Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Ten years in the life of the Labour Party

· Socialist Outlook no. 18, October 1989 · pp 23-27 · 5,686 words

Labour Party Lesbian and gay Britain

IN DEPTH

The downhill road to Brighton '89

TURNING FULL CIRCLE

irty

ILP. NOLS. IWC, Clause 4, Labour Action for Peace, Militant, and the LPYS. The Tribune Group refused to join.

In May 1980, on the initiative of the TGWU, the NEC called a spo- cial conference to aiscuss Labour » programme Peace, Jobs and Frocdom". This left programme was adopted by all sections of the party, including Callaghan. Yet the most significant event of the con- ference was probably the lunch-time launch meeting of the RFMC. Over half the conference delegates attended to hear Tony Benn. The RFMC held 20 meetings around the country between the end of August and conference, building support for the constitutional changes and produced several bulletins.

Benn himself became radicalised by his experience as a Minister. seeing Labour's programme blocked hy a combination of senior civil servants and Labour's leadership. It wasn't until 1980 that Benn ac-

sntL. 1980 that Benn ac tually joined the Tribune group and lent his support to CLPD's

his support to CLPD'

demands; he remained a member of Labour Cabinels, accepting collec demands: he remand a mammer tive responsibility, right up until the defeat in 1979. In 1981 he was not

err in 1981 ne was not even a member of the ICC, widely seen as the "Bennite" grouping.

"Bennite groupine

The Commistion report in June 1980 first raised the idea of the

st roused the idea of the leader being clected by an electoral college, even though until then it

though until unen it had always been posed as election by conference. The left, organised

The left. organised in the RFMC, took a tactical decision to support it as the only realisti-

port it as the wuy realista- cally winnable option.

The January 1981 special conference saw the lefl eventually win out with its proposal of 40 percent for the trade unions; 30 percent for the PL and 30 percent for the CIPs - against altematives giving a vir- tual veto to Mi's. The key to this victory was the unity around limited aims achieved by the RFMC

Control of the manifesto by the NEC was never won, despite being

As the Left at this year's Labour Party Conference contemplate yet 'another fine mess', while Kinnock's careerist team revel in the latest poll figures, PETE FIRMIN chronicles the political changes since Labour was last in office - and the role of the Left.

The Last Labour Governments

The Labour governments of 1974-79 under Wilson and Callaghan were a disaster for the working class. The IMF, NATO and multina- tionals dictated policies - cuts in social spending, three years of wage- cutting 'social contract", and vigorous support for NATO (and Polaris). To prop up his majority Callaghan made pacts with explicitly anti- working class forces: first the Liberals and then a deal with the Ulster Unionists.

The final collapse came with the "Winter of Discontent' of 1978. 79. when section after section of workers went into battle against the government's 5 percent limit on pay rises (which Labour Party con- ference and the TUC had both rejected in 1978).

Left organisation

From 1966 until the mid-70k, the Trune group of MPs was the main opposition grouping in the party. It called for the whole party to elect the leader and for the NEC to have greater control of the manifes- to. While most of its members were critical of the Callaghan govern- ment and voted against many of its policies in parliament, whenever this was followed by a motion of confidence they buckled and sup ported the leadership.

Frustration with the Tribune Group's purely parliamentary roic and dissatisfaction with its holding back in its attacks on the Icadership were factors leading to the founding and growth of new groupings in the 1970s.

The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy (CLPD) held its first meeting at 1973 Labour Conference. Its statement of aims said that conference policy decisions should be binding on the Parliamentary Labour Party and urged the National Exocutive Committee to ensure that Labour's election manifesto accurately reflected policy as ex- pressed by conference decisions. CLPD grew rapidly in the late 1970s.

The Labour Co-ordinating Committee, formed in 1978 by former co-workers of Tony Benn's in the Department of Industry, grew quick ly to a membership of 1,000.

Democratic reforms

Pressure developed around three important areas of constitutional change even before Labour lost the 1979 election. These were the right of CLPs to select their parliamentary candidate, whether or not they had a sitting Labour MP, the clection of the Leader and Deputy Leader by the party as a whole; and control of the manifesto by the NEC.

