Life's not so grand in the Rio Grande ... for victims of US immigration control
*Corpses of Nicaraguans slowly appear. The cadavers of a group of Nicaraguans who were forced to throw themselves into the river by the criminal "pateros" (river- crossing smugglers; slowlv appeared floating in the waters of the Rio Grande ... the pateros who saw the police coming shouted to the Nicaraguans 'throw your- selves into the water, here comes the police. only a few saved themselves: the majority went down in the Rio Grande'
"The body of a woman ... was found dead and recovered from the waters of the Rio Grande near a place called Las Piedras ... at first sight she did not presen signs of violence, nonetheless the coroner established that she had bled from her private parts, in- dicating that she could well have been attack- ed with some object'
It is perhaps irrelevant from the point of view of those on the immediate receiving end of immigration controls to argue that restric- tions in some countries are worse than in others. However the enforcement of controls on the USA/Mexican border, particulariy in the Rio Grande valley, is a shocking indict- ment of immigration laws generally. It is also a salutory waming of the extremes to which controls in the UK are also rapidly heading.
The above quotations, taken from border newspapers, show how refugees and migrants from central America are confronted with the twentieth century equivalent of a shark-filled moat, namely the Rio Grande, infested both by gangsters and "la migra' (the colloquial name for the US Immigration and Nationality Ser- vices, the INS).
In the Rio Grande there is a powerful racist lobby supporting controls - the thetoric of which finds strong echoes in the UK. In November: 1988 the alaried officials of
which includes
County.
Cameron Brownsville, the horder crossing town closest to Mexico, passed a resolution against un documented aliens on the grounds that they
Fighting a tide of state racism: anti-racist demonstration in Georgia
put a strain on social services, diminished the quality of life, and increased crime. lt re- quested the state legislature of Texas to purge aliens trom the voter molls
One official proclaimed: "We don't know what diseases these people are bringing in ... all they are here fur is to get on relief. County Judge D.J.Lerma announced that "The words on the Statue of Liberty don't tell people to run across the Rio Grande illegally. The Statue of Liberty in fact speaks of the USA welcoming the "poor and huddled masses', hut of course it was erected at a time when the US as an immigrant country was actively en- couraging more immigrant lahour.
Proyecto Libertad
The main source of legal help for refugees and migrants in the area is Proyecto Lihertad (PL). This is an immigrition law centre hased at Harlingen, just outside Brownsville, where the INS also has its local headquarters. PL's October 1988 newsletter gives vivid exaniples of the operation of immigration laws in the Rio Grande.
It shows how difficult it is for refugees to obtain asylum at all, descrihing one successful case this way: "Joc Guerra, a Salvadoran stu- who had distrihuled leaflets for the Movimento Estudiantil Revolucionario Sal- vadoreno (MERS) fled the country after a friend disappeared. he was granted axylum by Judge Vomacka, making him only the fourth Salvadoran asylum granted in the valley to a PL client in 7 years'.
PL is fighting cases alleging INS violence. One case is being fought under the Federal Tort Claims Act on behalf of Jose and Josefina
ELEE
Ruiz, a Mexican couple who were taken off a freight train by Border patrol agents near Har-
lingen. Josefina, who was pregnant, was
Ruiz, a Mexican couple who were taken off a
agents near Har-
Was preguant Was noxcar by agents. and
she telt pain, bed her precanc" When
statuen. Jose Was
PL also highlights the undercover world of
parastic immugration advisors generated by immigration controls The PL newsletter explains that what is happening is that the rip-off artists, notary publics, includ.
a number of Nicaraguan number
('frecdom fighters"), are charging refugees ex- borbitant prices for what basically amounts to. translating asylum fons, Since the INS won't allow refugees to apply in Spanish, the huck- sters crowd people into motis and rip them
off for thousands of dollars for "permiss"
(permits). They do not explain the asylum
process, and in fact often fill out the foms in such a way as to undermine a person's claim.
Chronology of victimisation
The history of the Rio Grande valley in the
last five years has been one of the INS and its
Border Control Agents constantly tightening
the screw, with only occasional and temporary
beaten by agents.
Pl: alen nigh
bogus.
00.... •Pensa:
ishis ann undercover
legal restraints. Indeed in 1984 the Harlingen
INS office declared that it would not even
lodge 'affirmative" asylum applications - that
is from central American refugees simply
turing up and making applications.
