FEATURES
.. That is why it is the duty of every worker and revolutionist to leam how to manipulate
Trotsky, American Problems.
In the final stages of the war, the political situation became increasinly dominated by the
working class, not only in the defcated axis powers (Germany, Japan, Italy) but also notably in the USA and Britain, and in the area liberated by the advancing Red Army in Easter Europe. For the post-war Fourth Inter- national, Emest Germain wrote the following
strength and combativity of the
arreated
analysis:
"In Czechoslovakia the approach of the Red Army launched a general revolutionary upsurge: occupation of the factories, estahlish- ment of plant committees to run the factories, creation of Councils (a kind of Soviet) which gathered unto their hands all political authority, concentration of all arms in the hands of the workers' militia...
In Yugoslavia and Albania the civil war (the struggle berween the Chetniks and Par- tisans) raged from 1942 on. From its very beginning the civil war gave birth to commit- tees of workers and peasants as organisations of power and to a workers" and peasants" militia. ...
In Poland, the approach of the Red Army was marked by a succession of clearly revolu- tionary movements on the part of the working
class, while the peasantry, sharply differen-
DINETTE Se ne factarm
ferti
The
*Ing DUE "Hu
In Romania and Bulgaria the approach of the Red Army started a real revolutionary up surge. August 23 1944 in Romania and Sep- tember 9 1944 in Bulgaria were marked by gigantic demonstrations of workers followed hy an uninterrupted sincerion of strikee mass demonstrations, etc., until the Red Army arrived in Bucharest and Soffa..
Finally in East Germany and Austria, the
US and Soviet troops meet up on the River Elbe
up plant committees and establish workers undertook the task of channelling discontent control. Red flags were hoisted over most of into relatively safe road of refons legislated the factories and in working class housing es through Parliament. In the USA, a massive
strike wave convulsed almost the whole of
hasic industry, and trade union membership
reached a new peak, only to sce union leaders
settle for minimal concessions.
The class struggle had not ceased during
the war: the capitalists had continued to pile
up profits. the workers to be exploited
cconomically and as cannon fodder, and
talex."
As we now know, Stalin's response, and that of the Red Army, was wherever possible ... repress and destroy these independent mobilisations of the working class. when eventually Moscow decided to proceed with the expropriation of capitalism in much of the East European "buffer zone", the overtums took place not from such grass roots level, but from above, hy bureaucratic and military ac- tion designed to exclude any possibility of genuine workers' democracy or workers' con- Imi.
While Stalinism demobilised the workers of the East and created only a bureaucratised parody of the potential workers' states, mass Communist Parties also played a key role in demobilising armed working class resistance fighters who potentially threatened capitalist rule in post-war Italy and France. In Britain, in a much less radicalised situation, amid gloomy capitalist expectations of a wave of working class militancy, it was the Labour Party that
many of them had drawn revolutionary con-
clusions trom their bitter experiences. The commitment of the social democrats to reforming (and preserving) capitalism had not changed any more than the counter-revolu- tionary treachery of the Communist Parties: the task remained one of seeking to build a new, revolutionary leadership with genuine and mass roots in the workers movement of each country. This aspect of the Trotskyist analysis was vindicated after the war - and remains sadly still true today.
John Lister
Britain's growing Greens pose challenge
Britain's Greens have rewritten the political agenda. The covironmental issue is now set to dominate the perspec- tives of the major parties for the foresee- able future. The Tory Party has launched an all-out attack on the fireens. describ- ing them as an 'extreme socialist party'. "deliberately misinforming the public' Labour has declared that it will be a red- green party by the next election.
But the far left remains stolidly uncon
stella mmm vinced As with its initial reaction to the
have The
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989
peace movement and the Greenham Common women, it is suspicious and even hostile to an issuc that can politically mobilise the centre ground of British politics.
Many on the left theorised that while the environmental movement would be an im- portant factor, its political impact would be negligible. The political factors which fuelled the growth of the German Grunen would pass through the Labour Party, many thought. But the Greens' results in the Euro-elections, cap- turing two and a quarter million votes in Britain - the highest proportion of votes ever
gained by a Green Party in Europe, have con- founded the analysis.
The wverwhelming majority of the Greens" support came from disillusioned sup porters of the Social and Liberal Democrats (SLD) and David Owen's rimp Social Democratic Party, joined by ex-Tories exer- cised by issues such as water privatisation or the Channel Tannel rail link. It is true also that the Greens" largest support came from the more prosperous south. But to use these factors to belittle the Greens' breakthrough is the height of sectarianism.
Page 29
FEATURES
While: the Greens largest support came from the south, to record elec- toral scores of 12 per and 8 per cent in the north and Scotland respectively was
Another source of
hostility on the left
towards the
ecologists is that they
point to the major
post-capitalist
countnes like the
Soviet Union and
China thosc
countnes in which,
for "xample. emis-
sions of greenhouse
gases are still rapidly
increasing.