Mandatory reselection was passed in 1979. 1979 conference also set up a Commission of Enquiry to report not only on constitutional changes but on the general functioning of the Party.

In response to the threat from this Commission of Enquiry, the left set up the Rank and File Mobilising Committee (RFMC) to continue the fight for the changes. On the initiative of Socialist Organiser (at that time the paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory) this included nearly all the left organisations in the Party - CLPD. LCC.

tually joined the Tribune group and lent his support to CLPD's demands; he remained a member of Labour Cabinels, accepting collec

treat in

auw the tell eventually win *ade unions 30 percent for Inst alteratives giving a vir- was the unity around linuted

passed in principle in 1980 and 1981; the necessary constitutional amendments were narrowly defcated.

The Right desert - and fight back

Shortly after the special conference of January 1981, the "Gang of Four" Labour renegades issued their "Limehouse Declaration" and in

a 'Limehouse Declaration' and un March the Social Deniocratic Party was formed. During the course of 1981, 28 Labour MPs defected. The introduction of accountability to their CLPs and removal of their sole right to elect the leader was too much.

Shortly after annual conference in 1980 had adopted the principle of the election of the leader by the party as a whole, but not decided how, Callaghan resigned as leader. The left fought for Michael Foot, the deputy leader, to become acting leader pending the implementation of the clectoral college, but the PLP voted 2-1 to proceed with a full

NEI

passed in principle in 1980 and 1981; the necessary constitutional

never won, despite being

~ nocessary constitutional

«ox Lad adopted the principle

au a whole, but not decided

..tr. I elt fought for Michael Foot.

eung leader pending the implementation

....2'Lr need 2-1 to proceed with a full

election. As a holding operation those left MP's who supported the con-

stitutional changes voted for Foot to keep out Healey.

Denis Healey, most associaied with the 1974-79 govemments, was

still deputy leader. In April 1981. Tony Benn announced he was stand-

ing against him. Most groups in the RFMC threw themselves into this campaign, with fringe meetings at every union conference and mass rallies around the country. So much was this campaign around policies rather than personalities that the campsign was maintained at the same high level even when Benn was ill and unable to participate.

Healey scraped home by 50.426 percent to 49.574 percent on thie second ballot. The votes of 4 more MPs in the second ballot would

ne pany

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

Page 21

IN DE have recured the deputy leadership for Benn. 16 Trihunites (led by Neil Kinnock) abstained in the second round, while 4 voted for Healey.

But the right was far from finished. Not all of them had left with the SDP. The left had been making gains on the NEC ever since 1972,

controlling it since 1974. In 1981 the right were triumphant: 5 right controlling

wingers replaced 5 left wingers creating a fragile balance of power on

the NEC. Foot and his allies on the 'soft left" (Kinnock and Lestor)

he NEe Font

and.-

were able to frustrate many left wing moves.

The witch-hunt takes off

Reg (later Lord) Underhill, national secretary of the Labour Party. had been agitating for the NEC to publish his documents on the

"infiltration" of the party by Militant. At first refusing, the NEC even- tually succumbed when Underhill, on retiring, released his report to the press anyway. In December 1981 the NEC commissioned Ron Hayward, the new general secretary, and David Hughes, the national agent, to investigate the activities of Militant.

In January 1982 the NEC and Trades Unionists for a Labour Vic- tory held a meeting at the ASTMS educational school in Bishops

ASTMS educational school in Bishops. Stortford. A deal was done to present an appearance of unity in the face of the Tory government. The left on the NEC felt relieved at the out- come - not a single constitutional change had been agreed, no specific. move against Militant or parliamentary candidates had been agreed and expulsions seemed a long way off. Reality showed that it was the left that was prepared to 'mark time", not the right.

Within a week of the Bishops Stortford meeting the organisation

sub-committee of the NEC ordered Sunderland North CLP to rerun its selection of Boh Clay and, shortly after, the NEC rejected Pat Wall's selection for Bradford North.

