Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

SWP and women's liberation

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · pp 30-31 · 2,057 words

Women Marxism Asia The left

FEATURES

two systems' will become a forceful element in the restoration of capitalism in China. If there is no intervention from the masses, the "two systems' will conflict and struggle against each other with one of two possible results. Either the CCP changes its policy, strikes at the bourgeois forces and overthrows the capitalist system or, altematively, China goes through capitalist restoration.

In our opinion, to realise the unification of China, for Hong Kong to be integrated into China, for capitalism to be overthrown in Hong Kong, bureaucratic rule in China must be over- thrown. Socialist democracy must be es- tablished in China in conjunction with a single system of state property. Only the mobilisation of the Chinese and Hong Kong masses can achieve this.

In Hong Kong, these mobilisations will begin around struggles over living conditions and democratic rights. The central demand at the moment should be for a Hong Kong People's Congress with full powers, constituted by a general election to replace the colonial regime. The Hong Kong People's Congress so constituted should draw up the Basic Law.

The Hong Kong working class must be the main force behind this struggle and lead the other toiling layers. As the wave of class strug gie rises revolutionaries would then raise the demand of a Congress of the toiling masses to replace the Hong Kong People's Congress so as to meet the new objective requirements at that time and push the struggle to a higher plane.

The higher the level of struggle in Hong Kong, the more possible it becomes to en- courage the people on mainland China to strug- gle and assist the people of Hong Kong to gain their rights. The democratic future of Hong Kong is tightly linked to the democratic future of their fellow Chinese on the mainland.

The question of Macao is, in its essentials, the same as Hong Kong. The Chinese and Por- tuguese governments have agreed to return Macao to China and end Portuguese rule of Macao on December 20th 1999. As with Hong Kong, the Chinese authorities appointed their officials and supporters to draw up the Basic Law for Macao to ensure its strict control.

The aim of the people of Macao should be to struggle for democratic self rule. In reality, this means struggling to constitute a Macao People's Congress through universal suffrage. This could discuss and adopt a Basic Law for the Macao Special Zone which in tum would be presented to the National People's Congress as a record to guarantee the people of Macao full democratic rights. From today on, the people of Macao must unite to take initiatives, participate in and decide their future. The struggle of the people of Macao must also link up with the

struggles in Hong Kong and mainland, China in order that all Chinese people are reunited through struggle.

(The original text is in Chinese. This is an

edited form of the translation)

Page 28

The SWP and women's

Facts Tony Cliff cannot

handle

The policies and theoretical analysis by the Socialist Workers' Party (SWP) on the issue of women's liberation were discussed in a feature article by Rebecca Fleming in Socialist Outlook No.14. Here VALERIE COULTAS develops the discussion - which will also be open for additional contributions.

I agreed with many of the points made in Rebecca Fleming's article on the SWP and women, but there were some points with which I cannot fully agree.

It's true that the history the SWP presents of marxism and feminism is a selective his- tory - but Rebecca doesn't specify where it is selective. This is an important omission, be-

women's movement- not on whether marxist women should prioritise the needs and demands of working class women within that movement (revolutionary women have al- ways done this).

This point is important for today because Cliff suggests that marxist and socialist women sympathetic to feminism (inside and outside the SWP!) are arguing for a cross class women's movement. This has never been our position. We have always argued for an autonomous women's movement, a movement governed or led by women, based on the needs of the working class as a whole.

Marxist women are not for autonomy in the abstract - that would be separatism: we advocate self-organisation to allow women to organise against their oppression. We argue that the best route to securing women's liberation is through an alliance with the workers' movement, because of the revolu-

cause debates among marxists in the past can help us clarify issues today.

SWP leader Tony Cliff always places the stress on the attitude Clara Zetkin and Alexandra Kollantai took towards the bourgeois women's movement before the victory of the Russian revolution, where marxists advo cated building a com- munist women's move- ment. He refuses to acknowledge that marx- ists (Lenin included) gave

WULKEIS

tionary role of the work-

ing class. We argue that

the self-activity of

women on issues of abor-

tion, sexuality and equal

rights aids the working

class and disorganises the

ruling class. The alliance

with the workers' move-

ment must be based on a

recognition of the

specific oppression of

women in all spheres of

life.

