Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Tory class war plans dissected

· Socialist Outlook no. 18, October 1989 · pp 33-36 · 3,014 words

Ireland Lesbian and gay Labour Party Women

REVIEW

Right turn: the Conser- vative revolution in education By Ken Jones (1989) published by Hutchinson Radius

nser- in

Debbie Epstein

Ken Jones has written an impor tant book, which should be read not only by those involved in education, but by all of the left who wish to understand the na- ture and method of the Tory's ideological attack on the work- ing class.

In Right turn he traces in detail the history of Conservative thinking about education and ex- amines the reasons for its suc- cess in changing the face and nature of the British education system. In doing so, he engages in argument with the ideologues of the Tory right — Scruton, Pas mer, Honeyford, the Centre for Policy Studies and others. It is important to know your enemy. and, in order to do so, to present their arguments - not as paper tigers, hut clearly and recognis ing their strength and appeal. As Jones himself says:

"At a time when the ideas of the right are so ascendant in public debate, this can be dangerous method of presenta- tion: perhaps the evocation of opponents ideas will prove more alluring than one's own... In certain ways, Conservatism in education has made contact with popular discontents, and has been decisive in linking educa- tion to overall strategy. The

Education: now the playgrou

power of its arguments has to be registered, or a strategy for its defeat will not develop."

Right turn does register the power of right-wing arguments, but at the same time shows the contradictory strands within them and their fundameatal intel- lectual weaknesses: At the same time be offers an explanation of the material basis for the success of these writers in gaining politi- cal support, with the result that the Education Reform Act (ERA) bears the clear imprint of their thinking.

This section of the book oc- cupies its first four chapters. In them, Ken Jones analyses the ten- sions between the modernising and traditionalist strands of Tory thinking about education, which he touches on in his article in this journal, and which provide an explanation for the apparent distance between the rhetoric of Tory politicians and the reports of the National Curriculum Working Partics - which have, by and large, endorsed "progressive methods of teach- ing. Again, this is discussed

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

the Tory think tanks

briefly in his article.

Ken Jones also examines the failure of the Labour Party and the teachers' unions to oppose ef- fectively the ERA and the effoct of "new realism" on cducation policy. He points to the essential weakness which reformers in the 19605 and 70s displayed in un- derstanding the need for allian- ces:

"Progressivism... expressed in a heightened way all that was sectoral aboul education reform. It was adroit in establishing an in- fluence at certain points within the education system, but less at- tentive lo seeking support out- side it. In popular tens it was more likely to be the butt of criticism, rather than a rallying point of campaigns for change."

It is depressing that certain sections of the left in teaching have not yet understood this, and see their struggle purely in sec- toral terms, and that so many dis cussions about education fail even to mention students or parents - apart from a ritualistic nod in the direction of "com- munity" or "black parents".

Nevertheless, the book is not depressing, since it outlines the alliances which can be built to resist the Tory attack, and offers ideas, in the form of the Socialist Teachers" Alliance Charter for Education, for the line a genuine- ly democralic and progressive education would take. However, it could be strengthened by a fuller discussion of the place of union action in opposing the Tory attack and of how the neces- sary alliances can be developed.

Another limitation of Right turn is one which Ken Jones ac- knowledges in his introduction. This is that it concentrates on English secondary schools. As he points out, post-16 education has already been well dealt with by others, the the changes in primary schooling remain to be investigated from a left perspec- tive.

In spite of being an undoub- tedly "intellectual book, which grapples with idcas of the right as well as the left, Ken Jones has succeoded in writing clearly and interestingly. Read it!

Page 31

LETTERS

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

No laughing matter?

It's not often that Socialist Outlook makes me laugh. It's not that sort of journal is it? But I couldn't help raising a chortle at Tony i Benn's interview in No.17.

Asked whether he didn't sec problems with 3 making the Morning Star the paper of the Socialist Movement, he told us what a good idea it was, and how we really should "get over all this Trotsky-Stalin argument'!

But seriously, it's not just the way he tells them: the intervention of the Communist Party of Britain into the Socialist Movement, and the enthusiasm of some left MPs for it is a crucial development worthy of more attention.

Hilary Wainwright's balance-sheet on the Sheffield conference left me with puzzlement rather than amusement: but it was interesting nevertheless.

Most important, however, the two inter- views begged the question.

Socialist Outlook view on it all? Participant or

... An interview with Davy

commentator?

Jones, perhaps?

Simon Kennedy

Swansea

John Harris/FI

Challenging the platform at Labour Conference: this year LCLGR will try leged cloctoral unpopularity of the block vote as a cover for the real motivation.

This year the key debate for Labour's con- Terence will be on unilateralism. Next year it could well be the block vote. I believe the lat- ter might even be the more important.

We need to develop a response throughout the movement. Union lefts must address the issue and take a collective lead. Events like the Socialist Movement's Trade Union Con- ference must place the block vote issue at the centre of their concers.

Chris Jones

Manchester What men stand to lose

It is a feminist cliché that men are condi- tioned to worry ahour themselves, whil women are conditioned to worry about other

peopic.

