Second World War did provide a space for resource-rich and rela- tively developed countries like Argentina to build up import-sub- stitution industries and profit from favourable terms of trade. Imperialist industrial exports were disrupted by war, and foodstuffs and other TaW materials were needed desperate- ly. The Argentine ranchers, in- dustrialists and workers could all gain. Quite an advanced health and social security system was es- tablished. Absolute hunger and deprivation, commonplace in the majority of Latin American countries, were much reduced.
Thirdly the resilience of Peronism is its nationalism. Ar- gentina remains a semi-colonial country. Despite its development, the economy is still dependent on, and distorted by, imperialism. The 60 billion dollar foreign debt is the clearest expression of that. So Menem's nationalist rhetoric finds a ready audience. But Peronist nationalism continues to be premised on an alliance of working people with an illusory national bourgeoisie. In the 1950s, new national bourgeois in- terests did develop which had some conflict of interests with foreign companies. This sector of the bourgeoise is much weaker today, and is assimilated into the dominant pro-imperialist ruling class.
Working class identification with the gains of Peronism was seen in 1955 when the masses took to the streets to defend Peron's government against the military coup. Many were killed while Peron negotiated his own safe passage to Spain.
The 14 May vote for Peronism was also very much a vote against Alfonsin's Radical government. In the first years of that govern- ment people were willing to hold back on economic demands be- cause there were democratic freedoms for the first time for nearly ten years and some limited justice against the military was being handed down. However, Alfonsin, pressured by successive military uprisings, soon scaled down his human rights programme, and implemented more and more austerity measures to deal with a growing economic crisis. Government popularity slumped.
Page 8
UPDATE ARGENTINA
At the same time the vote for Menem is not a vote of blind con- fidence or general illusion in his programme. Many people realise that the old state redistribution formula of the 1950's golden age cannot operate if the economy is in such a mess there is nothing to distribute. To achieve redistribu- tion today would require much more radical measures.
Mass looting of supermarkets took place after the vote, and again on a lesser scale last week. Although illusions do exist, and looting does not in itself provide an organised political alternative,
Меет: no delay in ditching
promises
it does reflect a desperation and a lack of hope that the new govern- ment will put bread and meat back on the table.
Menem was careful during the electoral campaign to stick to vague promises about increasing wages, and to adopt a tougher posture on the debt. But he did not call for non-payment, and his basic project is a social pact be- tween industry and workers to produce a 'national' recovery.
His first moves have even surprised seasoned Argentine watchers in their brutal and in- stant break with his campaign rhetoric. Petrol prices have been increased by up to 700 percent. In order to cut the public sector deficit he has increased prices for public services by between 200 and 640 per cent; state spending will be cut. To try and sweeten the pill, unspecified measures will be taken against speculation and tax evasion. Talks are going on
with industrialists to freeze cer- tain prices and a special wage bonus has been proposed.
Menem's choice of cabinet ministers reflect an almost new- look sub-Thatcherite Peronism. Roig, his choice of economy min- ister had a brief of restructuring the huge 'lame-duck' subsidised state sector before his sudden death. His successor has pledged identical policies. The richest woman in Argentina is to become a roving ambassador to go cap in hand to the imperialist powers for economic aid.
A lot depends on how Menem
can use Peronist
control of the
trade unions to
sell his social pact.
Shopfloor militan-
cy is alive and
well in Argentina,
but it will face
sabotage from the
Peronist trade
union bureucrats
and will require a
political expres-
sion if it is not to
run out of steam.
Here Menem has
another advantage,
since the left op-
position is rela-
tively weak.
Historically the / his electoral
Communist Party
squandered its
early promise by its sectarian opposition to the na- tional struggle and to Peronism in the 1940s and 1950s. During the war Stalin ordered Communist parties in the third world to ally with their "democratic" bour- geoises against the fascists and to abandon any anti-colonial strug- gle. Consequently Peronism cap- tured the working class, while the Communists had a base among intellectuals and were barely stronger than the Trotskyist cur- rent.