The Hayward-Hughes report, presented in June 1982, asserted that Militant was "a party within a party", hut avoided proposing simple ex- pulsion, calculating that such an obvious witch-hunt would be unac- ceptable to conference. Instead they proposed that the party set up a register of recognised gmups within the party, and made clear from the start that Militant would not be eligible - and therefore Militant sup

porters could not be members of the party. The decision to establish porters could the register was opposed by most CLPx and regional conferences, but carried with the support of the anions.

The issue of the register certainly had one of the desired effects of confusing the left, which failed to organise either for a united fight against the register or for the crucial NEC elections in 1982. Labour Liaison '82 - an attempt to unite those propared to continue the fight against the right's offensive - collapsod in disarray. By this time Tribune and the LCC were effectively calling for a witch-hunt of some of the more secretive sectarian organisations

The right won a clear majority in the NEC elections, and then used its majority to remove the left from all important NEC committees, with Foot ahstaining.

Disarray on the left accelerated after the passing of the register (by

5 million to 1.5 million votes at 1982 conference). CLPD was caught in 5 million tr 15-. the trap of its own policy of the sovereignty of conference decisions. and was never to be the same force again. The LCC described the register as a shambles, but still decided to register.

The Tribune Group voted 39-27 (with 6 ahstentions) to register,

*ed 30-27 (will D ahstentions) to register, resulting in the resignation of its chair and secretary and the eventual formation of the Campaign Group of MP's in December 1982, hacked

paon (roup of MI's in December 1982, backed by 23 MPs. Tribune newspaper became for a period a paper of the for left.

self held a Taur- Committen Againue ne W was a Miutan® Mil:

Drevealt a witch-sunt continued. Miliant it- seprember 198: • nut the "Labour Steering

•. despite non-Militant Ngureheads,

insen method of fighting the witch-

out action. The only other thing

hunt. as in cater ven they were inter

Because Miutan x. posed to the witch-nun Its founding meeting and unions It adopted a pos

they were interested in was self-advertisement.

avertisement. • organise seriously with all those op ur agaunst the Witch-hunt was formed. - 1082 nad 300 delegates from CLPe

st nop-m operation with the

"Labour

PT H uno a renusal to expe South, when to tiw members.

Because of Minan advisers told it to restnct editonal mart. her en

sporters. Be

instance Ishington Peter Tuate 1o be

Because of Militant's legal actions, the Labour bureaucracy's legal advisers told it to restrict expulsions to the 5 members of the Militant editorial hoard: but the witch-hunt was by no means restricted to Militant supporters. Bermondsey CLP selected Peter Tatchell as its parliamentary candidate. Provoked by an SDP MP. quoting from an ar- ticle by Tatchell in London Lahour Briefing which argued for extra- parliamentary action against the Tories, Michael Foot declared in December 1981 that Tatchell wnuld never be endorsed as a Labour candidate

After a long and bitter campaign, Tatchell eventually won selection a second time and was endorsed by the NEC. Bur the damage was

sha NEC. But the damage wao done. The media was given 'open house" to attack Tatchell, not only as an extremist, but also for his homosexuality. Disowned by the lender-

ship, slandered in the press and undermined by the Party NFC, ship: slandered Tatchell lost heavily to the Liberals in early 1983.

Foot's disasters - then Kinnock arrives

Foot's eventual endorsement of Tatchell meant that he was then pil- loried for backing down. The press began to speculate about Foot resigning

Foot's political concessions to the Tories were shown most around

the Falklands/Malvinas war in April 1982. Foot encouraged the the Falklands/Malvi... goverment to send the Task Force, and Lahour competed with the Tories for jingoism. Nor was there a left campaign against the war. The first vote in the Commons on 20th May was after 6 debates: only 33 Labour MP's voted against the govemmient.

When Labour lost the general election in 1983 with 27.6 percent of the vote to the Alliance's 25.4 percent (Labour's lowest share of the vote since 1918) it was hardly surprising. The media had spent its time promoting the SDP/Liberal Alliance, the party had been riven hy a witch-hunt under an apparently lame-duck leader. On top of all this Callaghan, the ex-leader, attacked Labour's policies on disarmament.

