EDUCATION SUPPLEMENT
Graame Cookson
offensive: will Labour
pass the test?
assessment of the weak- nesses in Tory education policy in England and Wales must begin with a recognition of the Tories' cousiderable politica achieve- ments-
it the weak-
In ten years, with accelerating pace, they have demolished much of the framework and idenlogy of post- war education, and hroken up the sys lem of political alliances which un- derminned - The doctrine that underlay post-war reform held that
«en up une sys- wances whinn al-
underlay post-war reform held that economic progress depended upon a more general provision of a higher- quality education, and upon equalis ing the opportunities available to stu- dents from different social classes.
Although the opportunities offered were for the most part seized by the
members of
in to stu-
classes.
less "disadvantaged" society, this understandi ture of reform had Ir- gested that the "needs economy could be m fcrentiated expansion of el one whin was not fon delineratelv targeted un
of the
1y and particular
manpower needs and purticular social groups.
It is this position which the Con- servatives are now dismantling. They reject the idea that a universal expan- sion of education is necessary to meet the needs they identify. They favour a much higher degree of targeting and selection: sclection within schools, so as to maintain academic streams, and to develop technical ones, selection between schools, so as to build up centres of scholarly excellence or col- leges of teclinology, In cacn case. it is implicit that there are groups who are not targeted for special trealment, for whom lower levels of education and different conceptions of relevance une proposed.
Selectiveness of this kind has a political, as well as an economic ra- tionale. Selection in the past benelited relatively small groups; the system that the right-wing Black Papers ad- vocated in the 1970s, for instance, comprised only five to eight per cent of the state school population. Con- servative policy now proposes several different types of selection, in a sys-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
tem which would involve a large seg-
a large seg
schools for which their parents had
opted, and which had, in tum. decided to select them. Traditional isn't the right word for this system.
It's not simply a retum to models of the past. It incorporates, of course, elements of older selective systems: the grammar school will survive. But overall it is new, and in its newness corresponds to other developing fea tures of the economy, and of classl and political relations, in Thatcher's Britain. In this wider
homogenenus in their exclusion from
wealth and their opposition to Con- servatism begin to disintegrate. Ins education, as in society as a whole. the Tories hope to draw some of these groupings into the orbit of Conser
existence of selection and (relative)
privilege.
The Tones make two majo
claims for their programme. The first
is that it is a modernisation of the
school system: the curriculum isl
As the new term starts, teachers, pupils, lecturers and students are
up against the
effects of the
Tory assault on
education. The
Queen's Speech
will contain
proposals on
student loans,
while Kenneth
Baker's onslaught on the
schools is still working through.
The articles in this supplement look at apects of
the Tory plans,
and discuss
ways of fighting
back.
Page 13
"For many years, the Tories were thought of as the stupid party in education: their policy was nostalgic, concerned more to preserve the past than to restructure it. The descril is no longer adequate"
the to re it. iption er
"The government's underfunding of education runs the danger of creating a parents' movement that is less interested in 'choice' than in overall levels of resources"
Page 14
SUPPLEMENT
being updated; the 'needs of industry are being more effectively served. In several respects, the claim is a credible one. For many years, the Tores were thought of as the stupid party in education: their policy was nostalgic, concerned more to preserve the past than to restructure it. The description is no longer adequate. Certainly, the Tories have utilised an appeal to tradition" against what they have characterised as "loony' reforms: that is one of the bases from which they have attacked programmes of race equality. But in other respects, they have been keen to embrace the new.
The "Technical and Vocational Education Initiative', for instance, promoted a student-centred, activity- hased curriculum, proud of its "relevance" and blazoning its opposi tion to the academic and book-based models of the grammar-school tradi tion. Likewise, the working parties that the government has set up to devise a National Curriculum are reporting in terms that reflect the progressive opinion of education professionals, rather than the Tory right. Roger Scruton may think of education as 'an extended war against relevance': not so, the DES.
The think-tanks of the right - the Centre for Policy Studies, for instance
- see this ax a betrayal. It is better
seen as a compromise, made from a position of strength, that is based both on a realisation of the poverty of the right's own ideas about teaching and Icaring, and on a desire to convert progressive potential critics of change into functionaries of refom. In this last respect, the govemment has been successful.
