Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Trotskyism: politics of class struggle

· Socialist Outlook no. 19, November 1989 · p 22 · 576 words

Trotsky Stalinism Marxism

politics and the class strug- gle, but also laid the basis for further development of the system of transi- tional demands taken forward from the early Comintern. In particular the Teamster strikes and the car industry battles developed practical experience of workers' self-defence and of strike committees.

Other lessons were also leamed in the struggles against Stalinist and reformist politics. In the fight for a united front policy against Hitler in Germany and the attempt to develop agitation around an altemative workers' plan to meet the economic and social crisis, the issue of workers' control of production was further developed. This was also strengthened from the experiences of the workers in Barcelona and other parts of Spain as they took control of industries in the fight to defeat Fran- co, while the Stalinists lined up alongside the so-called 'democratic" bourgeoisie to oppose workers con- trol and murder the most class con- scious militants. In France, too, militant sit-down strikes and the es calating governmental crisis were

tinued since the war to cuddle up to

sections of the trade union bureaucracy in the hopes of increas ing its own influence. The CPGB has

itself now split into warring factions, focussed around rival publications - the more overtly right wing Eurocommunist Marxism Today (CPGB) and the more traditional Stalinist Morning Star (now run by the Communist Party of Britain). But it was only a few years ago (in 1983) that both wings were united in silenc- ing class conscious youth shouting anti-Tory slogans on the People's March for Jobs, for fear of offending the various platforms of bishops, big- wigs and anti-Thatcher Tories' as- sembled as part of this latter-day Popular Front.

While Marxism Today has now shifted its ground so far to the right that it offers political guidance for the Kinnock Labour leadership, the Morning Star has set out to hold its base of support in the unions (and in the union bureaucracy) by projecting the image of a class struggle wing This has led to some interesting if fleeting alliances between Morning Star supporters and Trotskyists, and now the involvement of the Morning Star and the Liaison Committee for Defence of Trade Unions in the Socialist Movement and its Trade Union Conference.

Of course unity in action against the Tories and the employers' offen- sive must be built on the broadest possible basis: where the policies of the Morning Star coincide with the interests of the working class and the demands of other left currents it would be unprincipled not to strike together. However history shows us that such coincidental agreement can be short-lived, and that the legacy of Stalinism in the unions is a far from happy or progressive one. While socialists should welcome any forces making a genuine break from Stalinism, there must be no attempt to fudge over genuine political differen- ces.

The development of a new current of marxism in the unions as the con- scious alternative to Stalinism and the blinkered politics of reformism and "non-political' trade unionism is the key issue for the British workers' movement. Hopefully the escalation of class struggle under the combined hammer blows of inflation and Tory government attacks will open fresh opportunities for marxists to reach in- dustrial and other workers, showing practical solidarity, explaining the manoeuvres and waming of possible

sell-outs by bureaucratic leaders, and putting forward a more developed political programme for the battles to come.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

← Arming for battle against new realism · Gorbachev versus the workers →

Something wrong on this page?