I hope Valerie Coultas's article (Socialist Outlook No.17) was not implying that we are going to bring that attitude into the arguments for women's liberation. All we can do is for-

mulate our own demands; we can't be ex- pected to worry about how men will deal with

them - that's their problem, not ours!

On a more serious level, 1 feel Valerie

seriously underestimates the practical value to

men in general, and working class men in par-

ticular, of the subordinate position of women.

Having your children looked after, your

house cleaned, shopping done, clothes washed

and meals cooked is very liberating.

It allows men the sost of free time most

women have to fight for. And the less money

you have, the greater the real value of thesc

services (rich people can employ others to per

the Iwo inter- "where is the

Participant or

with Davy

Don't forget the block vote!

There has been debate for many months if not years over the role of trade unions in the Labour Party, Yet the political left has failed to grasp the full significance of what is going on. Certainly the lack of concerted response is a big problem.

To understand the importance of the issue we must appreciate certain facts:

1) The Tories do not have a guaranteed electoral majority - they win as a result of our two-and-a-half-party system.

2) Centre party politics have probably col- lapsed - leaving Labour as the governmental altemative

3) Kinnock is moving to the right to make Labour acceptable to the bosses as a political party.

With full-scale attacks on trade unions and workers' pay and conditions at the very heart

of the bourgeois strategy, how can they of the bour tolerate these same unions and workers having a direct structural say in the decision-making process of the altemative government party?

This might sound a bit simplistic, and I ac- cept that there are many complex factors 1 have not mentioned: nonetheless we have to see beyond the media pressure using the al-

fom them 1.

It is all very well for us as feminists to say that men will be better off emotionally when they lose these privileges, hut most men would see that as an abstract gain for a concrete loss.

Surely women's oppression will end when women organise to chieve it, not when men realise that it will he in their own interest?

Dorothy Macedo

London NW4

LCLGR: off the shopping list, onto the lobby!

Socialist Outlook No.16 carried a letter from Rebecca Flemming rightly complaining of the "disappearance" of lesbians from your coverage of Women for Socialism.

In that same issue you carried a thousand words from Pete Firmin on the betrayals of the Labour Party's Policy review. Lo and behold, the decision of the National Executive to abandon the conference commitment to full equality for lesbians and gay men, and the decision of the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights to wage a vigorous. campaign for its reinstatement, were both notable for their absence.

Lessbian and gay socialists have been Fighting an uphill struggle to make our oppres sion, and the fight against it, as important an issue for the labour movement as it is for the right

Repeatedly our efforts to convince lesbians. and gay men that socialists understand that fighting our oppression is an integral part of socialist strategy come unstuck through the betrayals of the Labour right and the regular failure of the left to treat us as anything apart from a name on a shopping list of worthy causes

In the case of the Labour Party Policy

Review, this is doubly unfortunate, because

we are currently organising a major campaign

to reverse the capitulation of the NEC to Roy

Hattersley's bigotry. Such a campaign can

only succeed with the assistance of straight

socialists, if we are to make it to the agenda of

party conference. Once there, we can be more

confident than any other socialist campaign

that we can swing the balance of forces suffi-

ciently to actually win the vote.

LCLGR will be organising a demonstra-

non in lobby the conference. We trust thar

Socialist Outlook will help us in publicising

this and building a substantial mobilisation.

Peter Purton

LCLGR

Southall

Page 32

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

LETTERS

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

Danger of political defeat for irish anti-imperialism

I feel I must criticise your report of the local cloctions in the north of Ireland. If you consider both the local and the European elec- tions in the north, there is obviously a malaise in the ranks of republican support. leaving the SDLP as the dominant party of the northern nationalists.

In the general and European elections in the south, the 'left" (which is only 20 percent of the total vote) is dominated hy the reformist Labour Party and the stalinist, pro- imperialist Workers Party. Even the extremely vague Irish Greens clected a T.D.

Whether we like it or not the whole ques ton of huilding a viable anti-imperialist alter- native in hoth parts of the country has to he reassessed in terms of strategy

Sinn Fein has failed to come up with a meaningful programme that combines the democratic demand tor lish muty with demands which have appeal for the workers und small farmers, especially of the south.

Careful with term 'schizophrenic"!

While reading David Grant's review of Paris by Night in Socialist Outlook No.17.1 was rather taken aback when in describing the character of Claire Paige he uses a word which is totally wrong: Hare decides to invest Claire Paige with an almost schizophrenic longing to uncover a tender, loving side to her personality.

I have not seen the film, bot Grant uses the term schizophrenic" in a way which suggests the has a split personality: if this is what he meant then I must point out he is wrong.

Schizophrenia is definitely not a split per- sonality: though the word is derived from Greek terms meaning 'split" and 'mind", it really means a disintegration of personality.

The medical term is ambiguous, and it must he said that there are many disagree- ments in psychiatry OVer whether schizophrenia exists: the argument doesn't end at schizopluenia but should also unclude many other depressions.

I believe as marxists we must understand these problems and enter the debate, because so far we have failed to understand this area at all.