This policy was in breach of both the
United Nations Convention on Refugees, and the Uniled States own 1980 Refugees Act. The consequence of the policy was that
Th Blaita.
ifturm
Page 10
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
FEATURES
ENDORSES * PASSAIC COUNTY SHERIF OFICES
PATERSON
% CORRECTION OFFICERS LOCAL 197
ISHa
OGE)
Bush courting votes from the law and order enforcement community: now the Rio Grande has been turned into a concentration camp
refugees had to wait to be arrested and go to court to ask for asylum: the only exception was for Nicaraguans. In July 1987, then Attor- ney general, Edward Meese, issucd a directive that Nicaragun should be given favourable Ircatment in axylum applications. This in itself is a clear indication of the political motivation hehind the USA's treatment of refugees: no asylum for those feeing US backed military
Rio Grande valley while their applications were being considered.
Refugee applicants resorted to living in trees, under hushes, in primitive camps, aban- doned buildings and church shelters. Even the local Senator, Llovd Bentsen. failed Democratic candidate for Vice President and
aul known for any advocacy of me
said thai "They are turn
dictatorships in El Salvador, Guatemala or Honduras, but a welcome for those leaving Nicaragua, whose econnmy has boen devas tated hy US-hacked Contras. As late as Fehruary 1988 a Guatemalan woman assisted by Pl. in filling out an asylum form was told to leave the INS office because "Guatemalans
can't apply only Nicaraguans', She was later
Texas intes n massiv detentiun
this policy-
In addition to this, the INS declared that
work authorisation would be refused to ap- plicants. This is similar to the little-publicised provision, hidden away in the Schedule, of the Eatest 1988 UK Immigration Act, whereby denial of work authorisation can for the first time he made a condition of temporary entry. Such laws are in contravention of Article 17 of the UN Convention, which obliges govern ments to protect refugees' rights to engage in gainful employment
The 'legal massacre' of
February 1989
On February 20, the head of the INS. Commissioner Alan Nelson, flew personally to Bownsville lo publicise a new action plan" for south Texas: This read like a doclaration of war on relugees, It called for an expedited
ajudication on asylum slainis .. the asylees are just pour-
mediate detention of those who do apply and are refused.
told wuls
Asa result of pressure and campaigning by PL and the Incal refuge Rights Coalition, the
affimative applications from other central
Between May and December
1988 there were over 27,000 axylum requests
In response to this, the INS decided to launch its own 'alien invasion' scare cam paign. Omer Sewell, its local director, claimed that the INS was like 'the Dutch boy with his finger in the dam, except we don't have our
ing through here. According to the Sun An- tonio Espress: Border patrol agents xaid the
Haru.
accepting ser centrat
December
new policy has hampered their efforts to con- trol the horder. Backed up by this propagan da, the INS in southern Texas announced a new policy in December 1988: all people ap plying for asylum had to stay physically in the
The "action plan" involved an increase of at least 500 new INS personnel just for lie Harlingen district - comprising 269 more Bor- der Patrol agent: 74 INS din support staff: 30 nore dete
tion workers; 16 special agents; and 141 INS,
State Department and immigration court per-
sonnel. Parallel to all this would be u massive
prison allocation programme.
To house the in apoctea number of
detainces, the INS was to erect a tent city at its
Port Isabel Service Processing
(PISPC), near Bayview in Texas. There was to
he provsion for 5,000 people. There were to
he 200 additional places at Webb County retents facility and several hundred
detainces would be sent to El Paso. In addi-
tion there would be "soft detention', sub con- tracted private facilities, mainly for families with children, where detainees could theoreti cally go out, but would be subject to daily roll-calls: one such centre was to be the Red Cross Shelter in Brownsville.
Nelson "justified' this quite incredible plan by saying that the new measures would "send
a strong signal to those people who have the
mistaken idea that by merely filling frivolous asylum claim they may stay in the United States, This wilful manipulation of
America's generosity must stop.
On Fehruary 21, a day described by PL as
"a legal massacre", Nelson's scenario became
a reality. Of the 233 applications processed on
that day, only two were granted - both
Nicaraguans, 215 were refused and im-
mediately imprisoned in Port Isabel. 16 were
given two weeks to produce further documen-
tation. Interviews lasted only 30 or
minutes, and lawyers from PL were forcibly ejected when they attempted to advise refugees in the Port Isabel prison tent city. This denial of legal help to refugees was con-
trary to a recent US District Court decision
WOLLE
Paralle: »
eINS wart.