Now to touch on the

issue of *material recognised women's interests'. This debate is a Dn very old one among

marxists, revived in a new

The Comintern specific oppression

any weight in their analysis and tactics to the specific oppression of all women, despite the fact that this oppression takes different forms among different classes. This helps Cliff to leave out of his analysis the more sophisti- cated tactics developed by the Third (Com- munist) International after the defeat of the German revolution in 1919; he makes no reference to the debates on the united front and the women's movement, where Lenin and Zetkin discussed how marxists should try and work with suffrage organisations to pur mas then finht for maman's rinhte

This is where we disagree with Cliff - over how to use the united front to build the

form among modern feminists. It has been debated in nearly all revolutionary organisa- tions that have had an active engagement with feminism. Lise Vogel (Marxism and the Oppression of Women) argues that there has always been a theoretical confusion in the marxist movement over the exact nature of women's oppression. She suggests that a 'dual systems' analysis (i.e. based on systems of patriarchy as well as class society) and ex- planation of women's subordination has often co-existed with an analysis more direct-

ly related to the social relations of production - for example in the accounts given by En- gels and Bebel for the origins of women's

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

FIE AT U RE S

for the origins of women's op- pression.

There has thus been an on- going debate about how far we can talk of a separate system of patriarchy or male power, operating autonmously from class relations. But those mar- xists who defend some kind of dual systems analysis, and therefore stress that working class men have a material in- terest in the oppression of women, have some pretty tricky questions to answer, as Rebecca's article showed us.

If working class men have. a short-term material interest which differs from their long- term interest, which interest is dominant at any one time? What determines what is their dominant interest? In what sense is the term 'material

class interest. What purpose Wayne Edginton

interest' being used? For mar- xists, material interest means

does it serve for marxists to structure their analysis around individual relations in this

Petitioning as women fight for their NHS case, rather than placing in- dividual relations in the context of social relations, structures and power relations in class and capitalist society, as we do in every other case?

While men do have more status and power in society and can oppress women in a myriad of ways surely the marxist answer to this is to urge women to organise collectively to confront that sexism? We also point out that structures, like the patriarchal family, reproduce these social relationships on a daily and generational basis, and working class men have every reason to support a total transformation in these relations. The power that working class men are allowed to exercise over women and children in the family does not in fact allow even men to lead full and free lives sexually, emotionally or materially.

Working class men appear to benefit from exercising sexual domination over women

but domination is not real power. As women

have gained more freedom, they have begun to show - through the divorce statistics - that they can resist aspects of this domination. It is the capitalist class that benefits materially from male domination, not working class men or women, even though men are the agents of domination.

Which class benefits from an analysis that focuses on the conflicts between working class men and women, as opposed to that which unites them? When we argue in trade unions that working class men must support women's abortion righis, and lesbian and gay rights because it is in their interests to do so. do we really mean it? Should we be saying

"This resolution isn't in your short-term inter- ests but...'?

We know that a lot of men will not change until social conditions, and particular- ly the family, are changed, but we argue that the battle for women's liberation must start now and that the most advanced workers will fight on behalf of the specially oppressed.

Traditionally, Lise Vogel points out, the reformist wing of the workers' movement leant towards the 'dual systems' analysis, and the revolutionaries defended the position that women's oppression was rooted in capitalism and class society. Far from the latter position meaning that you refuse to confront issues like rape, pornography, and female sexuality, it means that you confront those issues from a standpoint that analyses gender oppression in the context of class society - which means you support women organising but you refute racist, 'law-and-order', or "lifestylist' solu- tions.

Our experience in the class struggle tells us a lot about the relevance of these debates. When the mining communities went into bat- tle with the Tory goverment, and men no longer had to go down the pits, the politically active miners' wives, backed up by the sup- port groups, were able to challenge the back- ward attitudes of their husbands. Men did begin to perceive their class interest lay with women's liberation.

This was a very exciting experience be- cause some of the miners began to see that what they had seen as their privileges - to spend their leisure time away from their wives and kids, to expect their wives to ser-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

vice them because of shift work - were not as advantageous as shared political and domes- tic involvement turned out to be. However retreats on this front were inevitable as soon as the men went back to work.

Tony Cliff's history of the women's movement is very one-sided. He fails to project a clear record of the debates that took place between radical and socialist feminists over the last two decades in Britain and America. He ignores the positive features of feminism and the gains that women (includ- ing working class women) have made in society, the trade unions, political parties and the far left as a result of self-organisation. His rigorous critique of the women's movement is never applied to the SWP, whose record on women's rights has been inconsistent, oppor- tunist and crude (busloads of SWP men shouting women down at Greenham!) as Rebecca explains.

In replying to Cliff it is correct to take the side of the downtrodden, particularly when the movements he attacks are under seige from the right. But socialist women should not fall into the trap he sets and allow anger at his doctrinaire version of marxism to cloud our understanding of the revolutionary poten- tial of the working class, nor forget that socialist women have waged many a battle with radical feminists about the agenda for the women's movement. I hope Socialist Outlook devotes more space to this debate in future issues because it is a very rich one and touches on many questions of concer to marxists and feminists.

Page 29

← Nicaragua under the Sandinistas · A balance sheet of the women's liberation movement →

Something wrong on this page?