Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Union conference survey

Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · pp 6-9 · 3,965 words

Conference report

Trade unions UNISON France Italy

UPDATE/UNIONS the initiative seized by the unions

pressed home to the full.

At the same time a mass sup- port movement for the dockers has to be mounted on the lines of the support groups in the miners' strike. There are already impor- tant initiatives in this, for ex- ample in East London and in Bristol. The dockers must not stand alone. The great dock strike

of 1889 led to the development of the general unions and the TGWU in particular. We have to ensure that in 1989 the dockers, and all the other sections of the movement entering into struggle, are again victorious.

John Harris/FL

This year's union conferences

Battle lines behind the

headlines

When union conferences meet in the middle of the biggest rash of industrial militancy seen in this country since the 1970s, it's not surprising that media interest focusses on what conference decisions made will mean for that ac- tion and for Labour's newly- improved prospects at the polls.

But on the conference floors and behind the scenes there is much else that it's easy to miss: a constant battle being fought out over broader ideas and strategy, and the character of the political and industrial leadership of the movement.

In this year's round of con- ferences, the skirmishes between camps vying for power are varied - but the underlying stresses are similar and the chosen bat- tleground is common to many.

Boardroom deals and

golden handshakes

Union mergers - some out of financial necessity, some in the name of the members, but all car- ried out in the interests of those at the top - are the name of the new game.

The much-discussed mega merger beiween the National Union of Public Employees (NUPE) and the public sector

Page 4

white collar union NALGO rumbles on. This year's conferen- ces saw the merger plans nudged along, and now the health union COHSE is desperately trying to get in on the talks at the very last minute. Their conference this year agreed to look at feasibility of mergers, clearly looking to the two bigger unions as potential partners. COHSE leaders should prepare for a rough reception.

Behind the scenes at NALGO and NUPE, serious effort has gone into preparations for the harmonisation of rule books, with a "levelling down' of internal democracy likely, to ensure that the power stays where it is - at the top. Trading top positions so that the spoils are shared out in a gentlemanly fashion is another important part of this process.

The NUPE/NALGO merger is a classic case. NALGO's shadowy General Secretary, mystery man John Daly, an- nounced his decision to take early retirement just before the union's conference - and to leave just before the merger target date. He thereby leaves the way clear for a younger, more vital replacement from NALGO's hierarchy, to ward off any effective competi- tion from NUPE's higher-profile challengers. Speculation is rife about Daly's likely successor, and about the size of his golden

handshake.

He won't be the only bureaucrat to benefit handsomely from the streamlining of staffing in the merger process. Large payouts for people at the top are increasingly common in the trade union movement, much to its dis- credit. Self-confessed property millionaire and former ASTMS leader Clive Jenkins hit the head- lines last year when he left the newly merged Manufacturing Science and Finance union MSF with f213,000, leaving the top job safe with Ken Gill, the "tankie' communist former leader of the engineering white collar union TASS. The TASS takeover of the merged union is almost complete: they now have the general secretaryship and three out of four assistant general secretaries.

The movement is currently gripped by merger mania. MSF itself. like the National Union of Mineworkers, is now looking for another potential new partner in the Transport Workers (TGWU). But moves to 'workers' unity' are not always in the workers' best interests - born often of neces- sity, combined with self-protec- tion and self-aggrandisement on the part of top officials and driven by the manoeuvres of high TUC politics.

When such proposals are put

to the members, real politics sometimes invervene: The En- gineering Union (AEU)'s policy- making National Committee delivered its leadership a bloody nose earlier this year when it voted to halt all merger talks with the EETPU, the scab electricians" union. The delegates insisted in- stead that talks should procede only with TUC-affiliated unions.

Given a chance, politics sometimes also make it onto con- ference floors and agendas, giving the members the chance to • engage in the popular conference sport of 'overturning the platform' (or just attempting to). Their scores in this sport are a useful measure of the union's in- ternal democracy, as well as the degree of member's confidence and level of organisation.

This is just as difficult as it sounds - and in some unions al- most impossible.

GMB - Edmonds' 'new

model union'

The newly-merged (or sub- merged) clerical workers' union APEX and general and municipal workers' union GMB met for their first conference in Brighton this summer. Living up to its well-eamed reputation as possibi- ly the most undemocratic or- ganisation in the movement, the overbearing GMB trod all over

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

UPDATE/ UNIONS

not only the smaller and weaker APEX but over its own ranks too.

