Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

EDUCATION IN CRISIS

Socialist Outlook no. 18, October 1989 · pp 21-22 · 1,125 words

Education

Education and regional demos

NOVEMBER 29: Anti-loans demo

called by NUS

London area

Page 19

SUPPLEMENT

Cort Taylo JUILD

ECURT

period are cracking and crumbling. with as yet nothing clearly coming Forward to replace them. This crisis of leadership has permeated every level of the student movement. Local stu- dent unions are retreating into effi- cient service provision, demoralised by the violence of Thatcher's attacks and disillusioned by the failure of the NUS leadership to stand up to them. Politics is out, and 'student unionism" is in.

"Loans are not ridiculous, they deliberately alter the concept of higher education, excluding still wider layers of people from its already narrow corridors. It is the NUS leadership who are ridiculous"

Page 20

The force which has provided the leadership of NUS for the last five years - the "Democratic Left' (a soft left grouping in the National Or- ganisation nf Labour Students (NOLS)) is more than ever revealed as politically bankrupt. The last year. has witnessed a sharp fall in the num- per * lunctioning Labour Clubs. dramatic internal schisms and poor election performances. The DL now relies on alliances with forces to its right, such as the eurocommunists and various independents to keep

control.

Its strategy to combat the Tory of- fensive has proved woefully inade- quate, more and more pursuing a line of tactical retreat. This year's proposed loans campaign represents the nadir of this line of capitulation, the central slogan being 'Ridiculous ideas No.1 - Student Loans!", accom- panied by a Heath Robinson illustra- tion. Loans are not ridiculous, they deliberately aller the concept of higher -ducation. excluding still wider layers of people from its al ready narrow corridors. It is the NUS leadership who are ridiculous.

However, the main opposition in

the Sneralist Organiser. dominated Socialist Students m NOLS (SSIN), is in no better state. Having thrown away its opportunity to take control of NUS with a series of strategic blunders - such as the 'femocracy" debate, where SSiN suc-

STIN

cessfully alienated whole layers of its supporters in the liberation campaigns with its opportunistic opposition 1o women's autonomy and reactionary accusations of women activists using sexism and heterosexism to further their careers - the trend is clearly downwards. An orientation to captur- ing the bureaucracy while ignoring the base will always be fatal, however well you manocuvie, and recent of- forts to revitalise and reunite SSiN such as Left Unity have failed to draw in any new activists or rise above being an SO froat. The decline seems terminal.

The history of these two opposing groups is inextricably linked. They both came to prominence on the backs of Bennism in the Labour Party and have at times been defined more by the fact that they are opposed to the other rather than any positive programme. This is particularly true of the DL which has been very inter- nally heterogeneous, held together only by a hatred of Trotskyists, It is thus. not suprising that their downward trajectories are roughly parallel - indicating the dim view of Kinnock's Labour Party prevalent in the student movement, and that you can only fool people for so long.

The only growing force in NUS are the "independents" in which category the Greens currently fall as they have as yet no organisation or clearly delined political identity). As the name suggests, this covers a broad spectrum of political views, but they are on the whole part of an apolitical drift in the student movement, work- ing hard to serve students' immediate needs within the paramelers set down by the Govemment - cheap beer, wel- fare services etc, and shunning politics and especially political or- ganisations as part of what they see as wrong with NUS. They consistently find themselves allied with NOLS against mass action.

The interal decay and political barrenness of much of NUS can be clearly seen in the development of the liberation campaigns. Previously one of the most dynamic sectors of the movement, forging ahead with new ideas, new debates and new struc- tures, it was the strength of these campaigns that ensured that NUS had such progressive and radical policies on. for instance lesbian and gay liberation and a woman's right lo choose, long before other national or- ganisations.

However, the interal culture of these campaigns has hecome stifling and the women's and lesbian and gay

campaigns in particular are sinking

into the mire of identity politics.

Though activists on the ground con-

tinue to work hard and enthusiastical-

ly in their colleges and areas the

amount of support and hack-up they

receive from the national organisation is minimal and largely directionless. Now the liberation campaigns are used and abused at Conference as

pawns in what has become a battle for survival, with scant attention paid to the autonomy we have fought so

long and hard for.

However, the severity of the government's altacks not only on students" immediate standards Living but on the education system as a whole has a very deep radicalising potential, some of which was demonstrated during the last year. The old Robbins principles - that higher education should be available to all those who can benefit from it - have such strong support that even those students who will have left education by the proposed date of in- troduction of the loans system will fight strongly to defend them. Despite the efforts of the NUS bureaucracy to defuse action and dampen the anger. last year saw a wave of action and radicalisation an the colleges. the most obvious point of which was the police charge on the November 24 demonstration. This anger will retur with a vengeance as actual legislation on the proposals begins to be dis cussed in Parliament.

The Socialist Movement can play

an important role in these develop- ments, as an exciting. dynamic left force in the labour movement. through which students can build links with other socialists in practical activity. The open structures the Socialist Movement is developing

can also enable students to participate

in a range of discussions on wider is-

sues which are so often absent from

- important m"

student politics.

Mass action against loans, linking with the labour movement, is the only strategy that will defeat the Tory at- tack. It is a strategy that must be fought for against the present NUS Jeadership: but the structures of NUS must not be ignored, for what we are working for in the largest possible mobilisations, the greatest and widest

number of people involved. That

could best be achieved with the sup-

port of the leadership. The signs are

that the hureaucracy's grip on the

tion is slinping: things are

moving in the right direction.

Rebecca Flemming.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

← Tories give students the third degree · Ten years in the life of the Labour Party →

Something wrong on this page?