Argentina has had one of the strongest Trotskyist traditions. In general it was less sectarian to the nationalist movement and to Peronism and was able to build a real working class base, which continues to exist today. In the 1960s one wing became the leadership of the PRT/ERP guerillas, which suffered a ter- rible defeat. The other wing, led by the late Nahuel Moreno - al-
though perhaps over-enthusiastic in its legalistic condemnation of any armed struggle - maintained a strong trade union presence and intervened in elections. Today this wing is called the MAS (Movement for Socialism) and has several thousand members.
In the recent elections the MAS and the CP were on a joint slate called Izquierda Unida (United Left). The MAS had campaigned for this unity for a long period. Internal open elec- tions were held to decide on which tendency should head the joint slates. The CP narrowly won. In the elections the slate as a whole won about half a million votes (or 3.4 per cent) in the par- liamentary elections and about 400,000 votes in the presidential elections (2.5 per cent). This rep- resented an increase of about half a per cent for the parliamentary Slate compared to two years ago. The MAS leader, Luis Zamora, was elected as an MP.
The vote for the left would perhaps have been greater if last January's leftist adventure of at- tacking the Tablada barracks had not taken place. The attack was aimed at provoking a general in- surrection. It came after a succes- sion of military uprisings which were as much negotiations as out and out coup attempts. It was led by the MTP (Everyone for the Fatherland Movement) which came out of a national-liberation rather than a strictly marxist or Communist background. It did not even have the sort of social base enjoyed by the PRT of the 1970s. Most of the guerrillas were killed, along with mostly conscript soldiers. The attack was violently condemned by the Iz- quierda Unida. The MAS, keep- ing with the Morenist tradition, even refused to let its lawyers defend the MTP prisoners. Of course the media portrayed the guerrillas as "PRT" or Trotskyists, and this must have had some im- pact on the electoral campaign.
The May rioting and looting also gave the authorties a chance to repress the left. Even the inter- national press has picked up on the alleged role of Trotskyist groups. 1000 people have been detained, including militants of the MAS and another group Politica Obera (Workers Politics). The latter group has
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989
FEATURES
been particularly singled out as organising the looting. PO is another Trotskyist group with some sort of base, although is on
a different scale to the MAS. It
polemicised against the MAS for alleged concessions to Menem and Peronism and for freezing it out of the Izquierda Unida. The MAS responded by arguing that it made ПО concessions (its newspaper did have extensive coverage against the 'illusions' in Menem) and was keen for PO to l come into the front.
From outside Argentina and without more evidence it is dif- ficult (and silly) to make categoric statements on who is sectarian or who is making con- cessions. However it is clear these left, mainly Trotskyist for- ces already do have a certain base. Given the extent of the crisis and the potential contradic- tions with Menem's project there is plenty of potential for the development of a left alternative.
Here we can only highlight the difficulties:
a building united front work with Peronist workers in the trade unions without making conces- sions to Peronism ;
at linking the economic strug- gles to overall political alterna- tives such as proposals on the debt or the public sector;
I finding ways to take up the question of the military threat of even power itself without falling into adventurism.
Already some military leaders have made noises about keeping things under control or about their future presidential ambitions. The l history of modern Argentina has oscillated between short periods of democracy and general mobilisation for reforms and long periods of military dictatorship drowning such hopes in blood.
Generally in Latin America events (Venezuela) and votes in elections (PT success in Brazil) have indicated a uptum in| popular mobilisation and new openings for the left. However it is all very fragile, and it is the responsibility of socialists in Europe to mobilise solidarity with these new struggles. This means in the first place defending the left wing political prisoners ar- rested under Alfonsin but still being held in Carlos Menem's Argentina.
THI
MILLION
PAY NOI PAY
NU PAYEL U
POLE
STAK DUNTCOLLE JOIN JOIN
THONTGBEN
MILLION
THE
NON
MILLION PAYERS
NON
PAYERS
DON'T COLLECT -
DON'T PAY
Gordon Morgan
Will the Socialist Movement help swell the army of t million non-payers of poll tax?
Building the Socialist Movement
Sheffield