GMB general secretary John Edmonds has inherited a strong regional and officer- dominated

structure, combined with a unique- ly undemocratic decision-making process. The regional barons' grip extends even to granting (or refusing) permission to members of their delegations to address conference. This year a young woman delegate from the London Region

year's elections: Sawyer is not getting things all his own way.

But of course the most significant plat- form victory at NUPE conference this year was the reversal of its non-nuclear defence policy. The vote repre- sents a victory for Sawyer's own brand of new realism in the union and bodes badly for prospects for the super-union to be created by the merger with NALGO.

NALGO

was almost reduced to

Due to a combina- tears as her local boss

dainto tion of a particularly

subjected her to a

top-heavy but political-

humiliating half-hour avne :

ly weak bureaucracy, public harangue. Her

and a relatively strop- crime? She had dared to

py, organised and con- go to the rostrum to com-

fident membership, the plain about sexism in a

odds are slightly better GMB promotional video

for platform defeats at shown at conference. Her con-

NALGO. This year the mood tribution was well received, even

was to the left, although victories by the overwhelmingly male con-

for the conference floor were ference. But she hadn't asked for

modest - confined basically to his permission to speak.

those issues which would not re-

The GMB's ruling body, the

quire the union to confront the Central Executive Council,

Government or the employers. makes its recommendations on

The ruling National Executive conference motions to its regions

Committee was defeated on its well before conference itself.

proposal to hold only a 'confit- Most other Labour movement ex-

matory ballot' (ie. do what the ecutives wait until eve-of-debate

union officials tell you) for the meetings and deliver their

election of a new General deliberations to delegates on the

Secretary. It was defeated too in conference floor. The GMB

its opposition to affiliation to the method might have a consultative

"Time To Go' campaign on gloss, but it is, of course, a stitch-

Ireland, and on a number of rule up. Under their system, Regional

changes. As a iesult NALGO Secretaries (who under GMB

women's conference will now rules can - and do - dominate the

send motions through to national ruling CEC as elected as well as

conference - a breakthrough in paid officials), use the time to go

bringing women into the heart of back to push through their own

union policy making and a con- recommendations to their mem-

siderable advance on the Labour bers for a rubber-stamp which

Party structures, for example. binds conference delegates. This

Despite only small gains and way, votes on the conference

defeats on some key issues, (in- floor are almost entirely ac-

cluding the conference rejection counted for weeks in advance.

of a proposal to write some Emergency motions put directly

democratic safeguards into the to conference tend to be the only

NUPE/NALGO merger discus- possible spanner in the works of

sions), the NALGO left took this otherwise monolithic

comfort in the size of its opposi- machine.

tion vote. A third of delegates

This year the platform, as

voted for a position of non-com- ever, suffered only a few minor

pliance and non-implementation defeats. The rejection of the

of the law in the poll tax debate.

CEC's recommendation that con-

A quarter of the delegates sup- ference be a non-smoking event,

ported the call for an immediate

predictably trounced by the

GMB leader Edmonds: inherited a uniquely undemocratic structure massed ranks of male middle- aged and smoking delegates, can hardly be acclaimed as a step for- ward for the working class. Two other defeated recommendations, concerning numbers of visitors' tickets issued and the organisa- tion of industrial conferences were, in the scale of things, also of little importance.

But one significant blow was delivered to the GMB bosses, who suffered the humiliation of having to back a conference floor attack on one of their own offi- cials.

Excelling in its ability to bend over backwards until it falls down, the Labour Party NEC has surpassed last year's decision to allow the scab Royal College of Nursing (RCN) a stall at Labour's annual conference (COHSE opposed - NUPE's Tom Sawyer abstained). This time they voted to let the pro- privatisation Water Authorities Association have a stall (a move supported by Tom Sawyer as well as the GMB). But at the June GMB Conference, an emergency motion from the London Region sent the union's NEC rep, Tom Burlinson, back with his tail be- tween his legs to the NEC to overturn its position - which he had previously supported. A spe- cial emergency Central Executive Council meeting called during conference had decided to sup-

port the move rather than face certain defeat.

NUPE

The platform at the notorious- ly officer-led union NUPE was defeated on only one key con- ference debate this year, when conference backed a call for co- ordinated national industrial ac- tion to defend the health service: the report of the year's activities in the health sector was also referred back, in a clear gesture of no-confidence from the mem- bership. The apparatchniks will no doubt comfort themselves that since the resolution calls for joint action with other trade unions it never need be implemented, as they have no intention of building for such solidarity. But the vote nevertheless indicates not only the growing mood of industrial militancy, but, more importantly, a broader dissatisfaction with the leadership's "batten down the hatches' new realism.

