Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Extracts from Mandel and Trotsky

· Socialist Outlook no. 18, October 1989 · pp 29-30 · 1,156 words

Trotsky Trade unions

Trotskyist view is per- haps best summed up in the following extracts from two Fl Manifestoes:

"A Bandit War"

"All the ruling classes of the capitalist countries are bandits. Their war, whatever the pretensions and hypocritical slogans, will be a war between bandits. It will not he a workers' war, but on the contrary the workers, and the exploited in general, will be its victims. It will not be a war for democracy, since true

senden"

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

Page 27

democracy for the masses can be won only in the struggle against capitalist

lomination Even

democratic rights which the masses still enjoy can- not be preserved or ex- tended, as the example of the Spanish Civil War has shown. by methods of revolutionary class strug gle for socialism.

It will not be a war in

interests of thr workers, since the attacks on the social conquests of the French workers of June 1936, especially the 40-hour week, show that detence of the most elementary economic and social unterests of a masses - their daily bread and their freedom - is in- comnutihle with the dete

the

except

militant,

United in opposing revolution: Churchlll with Molotov as the 'allles' begin to divide up the territorial spoils

of the bourgeoixie.

Hitler. who destroved

each country, and of soldiers with soldiers on the opposite side of the battle front; we mobilise the women and the youth against the war; we carry on constant, persistent, tireless preparation for the revolution - in the fac- tories, in the mills, in the villages, in the bar- racks, at the front, and in the fleel...

(Leon Trotsky, Manifesto of the Fourth In- lernational on the imperialist war and the proletarian world revolution, May 1940)

Carrying such a line into practice meant rejecting pacifism and soctarianism and rocog- nising the need to fight with and alongside the working class - in the army in war as the marxist fighis in the workplaces in peacetime. Trotsky, in conjunction with leaders of the US Socialist Workers Party boldly set out the basic line for the small forces of revolutionary marxism in what became known as the "proletarian military policy":

"Militarisation now goes on on a tremen- dous scale. We cannot oppose it with pacifist phrases. This militarisation has wide support among the workers. They bear a sentimental hatred against Hitler mixed with confused class sentiments. They have a hatred against the victorious brigands.

The bureaucracy utilises this to say help the defeated gangster. Our conclusions are com- pletely different. ... We must oppose sending untrained boys into battle. The trade unions must protect the workers in peaceful times and protect their industrial skill, but they must now demand the possibility of leaming the military art from the state.

For instance in the trade union we can argue like this: I am a socialist and you are a

German and Austrian working class, is leading the struggle in the name of capitalism against the interests of the peoples of Europe. In the midst of war threats we emphasise once again that the main enemy is in one's own country. The working class has no fatherland to defend except where it conquers and rules. No support to the war makers and to imperialist war - we say - but the continuation of the class struggle in every situation and the utilisation of the war crisis for the overthrow of capitalist rule, i.e. the overthrow of the war and of capitalism it- self!"

all wxcial gains of the oking clown. ix leading of capitansm against u.. of Eurone. In the

Against Imperialist War!,

(Manifesto: adopted at founding conference of Fourth In- temational, 1938)

*..We do not forget for a moment that this war is not our war. In contradistinction to the Second and Third Internationals, the Fourth In- temational builds its policy not on the military fortunes of the capitalist states, but on the transformation of the imperialist war into a war of the workers against the capitalists, on the overthrow of the ruling classes of all countries, on the world socialist revolution.

The shifts in the battle lines at the front, the destruction of national capitals, the occupation of territories, the downfall of individnal states, represent from this standpoint only tragic episodes on the road to the reconstruction of moder society.

Independently of the course of the war, we fulfill our basic task: we explain to the workers

of the war we to the workers

the irreconcilability between their interests and the interests of bloodthirsty capitalism; we mobilise the toilers against imperialism: we propagate the unity of the workers in all war- ring and neutral countries; we call for the fraternisation of workers and soldiers within

patriot. Good. We will discuss this difference between ux But we should agree that the workers he trained at govemment expense to become military experts. Schools should be ser up in connection with the trade unions - at government expense hut under the control of

the trade unions. This kind of approach would give us access to the workers, who are 95 to 98 percent patriotic even at the present time...

..."We can say to the workers; We are ready for revolution. But you aren't ready. But both of us want our own workers' officers in this rituation. We want special workers" schools which will train us to be officers..."

(Loon Trotsky Discussions with Trotsky,

June 19401

Trotsky claborated further on this approach in several articles and interviews, including the following explanation, directed specifically at the situation in the USA:

"Now the national feeling is for a tremen- dous army, navy and air force. ... To some ex- tent this will also be true of the workers.

That's why we must try to separate the workers from the others by a programme of eduction, of workers" schools, of workers' ol- ficers, devoted to the welfare of the worker army, etc. We cannot escape from the militarisation, but inside the machine we can observe the class line.

The American workers do not want to be conquered by Hitler, and to those who say 'Let us have a peace programme, the worker will reply "But Hitler does not want a peace programme." Therefore we say: We will defend the United States with a workers' army, with workers officers, with a workers government, etc. If we are not pacifists, who wait for a better future, and if we are active revolutionists, our job is to penetrate into the whole military machine...

Furthermore our comrades should be the best soldiers and the best officers and at the same time the best class militants. They should provoke in the workers a mistrust of the old tradition, of the military plans of the bourgeois class and officers... In this epoch, every great questive, satlonu or anternational, will be resolved with arms - not by peaceful means.

Page 28

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

← Trotskyists and World War 2 · Growing Greens pose challenge to the left →

Something wrong on this page?