Foot resigned soon after the election. Orchestrated by Clive Jenkins

ureaucracy - rega ers of the Militant -ane restricted to

Militant sun parliament

chell

i Tatchell as

SDP MP. quoting Irr Jing which argued 1 - Michaer Foot declared ever be envorsed as a Labour

envemmient.

triu erection un 198y with 27.o percent ot

west share of the

•wid spent its time

nalty had heen nyan hi

leader. On top of all 1

polices on disarmament.

hestrater hv Clive Jenku and Moss Evans, the TGWU & ASTMS executives

executive. wuch ju happened' to be meeting on die sane day as Foot announced his resig- immediately declared their support for the "dream ticket of Kinnock and Hattersley, even before they declared they were standing! Coincidentally. Benn, the most credible left candidate, was unable to stand for election having lost his seat after boundary changes.

Eric Heffer stood as leader und Michael Meacher (then a member of the Campaign Group) as deputy. Some on the left had their doubts about supporting Heffer hecause of his poor record on abortion rights. others disputed whether Kinnock should he supported on a later round (against the right's Peter Shore) if Heffer was eliminated, because they felt, rightly, that Kinnock was a 'stalking horse" for the right. Kinnock won easily on the first round, with Meacher, the candidate of the left for deputy, voting for him! A sign of the shift that had already taken. place was that Kinnock got 91.5 percent of CLP votes, despite the fact that he had been generally despised only a couple of years before.

Kinnock's election widens Left split

The split in the left - hetween "hard' and 'soft - widened after

hetweer mard' ane "soft" widened wer

Kinnock's clection. The "soft" lefl - led at constituency level by the

LCC and with Ken Livingstone ax its most prominent national

proponent - argued that the left needed to 'cuddle up" to Kinnock to

keep him out of the arms of the right, ignoring the fact that he was ac-

"New Realisn" had been growing in the unions - having sold out

ASTMS

Kinnock . - LCC and with Ker proponent keep lum tually tea

keep him out of the arms of the right, ignoring the fact that he was ac- struggles against the Tories the union leaders declared that struggle was futile and the unions needed to rescind their policy of haycotting

out of th une the ri

"New

naving sold aut ed that struggle , of haycollins

In the Lahour

s moderation"

was futile bipartisan nodk Party it meant th

bipartisan hodies and begin talking to the govemment. In the Lahour Party it meant they gave full support to Kinnock and his "moderation"

was held up somewhat by

miners' strike and the support given to it by union and constituency se-

tivists as well as the left on the NEC. Kinnock gave as little support 1o

ot poucies.

The advance miner strike ar tavists as well..

"miment

Page 22

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

IN DE

strike as

to speak at miners rallies on

denouncing

linc No better example exists

No better examp of the educative nature Of

brought about in the miners?

cion by their strike. In 1983 wotan delegate had con-

plained from the rostrum of

harassment by the miners" delegation. In 1984

NUM supported the demands for democracy par forward

hy women and black sectons, and Antish withdrawal from Ireland.

1984 conference passed

resolutions. often radical against the advice of the NEC condemning pole behaviour during the miners strike, against local authority

und opposing the Prevention of Terrorism Act and the use of no-jury courts, plustic bullets and su-

pergratses in the North of

Ireland. Yet although the lat- ter was passed by 3 million 1o 2.5 million against NEC advice, only 450.000 votes

vast British were withdrawal.

The frst serious attempt to introduce a form of 'one member one vote for parliamentary selec- fion was, to the surprise of many, defeated. Not only would political levy-paying trade unionists have been disenfranchised at a stroke, bot the utter hypocrisy of the move was shown in that it was only to apply to sitting MPs!

The Miners lose and Kinnock hits back

In the late: 1970s auld carly 1980s the left had operated as a cohesive block on the NEC, The break up of this unity and the policy gains of the right accelerated from the end of 1984 and during 1985, with Sawyer. Blunkett and Meatier (still a member of the Campaign Group) increasingly voting with the right. Kinnock began to dismantle the policy-making role of the NEC, handing it over more and more to the Shadow Cahiner.

In early 1985, after a call by Lahour Briefing, Labour Left Co-or- dination was formed involving Briefing, CLPD. Black Sections. LCLGR. Labour Women for Ireland, Labour Committee for Ireland, Militant and Labour Herald of the left papers ignored this call, LLC Militant and Labour Herald on the left papers agnored this call. LLC look important small steps around support for particular issues.

