FEATURES
on, to consolidate and develop national struc- tunes which have effective and democratic strictures ...
'COSATU rejects any strategic alliance with representatives of big capital and par- ticipants in apartheid's state structures".
(Resolution from COSATU Congress, June 1989). (Malan's Democrats participate in the Tri-Cameral Parliament, and this sec- tion of the resolution is a direct reference).
In other words, both Mayckiso and COSATU as a whole propose to reconstitute and reorganise the UDF around the workers" movement on a new democratic basis to carry out a new political project: the first results can be seen in the defiance campaign and the general strike against the White clec- tions.
The COSATU resolution the Guidelines focusses on the accepted proposal for a workers" charter contained within them:
"The CEC is instructed to call a special National Congress to draft a workers' charter when we have discussed our demands in all nur structures and with our aules in the work- ing class
The workers' charter is not meant to be a socialist programme. Its framework is the "democratic framework of the Guidelines, as Mayekiso says: "The Workers" Charter can answer things that trouble workers- like the
Then the working class right to strike... pohtical programme must answer the ques-
tion what is the future society? ... So there are two different things'.
Mcanwhile the trade unions are ex- periencing real difficulties. South Africa's economic crisis soems insoluble, and mil- lions of blacks are now unemployed or semi- employed. The gap between employed and unemployed is growing, creating a real chal- Jengr Remmmerin ...unued even heightened - hefore the White elections: the level of self-sacrifice involved in simply keeping the lahour movement going is a per- manent drag: neverthere. the movernem. taken as a whole, is still growing, and the process of workers" unity still unfolding. In March this war 15 KA* 11 NACTU unions and 17 independent unions met at a workers" summit" against the new Labour Laws.
This is the context to the current discus- sion about negotiations in South Africa. Only a few left groups are opposed to negotiations
serenila,
sarily counterposed to revolutionary struggle to overthrow apartheid). But even Moses
Moser
Mayekise. who is some way from the views of the ANC and South African Communist
Party, summed up his view on negotiations thix way:
Firstly. I believe that the solutions to our country's problems will finally come through negoliations. I don't believe we will be able to get to Pretoria and oust [then President] Botha from those buildings. But 1 also don't
believe that negntiations are near. There will he a negotiated settlement at some stage, but at the moment those chances are nil. ... We must build our organisations so as to have power and control. The political initiative towards negotiations, the concept of negotita- tions, must come from us. We must control the initiative so as to dictate the conditions. We must not be dictated to by the Americans, the Europeans or the De Klerks."*
COSATU General Secretary Jay Naidoo
We are acutely aware of the designs of the imperialists and big business to manouevre a reformist settlement in this country. We will have nothing to do with this. Our resolution also stresses that no negotiations can take place without the democratic participation of the people in this process. It also clearly states that only a sovercign body mandated by the people and accountable to them can have the authority to develop a new constitution. Our bottom Line on negotiation is that it must lead to the transfer of power to the people*.
(Interview, August 1989)
Serions negotiations are not as likely as the world seems to think. The conditions for negotiations inside the country are further from being met today than three months ago: and all sections of the mass anti-apurtheid movement share the basic conditions for opening negotiations: release the political prisoners, end the State of Emergency, unhan the banned organisations, free speech and as- sembly. It is not the ANC's support for armed actions, not its "secret communism" that frightens South Africa's rulers: it is the
fact that the apartheid stale is most vul- nerable on the democratic question, and the ANC remains a potent enemy while it promotes unity on that issue.
Though theory does not rule out a Zim- nabwe style democratic transition ..and vapitalist entrenchmear, followed by the Aestruction of democratic rights South Africa's rulers have wisely excluded that op- tion - and not only because of their relatively buge white population. The dynamics of the struggle for democracy and the level of maturity and self-organisation of the forces uvolved would make
peaceful
"democratic" transition infinitely more risky than in Zimbabwe.
The struggle over the future course of the South African revolution is already under- way. In some senses this discussion is very advanced, but it is clearly unfinished, and on
some fronts barely started. In many ways the South African example and some of the con-
clusions the workers" movement has come to
may end up having a bigger impact on the
rest of the world than Moscow and im
perialism are having on the liberation forces
in South Africa today.
st of the
South
Open
season
against US
abortion
With the help of Ronald Reagan's con- troversial appointees, the US Supreme Court has been handing down one reac tionary ruling after another.
They have been overturning positive action principles, okaying the death penalty for the mentally incompetent and for teenagers; and rounded off their session by upholding the Mis- souri statute which prohibits abortion in pablic hospitals, harasses women seeking late abor- tion. and declare» that life begins at
"conception". The political implications of these
rulings underscore the cynicism of Bush's
promise of a "kinder, gentler nation".
Initially those who oppose legal abortion
vowed they would overturn the historic 1973
Roe v: Wade judgement which permitted it: but
as Justice Scalia explained: "It appears that the
mansion of constitutionalised abortion law,
constructed overnight in Roe v. Wade, must be
disassembled door-jamb by door-jamb, and
never entirely brought down, no matter how
The anti abortion lobby have therefore been forced to alter their strategy, instead placing as many obstacles as they can devise in the path of women seeking abortion. The Supreme Court's ruling on Webster v. Reproductive Health Ser- vices is a measure of their success, opening the gates to a flood of reactionary legislation.
Opiuvu pous show that support lor legalised abortion has never been stronger, and especially strong among the young, who grew
up thinking that their reproductive rights were
secure. According to a national survey in the
Los Angeles Times, 74 percent believe that
Lal has l0 oc mace by
every woman for herself.