This dissatisfaction was demonstrated too, in the results of the ballot for NUPE's Deputy General Secretary. Militant sup- porter Nick Bradley polled around 30,000 votes to Tom Sawyer's 48,000 - leaving Sawyer a surprisingly slim majority and an even slimmer turnout. Just 13.5% of the union's 650,000 members bothered to vote at all. The left on the union's NEC was also reinforced in this

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

Page 5

U PD AT E

ballot for all-out strike action in the local government pay campaign. And in a close vote the NALGO black workers' group proposals for autonomous self-or- ganisation were just lost - whilst con- ference went on overwhelmingly to reject the NEC's preferred option.

TGWU and MSF: last line

of defence?

A divided TGWU leadership leaves more openings for a fair fight between opposing forces on the conference floor. Thus the defence debate confounded the new realists: the union's unilateralist stance was narrowly retained. Though the 1.1m strong IGWU will cast its votes, together with MSF (whose con- ference earlier this year voted, at its leadership's recommendation, to take a unilateralist stance) against back-track- ing on defence, Labour's leaders have done their sums and know they have it in the bag. The implications of the vote, as a blow to Kinnock's grip in the movement, have been talked up out of all proportion.

Everything else in the TGWU con- ference will have given Kinnock a great deal of comfort. Delegates pulled back from demanding that a future Labour Government would reinstate full trade union immunities, and rejected a call for Labour to reinstate and extend nationalisation. 'We will not do oursel- ves any favours by promising much more than we can realistically hope to deliver,' warned TGWU general secretary Ron Todd, stepping back firm- ly into the Labour leader's camp. Con- ference also voted overwhelmingly to

take public money for ballots, and ended the union's opposition to EC membership.

New realism

It would be easy to see the summer of discontent as a slap in the face for the new realists and the end of their ascen- dency. It is certainly a measure of the mood and the members' willingness to

fight - always underestimated and

played down by those who lead them.

But beyond the first stage of getting

the troops out, lies another hurdle.

'What do we do now?'. Until the left

advances a convincing answer to that

question and fights for it consistently in

the trade unions, it will continue to lose

the political battles for leadership, and

we'll witness yet again the waste of a

frustrated militancy, translated only into

meaningless composites and manouvres

rather than channelled into effective ac-

tion.

Page 6

Jane Wells

ITALY:

The left regroups after

Euro-Ele

ctions

The Green vote of 6.2 per cent represented nearly a threefold increase on 1987. They were very divided, be- tween a more 'leftish' Rain- bow slate that included some forces from the right wing of the fragmenting centrist move- ment Democrazia Proletaria (DP - Proletarian Democracy), and the official, more British- style, Green slate.

The hard left wing of DP must have breathed a huge sigh of relief, because they managed to hold on to the same support as in the last Euro-elections - 1.3 per cent and made the quota for one Euro-MP. They were under the most pressure from the Greens since most of their parliamen- tary representatives were sup- porting the Rainbow slate and hoping to profit from a DP dis- aster.

Inside DP, which is a little like a reservoir of the post- 1968 revolutionary experience, there has been a very sharp political crisis for nearly 2 years now. DP's main historic spokesperson, Capanna, along with nearly all their MPs bat one, and most of the other public officeholders, wants to abandon any strategy for change that includes action and conflict outside of bour- geois institutions.

Despite a lot of wooliness about DP's programmatic statements over the last years it has maintained references to marxist notions of the class struggle and the state. The right wing want to abandon

DP as a structure, name and

tradition and build some sort

Every other year it seems there is a government crisis in Italy at the beginning of the summer months. More often than not it is sorted out before the annual holidays, since the politicians are anxious not to share a hot and sticky Rome with the tourists.

This year Socialist Party leader Bettino Craxi made the first break in the five-party coalition ('pentapartito') in the run up to the Euro-Elec- tions. He thought a sharp turn

to attacking Italy's number

one party, the Christian Democrats, would bring in some more votes.

In the event, the Christian Democrats lost around one per cent, polling 32.9 per cent, while the SP vote increased by about half of one per cent.

Craxi lost out: the Christian Democrats have regained the initiative within the coalition, and that wily old stager, former Prime Minister Andreotti, is set to lead the same, reshuffled group of coalition partners.