With the miners" strike over. Kinnock uxed hix plutform at 1985

conference to attack the NUM and Liverpool Council, one of only too

Labour Councils which had alternpled to carry out conterence policy on resisting rate-capping. Kinnock's speect dominated, yet Tribune declared after the conference that the left has never been stronger and the prospect of a radical left wing Labour govemment has never heen radical socialist policies'. Livingstone. the darling of the LCC after his

sell-out of the rate-capping strugele, was describing Kinnock and

Whity as *a new partnerstup that will fomm an effective

leadership

The left did win on

the indemnification of unions, lesbian and

gay rights and remos- ing MP~ conscience

clause on abortion, but

programime

Partnership. A

New Britain' put for- ward at 1985 con- ference contained no mention of socialism: instead there were phrases like partner- ship not confrontation" and a new sense of common purpose,

Back us 1983 a resolution calling for Positive: action in favour of black mem- ners had been referred In the exocutive. majonty favoured Black Sections on the same basis as the YS and women's sections, but instead a "Black and Asian Advisory Committee was set up which was In be un- elected and have a purely advisory role on organisational'

only. The

New

the

Peter Tatchell: a 1963 victim of Foot's attempts to pander to bigots and the media

matters BAAC was baycotted by Black Sections and the left, and collapsed.

A renewed witch-hunt

Kinnock's attack on Liverpool Council was the clarion call for the next major stage of the witch-hunt. Liverpool District Party was suspended by the NEC in Noverher 1985, and 9 members (all sup: porters of Militant) eventually expelled belween May and October 1986. This time the LCC on Merseyside led the witch-hunt, while others on the soft left allowed themselves to be blinded by the accusa. tions of intimidation'.

Lahour Against the Witch-hunt "86 was formed to fight the spread- ing purge, but met problems from two quarters. Militant, having given up even a show of fighting the witch-hunt other than by court action, was willing to do no more than send speakers to meetings and con- ferences. The new factor was that scctions of the 'hard lefl" disputed the need to defend Militani, claiming that, because of its reactionary positions on women's liberation, the Irish struggle and black and les- bian and gay politics, it was not really on the left. Insidiously, the defence of Amir Khan and Kevin Scally who had been expelled from Hattersley's Sparkhrook constituency was counterposed to the defence of Militant supporters.

This went alongside the smashing up of LL.C, and its replacement in May 1986 with Labour Left Liaison, by those intending to for an alliance with the "soft lett' ror, at best. its "hard" end). Socialist Action and CLPD.

In 1986, Kinnock concentrated on his programme for a right wing Lahour govemment. The shift to the right continued with Eric Heffer losing his NEC place. The CLP's now voted 2-1 in favour of expul- sions.

Page 23

The left did win some important victories - the demand for a future Labour government to set up a Ministry for women was passed against the NEC's recommendation, and the lesbian and gay rights resolation achieved 79 percent of the vote. Unilateralism was reaffirmed, together with yet another call for a real" campaign around it, but conference fudged the issue of nuclear power.

By this time Livingstone was bemoaning the fact that his 'realign- ment of the left' (around Kinnock) had failed, and was openly express ing the unsaid desire of the LIL. for a new alliance of sections of the hard left with the LCC.

1986 conference saw another new development. Labour Women's Action Committee (formedy part of CLPD), which had been in the foretront of the ampug for democratic women's structures, switched to providing the most vocal support for a review of women's organisation to be carried out by the NEC! L WAC either had to build links with women in struggle and take up the fight within the unions or it could wheel and deal with union leaders to get 'the best possible From the consultation. Its leaders chose the latter course.

By this time the witch-hunt was so rampant, with CLP's and regions being given the green light to expel whoever they wanted, that the poor NEC claimed it was not able to cope with the workload of dealing with the cases and appeals and a National Constitutional Conmittee was set up.

produced by some members of the LCC steering committee and LLL reaffirming left policies, to the outrage of the right of the LCC and Marxism Today. But again this consisted only of demands on a future Labour government, and despite holding one of the largest fringe meet- ings, nothing more came of it.

