Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

A balance sheet of the women's liberation movement

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · p 32 · 1,174 words

Women

REVIEWS

A balance sheet on the women's

The past is before us; feminism in action since the 1960s by Sheila Rowbotham, published Pandora Press, £15

Reviewed by Judith

Arkwright

'While the future is behind us and prophesy most perilous, the past really is before us, so the charting of experience can bring a sense of direction. The process of a movement in transforming it- self can link past and future without attempting to impose the past upon the future'.

In these words Sheila Row- botham attempts to explain what she had set out to do in her his- tory of the Women's Liberation Movement. With its detailed ref- erence to source material includ- ing leaflets and documents of the time, this is certainly the most comprehensive history of the movement and a must for all feminists.

Every woman who par- ticipated in the movement of the 1970s has her own story to tell, and Rowbotham makes no apologies for the fact that 'how the past is seen depends very much on who is looking'.

Rowbotham is a socialist feminist and the book clearly holds the line against those feminists who, with the advent of the Tory dark ages, began to waver in their commitment to those principles. In particular she takes up Bea Campbell's notion that women have no interest in making alliances with male trade unionists, saying that such argu- ments are: "part of a shift among feminists away from theory based on social relationships within capitalism and towards an emphasis on male workers' responsibility for female subor- dination at work'

She develops this into an ar- gument against theories of patriarchy which underlie this. According to her the use of this word raised more problems than

Page 30

it solved. The word suggests that there are two separate systems divided along male/ female lines, so that "patriarchy' oppresses women and capitalism oppresses male workers.

Apart from this defence of some of the basic precepts of socialist feminism, the book is thought-provoking in the balance sheets it makes of various cam- paigns and ideas in the women's movement.

For Rowbotham the breakthrough made by the modern Women's Liberation Movement (WLM) was the fact that it brought the personal ex- periences of women, especially within the family, into the politi-

women, whether we rather harsh- ly implied that women who were housewives entered 'voluntary slavery', or whether we failed to understand why women go in for things like the Miss World con- test.

This is the wrong way to pose the problem. There may have been a certain overzealousness and sometimes this was a result of political theory, such as politi- cal lesbians considering heterosexual woren less feminist. But such differences were political and not simply based on differences in personal lifestyles.

Where such attitudes were to do with overzealousness or

We fight for the choice and thus hope to unite women's

various personal experiences and feelings in a political

cal arena and thus made them the subject of struggle. This is espe- cially apparent when you com- pare this movement to previous movements of women (for ex- ample the suffragettes). But the anti-capitalist dynamic of the movement that flowed from this was also important. The lack of any bureaucracy or any bour- geois feminist layer meant that having made the personal politi- cal, the women's movement was prepared to go into confrontation with the establishment on a whole spectrum of issues.

However there are some problems in the way in which Rowbotham sees this link be- tween personal and political which lead to mistaken assess- ments. Having established that it is capitalist society that seeks to draw an iron curtain between production and reproduction, per- sonal life and public life, she ar- gues that it is difficult to accomodate the tremendous dif- ferences in individuals personal lives and experiences within one movement. The suggestion is that it was this difficulty which split the movement. She wonders, for instance, whether the women's moment became tyrannical to heterosexual

crudeness of politcal analysis they were not all negative but were part of the energy and radi- cal character of the movement. Only from the standpoint of Thatchers Britain do they seem a little extreme.

For example Rowbotham seems doubtful about the value of the Miss World protests. She argues that that they may have alienated some woren and come across as rather elitist. On the contrary, I would argue that such boldness and confidence was the strength of our movement be- casue of the challenge to the status quo.

These actions were very much the product of a young and optimistic movement and as the movement becomes broader it has to reflect the needs and demands of those within it. The discovery that the personal is political should not divide us as women; the whole point is to find political solutions to per- sonal issues and to unite in taking action.

In that sense there are problems with many aspects of Rowbotham's view of the debate within the National Abortion Campaign (NAC). She argues that women's personal experien-

ces in relation to abortion bore a direct relation to their political stance on it and thai the weak- ness of the campaign was that it did not take account of this. Whilst it may be true that NAC did not spend enough time dis- cussing women's experiences, and it is definitely true that we did not take on board the demands of Black women suffi- ciently (in common with the many other campaigns of the women's movement), it is not true that 'there were many also feminists who simply opposed abortion on principle'.

In fact the reverse is true. Be- cause of NAC's campaigning, abortion became a dividing line between feminists and anti- feminists, and most of the argu-

ments used against abortion were

also anti-feminist. Today, with the development of a broader definition of feminism, some women who call themselves feminist may be anti-abortion, but this is not the dominant trend and has no relevance to the debates in NAC. This is where here is a difference between the personal and the political. Many women may have many doubts about abortion for themselves and many women may decide not to have one. We fight for the choice and thus hope to unite women's various personal ex- periences and feelings in a politi- cal movement.

In relation to childcare, Row- botham is unhappy about the demand of the women's move- ment for free 24 hour childcare. Perhaps for some it does rather conjure up a 'Brave New World' type image, and it is true that sec- tions of the movement did not really understand the needs of mothers because it did not relate to their personal experience. But as a propaganda demand is it to- tally irrelevant? Rowbotham's at- tempts to challenge the relevance of such a demand are actually rather petty. She says 'Did we really imagine under-fives being delivered at ten and collected at six when women came off

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

← SWP and women's liberation · True Blue Murder →

Something wrong on this page?