FEATURES
(...) Was all the destruction pointless?
The legacy of World
War Two
The legacy of destruction left by World War Two is staggering. Eighty million people were killed, if one includes those who died of starvation and illness as a direct result of the war - eight times as many as during Worid War One. Dozens of cities were virtually to- tally destroyed, especially in Japan and Ger- many. Material resources capable of fooding. clothing, housing, equipping all the poor of this world were wasted for purely destructive purposes. Forests were tom down and agricul- tural land converted into wasteland on a scale not witnessed since the Thirty Years War or the Mongol invasion of the Islamic Empire.
Was all the destruction pointless? Has in- temational capitalism emerged from World War Two with all the fundamental contradic- tions which led to the conflict unresolved - not only structurally, but even conjuncturally? Many observers would have categorically denied such a statement ten years ago, when it seemed that in contrast to the inter-war period, the international capitalist economy had ex- perienced two decales rin the Anglo-Saxon countries, nearly three) of unprecedented growth, interrupted only by minor recessions. and long historical period of high levels of employment and impressive rise in the material standard of living of the toiling mas ses in the imperialist countries.
Today it is obvious that the twenty to twenty five years of the postwar boom were only an interlude, a "long expansive wave of the capitalist economy following the "long depression' of the inter-war period, which will itself be followed hy a "long depression" of even longer duration thar the 1913-1939 period.
To be sure, that interlude witnessed a new leap forward of the productive forces - the third technological revolution - and a great in- crease in the material wealth and average skill and knowledge of the international working class, not to mention a big expansion in the number of wage-camers. Even if the material and intellectual progress was very unevenly divided as between the more and ess developed capitalist countries, it enlarged the base from which world socialism can be built. The material preconditions for a socialist world of plenty and a global withering away of the social division of labour between "bosses" and 'bossed' were much more con- siderable in 1970 than in 1939, let alone 1914. They are even more so in 1985.
At the same time, however, the price humankind must pay for the delay of world socialism. for the survival of decaying capitalism, becomes more and more frighten- ing. The tendency for the productive forces to be transformed into forces of destruction not only asserts itself periodically in crises of over-production and world wars. More and more it asserts itself unrelentingly in the fields of production, consumption, social relations, health (including mental health) and above all in the uninterrupted succession of "local' wars. This global price in human suffering. death and threats to the very phyxical survival of humankind is again staggering. It outstrips anything seen during the First or Second World Warx....
"The perversion of human consumption and human wants through profit-oriented standardised mass production is imposing a growing burden of illness and death upon humankind... And the threat which poisoned
air, seas, water and forests pose to the very physical survival of humanity is similar to the threat of nuclear world war.
In that sense, the Second World War in- deed solved nothing, Le. removed none of the hane causes of the intensifying crisis of sur-
vival of human civilisation and humankind it- self. Hitler has disappeared, but the tide of destructiveness and barbarism keeps rising, al-
beit in more variegated forms and a less con-
centrated way (if World War Ill can be
avoided).
For the underlying cause of that destruc- tiveness remains. It 1s the expansionist dynamic of competition, capital accumulation
and imperialism increasingly tured against it-
self, ie. boomeranging from the "periphery" into ente with all the destructive potential this expansion and self-assertion liar- bours in the face of growing resistance and defiance from millions, if not hundreds of mil-
Lions, of human beings.
Ernest Mandel
Trotskyists and the War
At the start of the war, political adherents of Leon Trotsky and the Fourth Interna- tional, who insisted on continuing the class struggle and opposing the class col- laboration of the 'war effort" in the Allied imperialist countries, were a small, per secuted minority.
Their rectinn of the skin-deep "democratic" credentials of the imperialists. and their insistence that only a mobilised working class could, thrugh revolutionary ac- tion, establish genuine peace and democracy in Europe, clashed head on with the reformism of the social democratic parties and Stalin's total opposition to revolutionary struggle in
yists
Europe which, if successful, could swiftly des- tabilise his own bureaucratic grip on the Soviet working class. Stalin was also at pains to demonstrate his 'respectability" to his im- penalist allies: as a gesture in this direction. and as a symptom of his hostility to the spread of revolutionary struggle, he dissolved the Third International (Comintem) in 1943.
As the war progressed, however, the im- position of draconian attacks on trade unions and other democratic rights, and the reemer- gence of class struggle - in battles over wages
soon vindicated the and conditions Trotskyist analysis. And, ax German im- perialism hegan to suffer military defcats. across Europe, and capitalist state power
weakened its grip, the instinctive response of the working class was to reorganise inde-
pendently and take local power into its own
hands- only to be fiercely opposed by the
Stalinist and social democratic parties.
The class line of the