Phase I of the Policy Review, passed at 1988 conference, was

"iterence. War bland, laying out Kinnock's basic principles in support of market

ur support of market socialism, "helping companies to meet the challenge of the next

hallenge of the next decade. But it war accompanied by constitutional changes which hadn't been discussed throughout the Party in advance, which removed important democratic rights. All party membership applications were to be centrulixed, the support of 20 percent of the PIP (increased from 10 percent) was to be necessary to nominate for a leadership challenge, and the NEC was given the right to impose hy-election candidates (the rule change used to remove Martha Osamar as a candidate for selec- tion in Vauxhall in the search for a 'safe", white candidate who sup ported the leadership's policies).

A 'National Youth Campaigns Committee" was set up on which the LPYS was to be a monty and which would elect the YS repre- sentative on the NEC. The Black Sections resolution was yet again defeated, although it won the support of NUPE. Victories were won against the leadership - a commitment to one woman on every shortlist (which the NEC opposed): a national minimum wage and a 35-hour week; opposition to the goverument's Employment Training: and

unilaferalism was reaffirmed,

Everyone knew that Phase II of the Policy

Review was to be the crunch. Kinnock signailed

well in advance that it would be ditching

Labour's commitment to unilateral nuclear dis-

armament. The debate at 1988 conference,

though Kinnock would have liked to have won.

merely tested the water.

The Benn/effer campaign for the leader- ship in 1988 was a welcome opportunity to organise opposition to the Policy Review and rampant new realism. Meetings around the country drew large audiences and breathed new live into left groupings. Yet the result was dismal. Partly, this was inevitable in that due to the defcats in struggles against the Tories the left was weak. But there were other factors over which there was more direct control. The candidacy was declared late, so that although there were fringe meetings at many TU conferences, there was not time or the campaign to get the policies dis- cussed throughout the TU branches in advance. The Campaign Group itscif was divided on fighting the clection, with many preferring to try and build an alliance with the soft left.

1989 has seen the Policy Review with its acceptance of market forces launched with a fanfare as if it were already conference policy. while existing conference policy (on lesbian and gay rights and unilateral nuclear disarmament) has heen ignored.

Kinnock and most of the Party see Labour's success in the Euro- clections and higher standing in the opinion polls as a result of the Policy Review. Yet it coincides with the Tories" problems with the economy and the unpopularity of their next round of privatisation. - water and electricity - together with their attack on the NHS. and the impending implementation of the Poll Tax. Labour would almost in- evitably have risen in the polls in this situation.

The decline of the Alliance (and its component parts since it fell

omponent parts since it tell apart) is down to Labour stealing its "moderation" and the media fcel- ing it no longer has a need to promote it against Labour's 'extremism. The other aspect of the unpopularity of the Tories, the upsurge in the class struggle, has produced no support from Kinnock, who told the

•port trom Kumock, wao told the railworkers to call off their strike, and has refused to support even the "safest" and most popular of industrial action such as the nurses.

Some Conclusions

The watch-word in the Labour Party during most of the 1980s has been that the left shouldn't "rock the boat", that we have to maintain Party unity in order to win elections. The right only accept Party unity on their terms - the 'unity of the graveyard" where the membership are

aning the tact that his 'realign-

failed, and was openly express LL tor a new alliance of sections of the

The review" of the LPYS saw Socialist Youth dropped, regional YS conferences and committees closed down and national conference cancelled. The age limit was reduced from 26 to 23, thus excluding half the membership. Militant and much of the left put up no real fight against what has virtually meant the death of the YS.

One of the major successes of this period was

of this penod was the drive by Black Sections, supported by the left, to get black candidates selected for the general election. Eventually 4 Black MPs were elected, a major ad. vance which was somewhat soured by the witch-bunt by the leadership of Sharon Atkin, who was removed as a candidate by the NEC for the

"crime" of stating the truth that the Labour Party is a racist party:

Defeat in 1987 - enter the Policy Review

After 4 years of pushing the party to the right and the witch-hunt, Kinnock only managed to increase Lahour's vote in the 1987 election by 3 percent compared to 1983, 11 percent behind the Tories. He proceeded to blame the defeat on the hard left, gayx and blacks, and now felt it opportune to go for the long-expected frontal attack on policies: the two year Policy Review was initiated to by-pass the nor- mal policy-making process.