A majority of people opposed the Supreme
Court ruling, and in hundreds of towns around
the country supporters of women's rights to
control their own bodies demonsrated opposi- tion to the Webster decixion. The National Or-
ganisation for Women (NOW) reports its: fastest-ever growth rate, with 40,000 joining in
the last six months, and coalitions to defend
women's reproductive rights are springing up.
Now tuemies the mill ...... tour tundamental wavs:
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
FEATURES
vitation to anti-abortion mc-
tivists and legislators to pass
new laws restricting abortion.
Everything is up for grahs. Ar
a minimum, additional restric-
tions will result in increasing
the cost of an abortion, or
bring delays, increasing the
risk to a woman's health, and
ensuring that those with the
least resources are the hardest
hil - the poor, the young, and
women of colour.
Even if abortion remains
legal, if women believe access
is cut off, illegal abortions may
resurface. Shortly after the
Hyde amendment cut off fund.
ing 10г women under
Medicard. hospitals saw
women appearing suffering
from infections and other com-
plications of self-induced or il- Fundamentalism US-style - as crowds of bigots mobilise to blockade abortion clinics like this one in Atlanta
legal abortions,
The Supreme Court also agreed to review
three more abortion cases this autumn. One
challenges carly abortions by forcing out-
patient abortion clinics and doctors' surgeries
to become mini-hospitals: this would affect
But the reality is that the declaration sets
94 percent of all abortions, and would up a political judgement equating the life of a
prohably double the price (currently averag: foetus at conception with the life of the preg-
ing 230 dollars). nant woman, suggesting that the state impose its judgement whenever the interests of one
# The Count found that the declaration thar life begins at conception imposed no
substantive restriction, that it was no more
than a value judgement favouring childbirth
wizen ant....
- life of a
so impoun
life conflict with another.
This decluration is potentially far reach- ing It could he utilised as the basis for out
lawing forms of birth control which prevent a fertilised egg from developing: for restricting almost all abortion, or even for rising
Tet..m.
who fail to alter their diet habits or refuse specitie medical procedures
# The Count found that stales are free to prefer childhirth over abortion, and to imple- ment that policy by prohibiting public fund ing for abortion as well as by prohibiting
by prolubitun public hospitals and their staff from perfom- ing abortions.
This ruling is so broad that even a private doctor whose admission privileges are at a
hospital which received public funding or has contractual arrangements with a state or local government would he affected.
Much of health care in the United States
nas
is at least in some way connected to public
funding or public entities. For instance in
Missouri 97 per cent of all abortions in
months 36 of pregnancy were performed at the Truman Medical Centre, a private hospiatt in St Louis. But they can no longer
Only one woman in every ten who choose
ahortion undergoes the procedure in a hospi-
tal: but those who have severe threatening medical conditions are at greater
or life-
risk; others depend upon hospitals as their only source of health care (particularly poor or rural women) or discover foetal disease or deformity only later in their pregnancy.
Poor women and women of colour suffer disproportionately from a variety of serious health conditions which may be exacerbated by pregnancy. The few hospitals which may still be able to meet the criteria of being
"private" will not be able to service all the women who need hospilalisation - and these hospitals are also the ones most vulnerahle to anti-abortion boycott campaigns.
If hospital abortions are effectively out- lawed, medical personnel will no longer receive training in abortion procedures, and knowledge of the procedure will effectively disappear from medical schools. This in turn would drive abortion underground even if legal, making it potentially less safe.
The Court upheld viablury testing procedures for women 20 woks pregnant. despite medical testimony that foctal viability begins only around the 24th week.
Such testing adds beiween 125-450 dol. lars to the cost of an ahortion, and one such text, amniocentesis, itself has a one per cent risk of inducing a miscarriage or causing haemorrhage or infection. Such tests could delay an already late ahortion by one or two more weeks, make it still more difficult and costly.
Less than one percent of all abortions take place after 20 weeks, but this provision is extremely important: it is often very young women who have late abortions hecause they did not realise they were pregnant (or denied the fact), or were unable to scrape together the money to obtain an abortion. Other late abortions take place hecause of the discovery
of severe foctal abnormalities or because of the woman's health:
• The Court, by its decision, issued an in-
The other two cases deal with parental
consent before a minor can obtain an abor- tion. The rate of leenage sexual activity is
teenage sexuas activity is similar through the various industrialised
countries, but the USA has the highest rate of
pregnancy - clearly Europeans have more ef-
fective sex education programmes. Despite the fact that fertility is at its peak during these years, half of all teenagers are sexually active
a year before they obtain birth control. Con- sequently 40 per cent of all US teenage women become pregnant by their twentieth hirthday. More than a million US teenagers become pregnant every year, and almost half choose to have abortions.
Given the high rate of pregnancy, it is not surprising that 25 per cent of all shortions are performed on teenage women. Approximate ly 50-65 per cent of those who have abortions confide in one or both of their parents. However legislation in more than half of all states esome not enforced at present due to court orders) demands parental consent before abortion is legal.
Though public support for legal abortion is higher than ever in the US, still opinion polls show 6l per cent believe it is morally wrong, and 57 percent believe it is murder. The Supreme Court has indicated it is willing to restrict women's right to legal abortion in several fundamental ways. It is in this new context that supporters of women's rightx must discuss possible strategies to fight back.
Dianne Feeley
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18. October 1989
Page 9