cross it"

"The unions have their view, but i will be the Labour Prime Minister" - Neil Kinnock

Page 14

S UP P LE MENST

members frozen.' Sequestration, they say 'is completely unacceptable; and it will not be part of our new con- structive framework of industrial rela- tions law.

But without the full and unam- biguous restoration of immunity, Labour's promises of a 'fairer future' for the unions is not worth the reams of paper it's written on. Labour know that - but are too timid to do anything about it. The unions know it, too.

Led by the TGWU and MSF, the TUC Congress in September tried to fill in the gap.

A huge composite was moved by the MSF and supported by other unions; including calls for 'immunity in Tort (civil law) for trade unions'. Supporting the composite in the debate, Bill Morris, Deputy General Secretary of the TGWU, said: "There can be no half-measures; there can be no tinkering. The Tory anti-union laws which sack strikers and drag unions through the courts must go. We need a new framework of Labour law". In the absence of any alterna- tive, even the right-wing ABU and GMB unions voted for the motion. It was carried unaninously.

The reaction by politicians and the press to the TUC's decision was swift and wholly negative. In reality, the motion carried did little more than underline the legal steps that would need to be taken to ensure that Labour's stated aims could be ful- filled. But "immunity' rings alarm bells and Labour's leaders already are nervous about their union links, and especially about being seen to let the unions stand 'above the law'. That was the Tories' immediate line of at- tack.

Conservative Party Chairman Kenneth Baker claimed that the unions were 'once again putting themselves above the law', adding that the 'weasel words' of Labour's Policy Review were now laid bare.

Neil ('I'm dead hard") Kinnock's cringing response was to point out that Labour and the unions are separate bodies with separate policies and that "The unions have their view, but I will be the Labour Prime Minister'. Unnamed •Walworth Road officials' (read Peter Mandleson) made statements to the same effect.

Michael Meacher tried to argue that the TUC position was compatible with Labour's (much to the delight, goes the rumour, of the Labour leader, who is expected to make use of this to argue that Meacher's lack of judgement/left-wing leanings make him unsuitable for membership of the

Shadow Cabinet). The GMB General Secretary John Edmonds and the AEU President Bill Jordan, once they had caught on to the significance of what had slipped through, condemned their own decision as 'unwise' and *dangerous'.

All this, of course, helped pile on the pressure for the Labour Party Conference. Press speculation about a pre-conference stich-up and climb- down by the unions once they realised the error of their ways, (again fuelled by Walworth Road), was rife.

Unfortunately the press got it right this time. Stitch-up and climb-down there was. In compositing, the offend- ing 'immunity', originally tabled by the TGWU, disappeared. Emergency resolutions welcoming the TUC decision were ruled out of order; and left-wing motions demanding the removal of all post-1979 laws and the right for unions to write their own rule books were defeated - heavily.

Instead delegates and, most impor- tantly, most of the unions (including the 'left' TGWU and MSF), opted for an anodyne formula which called for a "fair and positive framework of in- dustrial relations legislation' but com- mitted the Party to no specifics.

Bill Jordan of the AEU used the opportunity provided by the debate to hammer home his own brand of new realism which in effect set the tone of the compromise reached on the issue:

fluid the Policy Review and the Wilson

"Today's party is a party of law makers, not law breakers." It was left to Arthur Scargill to point out the similarities between the proposals in

Govemment's In Place of Strife' anti-trade union legislation.

Meanwhile, following top-level talks between Labour and the unions, a joint statement by the TGWU and Michael Meacher was issued, "clarifying' Labour's proposals. In fact it was intended to confuse the issue and to bury any clarity so deep that it could never be dug out again.

What the statement says is that the status quo on immunities will be retained. Labour would tighten up some of the legal definitions and procedures currently used to trap unions, but they will still be vul nerable to civil action and to (limited) sequestration. The current powers of judges to keep inventing new liabilities for unions and to apply punitive sanctions will be reined in. New specialist courts, including lay representatives, will be set up to ad- judicate on these issues, reminiscent of the National Industrial Relations Court set up under Ted Heath's

union-busting legislation.

What the statement means is no commitment to repeal Tory trade union laws; no right to strike (only limited protection under the 'trade dispute definition) and more se questrations (just 'fairer' ones!).

Why are Labour's leaders so touchy on this - just as the trade unions are enjoying an unprecedented popularity following some successes in the summer of discontent, and as Thatcher is increasingly seen to be acting unreasonably and vindictively towards them?

The fact is that Labour's leaders want these laws - deterrents, sanc tions and all. A Labour Government with Kinnock's policies - just like the Wilson and Callaghan administra- tions before - will need its trade

its economic union laws policies are in tatters and it goes back to the working class and asks it to foot the bill for a few measly reforms with wage restraint other

How to respond and fight these es- sentially right-wing policies does pose an awkward question for the likes of Ken Livingstone, and for those who argue that Conference sovereignty has to take precedence, even over socialist principles, whatever the effect those decisions might have on the working class in the real world. In the event of a Labour Goverment, watchword then become, not 'wait for the Labour Government", but down and shut up until the next con- ference - we'll sort it out then?'

The TUC drew an important - if modest - marker for a future Labour Govemment. Less than four weeks later they stepped back and let Labour cross it. It is in the nature of the beast that is a union leader to pronounce a principle one day and to do a deal to dispense with it the next.

Labour's 'democracy' is likely to be the next casualty - as a direct con- sequence of the U-tum on trade union legislation. Insulating the Labour Party from the organised working class follows logically from protect- ing Labour in Government from the working class.

The challenge now - to defend conference and the union link, and to reverse Labour's disastrous rightward drift - can only be met by a left prepared not only to organise itself, but to address itself politically and or- ganisationally to the working class as well.

← Behind Broadwater Farm raid · Arming for battle against new realism →

Something wrong on this page?