In 1985 Hattersley had called for, and got, unanimous support for a resolution committing the party to extending 'social ownership". By 1987 an NUM resolution calling for privatised companies to he re- nationalised was defeated by 3.9 million to 2:4 million and conference only pledged itself to taking back Telecom and Gas. 1987 conference also adopted the constituency electoral college for parlinmentary selec- tion, introducing one member one vote for individual party members.

Yet, even in this period policy gains were made by the left. Vigorous campaigning by the Lahour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights meant that conference had its first ever debate on the issue in 1985, passing a resolution against the advice of the NEC on ending dis crimination and unjust laws by 3.2m In 2.8m with the support of the TGWU and NUM (the latter influenced by their strike and the support given by 'Lesbians and Gays support the Miners'), 1986 conference reaffirmed the same policy with unanimous NEC backing and achiev. ing 79 percent of the vote, well over the two-thirds needed for in clusion in the manifesto. In 1988, a resolution reaffirming existing

- resolution mattirming existing policy, calling for the repeal of Clause 28 and a commitment to posi-

coltunitment to post- tive images of lesbians and gays by Labour councils, 84 percent sup- port was won with only the electricians (EETPU) and engineers (AEU) opposing-

Prior to 1987 conference a 14-point statement for "left unity" was

4-DoInt

"The upturn in the class struggle should now be utilised by the left to bring In new forces to break the circle and enable us to fight

and defeat the right wing"

meer t

FIT DrE

committee and LLL

neht of the LCC and

if demands on a future it the lareest fringe meet-

Page 24

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

content with their role as canvassers and the right get on with making policy.

In the PLP and NEC there have been those "lefte" prepared to criticise so long as this

lotta as this criticism could remain within safe limits - as soon as it threatened their own position, in volved organising wider forces or they were accused of 'rocking the boat', they beat a hasty retreat.

One of the weaknesses has been the failure to use the democratic changes won. Only 8 descloctions of sitting MPs took place by the general election of 1983. No clections at all for leader and deputy leader took place be ween 1984 and 1987, despite this being the period of the most rapid moves to the right.

When democratic machinery falls into disuse it is easier for the right to attack it.

Kinnock's drive to remove all vestiges of left policies and left influence has been in line with the interests of the ruling class. They prefer a Tory goverment: but if the Tories are unpopular they are prepared to have what they consider a "safe Labour govemment, expe- cially as such goverments have in the past proved more succeseful in disciplining the working class than the Tories during periods of heightened class struggle.

The strength of the left in the Labour Party cannot be separated from the strength of the left in the unions. While many union leaders sup ported the democratic changes in 1979/80 and Tony Benn's deputy leadership challenge (many only under pressure from their member-

Wax -oscly connected to

rejection of Labour's pay policy and inten- tion to bring in anti-union laws. But as this faded into the past and the reality of a class. struggie Torv government emerged, these leaderships rapidly retreated. Demonicy threatened to spill over into the unions, put-

ting their own privileges in danger: and the altemative to supporting the Labour leadership's moves to the right was to or-

ganise seious resistance to the Tories, some-

thing they were not prepared to do. Joh Kinnock hasn'• finished. Having

sanitized policy through the Policy Review

he wants to make sure that the left can

never again attain the strength it did in 1979-81

The past ten years have shown, above

all, how much the fate of the left in the

Labour Party is linked to developments in

the class struggle. The impetus for the post-

-ement with Labour's policies in

te the truggle against the Tones

i the working class and

muon leaders for adequate

You ain't seen nothin' yet! The dream duo of Kinnock-Hattersiey still have more plans

79 changes came from goverment. Bur deleats... and employers reduced ine wildin removed the pressure in Labo.. and trade policies.

The uptum in the ... notably the newly launched SocI. the Chesterfield conferenc and enable us really to fior

vika svt... w he ntilsed by the lell -

« Movement that has emerged trom

"oW forces to break the circle

Back to Basics:

Don't

← EDUCATION IN CRISIS · Don't mention the War! →

Something wrong on this page?