Page 11
FEATURES
Isabel Houston.
gun ... the victim was to pay
the smugglers to lake him and
at least 12 other Guatemalans
Trom the Rio Curande valley 1o
The Rio Grande as a
war zone
For at least the last five
years the Rio Grande valley has
been both a detention centre
• militarized zone in
to migram» and
refugoes. There are regular INS
reconnaissance flights over the
border, miniature transmitters
for audio surveillance bave
been scattered thoughout the
area lo detect movement of
vehicles and people. Added to
this are compact television
cameras, night-vision cameras and a growing array of computer-bused sur- veillance techniques.
The war-zone has been extended to other areas having a land border with Mexico. In January 1989 the INS announced a huge scheme to contruct a ditch running though San Ysidro in California: it will be 14 feet wide, 5
feet deep and 4 miles long. Even this is insuf
ficient for the anti-immigrant lobby.
Federation for American Immigration Refonn
(FAIR) has recently issued a document Ten
steps to securing America's borders. These
tives Judiciary Sub. In Britain, desperate families like this, faced with the threat of deportation under racist committee on Immigra laws, have sought sanctuary - here in a mosque in central Birmingham
International Law, Alan Nelson argued that all detentions were "voluntary", since refugees al ways had the option. abandong their asylum claims and returning home! The INS portrayed Port Isabel as some kind of holiday camp: spokesperson Virginia Kice said "some people say it is inhumane to keep people here.
But they are clothed, fed, sheltered, and
situations they're living in better conditions
countries."
receive medical care. I think that in some
Similar
very Children
i INS
been a long-standing scandal. An estimated 5,500 young central Americans were ap prehended in 1986, and it is estimated that at any one time between 150 and 200 children are detained by the agency, frequently being used as bait' to capture their undocumented parents who come looking for them.
Who are these young people? One was a
16-year old wounded veteran of two years combat who had heen press ganged into the Salvadoran army al 13. Another Salvadora hay detainee, also press-ganged. how he had seen "subversives decapitated at
With the legal massacre of February, the
hay detainee, also press-ganged. how he had seen "subversives decapitated at the military base
With the legal massacre of February, the detention of minors increased. Some were
described centre at
held in an already existing centre for refugee children in Los Fresnos. In addition the INS
to constrict a new Brownsville to house 58 children.
The treatment of detained minors in the
The treatment of detained minors in the Rin Grande appears to have reached the level
respoct
tence and no fine ... the 15 year old Mexican detainee, estimated to be five feel tall and weigh 100 pounds, died June 2nd
Getting out of the valley
Getting out of the Rio Grande valley is not easy for the undocumented. INS officers raid Greyhound buses in the valley demanding every hispanic-looking person shows iden-
tification. Refugees are compelled once again
to put their lives at risk, this time trying to ex-
cape further north. Two newspaper report
help illustrate the problem:
*Thirty five debydrated Salvadorans were
found inside a sweltering boxcar during temperatures nearing 130 degrees, authorities
said The Salvadorans. women and two 14 year old boys had heen locked inside the car for five hours. Some were ying to get air through hole border.
boxcar.... the aliens told Border Patrol that an
unidentified man in Brownsville offered to get them to Houston for 300.600 dollars".
"A 31-year old Guatemalan was shot and robbed during negotiations with professional
illegal smugglers. ... Odilio de Jesus Ceron illegal smugglers.
Lima was shot at least five times with a shot-
OOPS SURRY!
I THOUGHT 100
WERE BURNING
A FLAG!
authont tas including three
ana 4
Federati. •FAIk, i
include such deterrent" measures as the con-
truction of metal and concrete fencing along
the entire land border, the greater use of 'im-
aging devices" such as low light television and
infra-red scopes, and the increased use of seis
and sensors aonk the
thusiast of the Vietnam War heing brought to bear on the control of immigration of people
*echnology and "n- • War neing hmught tro immigration af people into the hinterland of
from the "third world into the hinterland of
the USA - land of the free"
TEC By Steve Cohen
of legally sanctioned torture. Here is one news report: "Servando Betancount, convicted of criminally negligent homicide for snapping
undes. Cameron County juvenile
TLOOK no 18. October 1989