Louise Whittle Brighton

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 18, October 1989

To illustrate tie necessity of this, I would point out that unemployment in most parts of Dublin is the same as that of republican west Belfast in tems of numbers - even without sectarian discrimination.

The republican movement seems to think that a reversion to a 1970s style bombing cam- paign, and a political militarism. combined with an electoral programme which mimics that of the Workers Party, is the solution.

The anti-imperialist movement is at an im- passe. If it does not analyse the reasons for this it will fail the Irish working class, leaving them to follow the reformists. The way is being left open for a generational defeat; time is not on our side. The need for this analysis has to be stressed to Sinn Fein as the dominant anti-imperialist party.

On a separate issuc, I would also like to ex- press my surprise at the lack of mention of Fastem Europe and China in the debates and coverage of the Socialist Conference in your June issue:

The question of solidarity with the workers, peasants and oppressed nationalities in Eastern Europe and China does not seem to be important as a plank of your tendency at the conference. This is in stark contrast to the rest of your excellent magazine and its coverage.

Unity of the left must be hased on prin- siple. not on ignoring differences and allowing Stalinists of all hues to make excuses for mas- sacre and murder. National independence is a right of Latvians as well as Nicaraguans. To refuse to delend the struggles in the degenerated and deformed workers states is similar to ignoring the fact that a friend, col league or comrade heats his wife. Both posi tions are indefensible.

James B. Monaghan

Dun Laoghaire, Co. Dublin

OCTOBER 19

Lift the Ban!

A year ago the Home Secretary

imposed the ban on

broadcasting interviews with members of Sinn Fein and other

organisations in the north of

Ireland.

This censorship means people cannot be told the whole truth about what is going on in the six

counties.

March and rally against the Ban 12 noon: Assemble outside BBC,

Portland Place, London W1 (Oxford Circus tube) March to

rally 1pm Rally at Dominion Theatre

(Tottenham Court Rd tube)

2.30pm Lobby of Parliament

Organised by NUJ

Plight of prisoners under Thatcherism

I have just been released from Brixton prison after two and a half months on remand. I am Irish and have lived in London a few years. 1 am in my twenties.

Ax inmates in Brixton, we noticed a few senous lanures within the prison system: prisoners and prison officers alike are feeling the pinch of Thatcherism's cruel, inhumane

The screws are ulder sever menta stress and strain from under-staffing, and are taking out their misfortunes on the prisoners. This takes the form of brutalisation, mistreat- ment, and mass cuts in exercise.

The prisoner is the one who feels the flash- back from Thatcherite policies - for example being locked mp for 96 hours al a stretch (myself), which is detrimental to mental health; and cuts made in food, giving us only the barest amount, so we are hungry and mal nourished Is the public taking any notice?

Prisoners in F wing hospital in Brizzon as a fast resort have had in start their own union in order to gain some recognition. Their efforts were made public by Wandsworth prison after unsuccessful attempts were made to set up a peaceful strike.

We prisoners who have attempted 1o or ganise, and many of ux who have been illegal- ly held. robbed, and locked up for months on remand, have been going on lunger strikes on and off for our political beliefs, but publicity was usually banned - hence my letter.

I myself was brutally attacked (I would describe this as attempted castration) and in humanely rejused water while on hunger strike, and not allowed to slop out.

I know one prisoner who was left to die after suffering continuous pileptic fits.

We, the union for prisoners' rights feel it just to fight for our cause. We oppose being locked up 23 hours a day: we oppose our

heing stolen; and we oppose the removal of patients who are ill from the work rota which grants then some exercise and socialisation outside their cell.

John

London NW6

Labour Campaign for Les-

bian and Gay Rights

Lobby

and demonstration Labour Party Conference

BRIGHTON, Monday

October 2

Assemble 12 noon outside Conference centre on the sea

front

Page 33

for socialism

1st-3rd December

1989

Venue: Kingsway College, Sidmouth

Street (near Kings Crosstube)

THE SOCIALIST OUTI

MAJOR FORUMS AND DEBATES INCLUDE:

• The crisis of Stalinism in Eastern Europe and China

n in ina

• A socialist approach to 1992

• Socialist democracy and proportional representation

J Women's struggles in Europe

& Gay Liberation

WITH:

Ernest Mandel Zbigniew Kowalewski Oliver MacDonald John Palmer* Bernadette McAliskey* Tariq Ali Alice Mahon MP* Peter Tatchell Branka Magas Ken Livingstone MP Ai Meun Lim and others *(invited)

ORGANISED BY SOCIALIST OUTLOOK

Rates (whole weekend): Waged: E12; Students: E8; Unwaged: £6 (E1 off if you register by 13 November)

I would like further information about Outlook for Socialism 89 (yes/no) Please delete:

I would like to register for Outlook for Socialism 89 (yes/no)

I would like a subscription to Socialist Outlook (E8.50 inland)

lenclose £ ..... (please make cheques payable to Outlook International)

November)

Name:

Address..

Please send this form to PO Box 1109, London N4 2UU

← Growing Greens pose challenge to the left · Editorial →

Something wrong on this page?