Those who defend
the policies of the
ruling burcaucracies
in these countries are
sensitive to the fact
that their industries
are contributing
towards
heavily
global ccological dis-
aster. Backwardness of technique in these countries has meant heavy reliance on fossil fuels for power and the lack of systematic controls on waste. But, like the marxists, ecologists have also correct- ly pointed out that this is not the whole story Ecologically disastrous planning decisions: have been carried through in bureaucratic closed session: if the people directly affected by them had been consulted, there would have been mass opposition.
Marxists must develop socialist programme which does put production ceil- inge on ecologically damaging industries, and points in non-damaging alternatives, par- ticularly in the spheres of energy production and transport. This also means examining critically the patter of foreign trade to ex- amine the extent to which industrially ad- vanced nations despoil and plunder the natural resources of the third world.
Nor should our response stop al the level of economic programme. Friends of the Earth are developing with interested trade unions a "shop-stewards" charter" which would lead to monitoring of firms" activities by rank and file trade unionists, both in tens of the health of the workers in the workplace, and the effects of the firms" activity on the local, national and intemational community and ecology.
The starting point for a red-green alliance
as far as the Marxist left is concered, should
be a critical acceptance of the major points of the Circen propramme. while explaining that
the fundamental problem in not indostrial society, but the way in which that society is
no mean achievement for a new party with no na- tional apparatus to speak of. Thatcher nas don» much on the public rela- tions front to present her- self as a champion of the ecosphere. And yet all the evidence suggests that the environmental vote totally escaped the Tories: hence the furious attack on the Greens by Conservative Central Office. Lahours programme on the enG vironment shares the same philosophy of caviron-
environ- Affer one hot summer, discharges from factories could make things hotter still! mental protection as the Tories: far from attracting Green support, Labour is if anything losing left wing forces to the Greens.
But the most important factor is that of the state of the environment itself. The warmest five years of this century have all fallen in the present decade. Even the previously most sceptical now conclude that this is the result of global warming caused by the "greenhouse effect The greenhouse eases. methane nitrous oxide, chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and carbon dioxide, gather in the lower atmos phere, trapping heat with catastrophic cffect.
A temperature increase of one degree Cel- sius leads to a 60-100 mile shift in vegetation zones. Trees will die in large numbers and not be replaced rapidly enough to prevent defores tation, and the consequent side-effects of flash flooding and soil erosion. The predicted risc of three degrees Celsius by 2050 would, through the melting of the ice caps, raise sea- levels hy up to a metre, leading to the swamp ing of delta cultures such as Bangladesh. An increased incidence of hurricanes, droughts and flooding producing the devastation scen last year by Hurricane Inan is another conse- quence of the global warming-
The 1987 agreement limiting the release of
CFC into the atmosphere will only have a very limited effect. Carbon emissions as a hy-
product of hurning fossil fuels are the greatest
and most lethal contributor. The "greenhouse
effect poses point-blank the relation between the ecology and conventional conomic
product of hummi and most lethan con eflect poses poult-b the ecology an growth.
It a on this bor themselVes in agreems" vironmental platform port company with tea. Lake centur romantic mourn the adve". see the begu
effect poses point-blank the relation between
the laree
•ine timens en-
lase and nght,
.na minelanth
3010к) aje dar
come Green
They
social
the the earth beginning with the industrial revolution.
Yet the advance of technology, which has been part of the industrial revolution and par- ticularly of its acceleration in the twentieth century, enables the development of forms of economic development which are not ecologi- cally harmful. The problem is not industrial society, but that the application of technology is not controlled in the interests of the many. but is subordinate to the blind pursuit of profit.
Marxists, with a few honourable excep tions, have mistakenly adopted the Keynesian view of growth as the means to solve un employment. Much of the left therefore react antagonistically to any proposal to restrict growth. This is despite the fact that Marxists would see much of what counts towands growth as being unproductive; financial deal- ings in the world stock exchanges, advertising and wasteful packaging
Countries like Britain long ago achieved that level of economic development at which the divisions between classes cased to be- come inevitable and necessary. It is not fur- ther economic growth which will liberate and resolve the problems of British society, bur the abolition of the capitalist system itself.
But, responds the Marxist, what of the un- derdeveloped world? Surely any inhibition of economic growth is a reactionary move from the point of view of those which have not at- tained the level of growth of the advanced capitalist world?
But a critical view of such growth is essen- tial. The success" story of Indonesia, for ex- ample, with an annual rate of growth of 8 per
cent, must he set against the cost of that growth. Gross pollution and depletion of natural resources, when taken into account, reduce that rate of growth in harely 1 per cent.
controlled and organised.
Coupled with this should be the adoption of a practical programme of work within the Labour movement to convert the present an-
tagonisin between our movement and the
Greens into an alliance for Eco-socialism.
By Steve Roberts
Page 30
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989