Many of those at the higher levels of edocation - teacher trainers, local authority advisors and so on who hold personal beliefs favourable to progressive education now see their role as working within the framework of the National Curriculum. It does not, after all, seem to be the embodi- ment of reaction, and it is possible for professionals, through their involv-
ment, to limit the influence of the right. There is a price, though, for this strategy. The Tories have set clear
rules for joining their game: cur-
riculum reform will from now on be
implemented from the top, with none
of that scope for egalitarian impulses
that marked earlier peniods of change.
The second claim the Tories make
- and again, this is one which bas some popular appeal - is that they have made the system more
democratic, and more accountable.
They have increased parent repre- sentation on school governing bodies and strengthened their powers "Parental choice of school has been widened, and schools - through the publication of annual reports and exam results - have been forced into greater accountability. In this way. Tories claim. the old system. nased
lown hall bureaucracy and teachers who believed that they knew best, has been replaced.
Such, then, are the outlines of the Tory system, and the pontical strengths they claim for it. But will the system work? Can it deliver the skilled, work-orientated students that industry, in certain numbers, rc- quires? Can it command the loyalties of large numbers of parents, students and teachers? There are many reasons for doubt.
The first is the continued under- resourcing of education, and the lack of planning to deal with key issues. The National Curriculum may itself he a model of careful planning, hut it is an isolated example of purposeful activity in a landscape shaped by a principle of neglect. Over the last year, a series of reports from es tablishment quarters - the CBI, the School Inspectorate, Parliamentary Select Committes - have com-
havr am- plained about fundamental weak- nesses in the system.
Nursery education is inadequate. with serious effects on students" later performance. Post 16 education is a mess. Too few students stay on in education. Training schemes - such as YTS - develop 'skills' at too low a level for industrial need. Spending on all sectors of education is insufficient. most notably in the case of teachers pay, whose inadequacies have given rise to acute problems of teacher shortage.
There is a second difficulty that arises from the way change is heing pushed through
The Tory programme is one of top-down reform. It doesn't rest upon the invol- vement of teachers. Quite the op posite: it aims to direct a transforma- tion of the workforce. As Martin Allen's article shows, it wants to see a teaching force that is more closely managed, less unionised, harder- working, cheaper. Such changes are paralleled by a loss of educational in- itiative: teachers will play a great part in the implementation of change, hut virtually none in its original devising
The overall effect of these new pressures on teachers, now that the moment of militancy has, for the time being passed, is a strong sense of
alienation, it makes the work of many: teachers a depressing experience. But
il is aiso a pmblem for the govem- ment. Its curriculum reforms envisage an active role for the teacher, who is meant to encourage the engoiries of the student and devise new schemes of work, based on the nationally set "programmes of study'. Yet, ourside. the urgings of the curriculum work- une parties. government policy - on pay, conditions and teacher involve- ment - works against such a role. It in thus guaranteed to produce negative responses - from a quiet with-holding of commitment, to a possible resur gence of teacher militancy.
But it is not only among teachers that problems will grow. Parents have been promised a greater say in the running of schools. The hope is that in taking on managerial espon- sibilities, they will develop a sense of "self-help" and "making do". Faced with shortages of cash, they will or- gunise • jumbie sale, or sack a cleaner, rather than make a protest. From a Tory point of view, this is an
pumist. assumption. The govemment's underfunding of educa tion runs the danger of creating a parents" movement that is less inter-
ested in 'choice" than in overall levels
of resources. In the right circumstan-
ces, particularly in the inner citics, it
could be a real force.
Finally, there are the students who
will experience the new cducation and all the testing that goes with it. Tory policy has put a stop to most
expenment. intendea to
develop an education relevant to the
needs of working class and black stu-
dents. Instead, the National Cur-
riculum claims to deliver an educa- tion wilch will be relevant to all, whatever their race. gender, or background". This is a dubious claim. Although they apply some progres-
sive principles, the proposals of the
national curriculum working parties
emhody values and cultures remote from the experience of many stu- dents. They are thus unlikely to solve
historic problems of under-achieve
ment. Testing students at 7, 11, 14
and 16 - producing in many a strong
sense of falure - is also unlikely to
increase the commitment of students
from oppressed groups.
There are several reasons, then.
for doubting whether Tory policy is
capable of carrying out its project of
ment. T
modernisation. It has.
inuns some netahle suc
ignumant has been a chift in the night in the terms
aebate and policy
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18. October 1989
making. Many of the priorities and much of the language of the Conser- vative programme now find an echo in the Labour Party: the stress on "standards, choice, and consumer nghts, for instance. Moditied ver- sions of the Tories' central projects - the national curriculum.