The modestly good perfor- mance for the CP follows the launch of an increasingly so- cial democratic CP programme under party leader Ochetto at the recent Congress, and more vigorous activity by the party in campaigns against health cuts and mafia corruption (and their Christian Democratic friends). Nevertheless the last CP congress saw the formation for the first time of an opposi- tion current around an alterna-

tive document.

Many militants who do not particularly share rebel leader

Cossutta's nostalgia for the

Russian bureaucracy still

voted for this document, since it did at least maintain some

notion of class and struggle -

concepts almost totally absent

from the majority text.

of new rainbow alliance with the Greens and the Radical party.

The centre and left of the party have a majority for maintaining the DP tradition. Unfortunately precisely be- cause DP has been a bit of a catch-all grouping without very coherent norms it is vul- nerable to this sort of offen- sive. Movementist green-type currents have coexisted with the traditional communist working class strongholds of DP in places like Milan. The relationship between the party and its MPs was rather fluid.

Since the development of this crisis, the only other sig- nificant left group in Italy, the LCR (Revolutionary Com- munist League), Italian section of the Fourth International, decided to involve itself in this political struggle between the right wing and the left majority of DP. When the Capanna grouping went all out on the offensive refusing to support the DP election cam- paign or the referendum cam- paigns sponsored by their own party, the LCR decided to have a discussion about join- ing forces formally with the left inside DP.

Initially the LCR interven- tion went smoothly. A DP na- tional delegate assembly agreed terms for integration which included a proviso for the establishment of a Fourth International association ena- bling ex-LCR militants to maintain organised links with

and propaganda concerning

the International.

However during the Euro-

election campaign the DP Na-

tional Secretariat drew back

from the earlier decision and

postponed the formal integra-

tion until after the elections.

Disputes also arose about

standing well-known com-

rades from the Fourth Interna-

tional like Allain Krivine

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

UPDATE/ARGENTINA

SO o0P

Massive protest against the defeated Aifonsin government: will Menem fare any better?

(France) on DP slates.

The latest development prior to this report has been the formal split of the Capanna grouping at a na- tional assembly of his sup- porters on 8/9 July. Nearly all DP's MPs and public of- fice holders have supported the split. This assembly was called 'From DP to the Greens'. Apart from the Rainbow Greens there was a delegation from the official Greens at the meeting. Capanna wants to unify all the Green forces. This may be easier said than done, since the Greens are very heterogenous politically. Some of the official Greens have put themselves forward as members of the pentapar- lito govemment!

All this has concentrated the minds of the DP leader- ship, and it has now voted definitively in favour of the integration of the LCR, broadly in line with the ear- lier agreement. The LCR will hold a dissolution con- ference at the end of July.

Hopefully DP, despite the loss of nearly all its public officeholders, will emerge strengthened after the integration of the LCR in its fight to stop the drift to 'new realism' or vague green politics in Italy.

There is plenty of space for the activity of a party like DP. A new, revitalised DP would have to work out a correct strategy for linking up with the thousands of CP activists dissatisfied with the Ochetto turn. The struggle against the government's austerity measures, par- ticularly in the public sector goes on. The decree impos- ing charges for hospital care was renewed recently, again without debate in parlia- ment. It still has to eventual- ly be taken in full debate and voted on, so as much pressure as possible is necessary to ditch the decree. Already there has been a half-day general strike over this and the potential for further action is there.

Argentina:

Can Menem revive the old

Peronist

Dave Kellaway

A country which is one of the bread baskets of the world and a major meat exporter - but which has seen mass looting for basic foodstuffs.

A country self-sufficient in energy and water, but which can- not maintain continuous supplies.

A country with immense natural riches, overwhelmingly urban and largely industrialised, in which a third of its 32 million population live below the official poverty line. Here you car no longer use credit cards because in- flation is running at 120 per cent a month. Here the currency was devalued to 650 australs against the dollar in early July, though just a few days earlier it had been 300 against the dollar. The interest alone on the foreign debt is equal to 60 per cent of the value of its ex- ports and the public sector deficit is equal to 15 per cent of GNP.

This country is Argentina. Reality here belies all the superfi- cial analyses that capitalist and im- perialist contradictions no longer operate. Neither can it be dismissed as a peripheral undeveloped colonial country having little effect in the imperialist chain. Along with Brazil and Mexico it is one of the most industrialised semi-colonial countries.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

magic?

British capital has both an his- toric and a contemporary respon- sibility for the devastation of the economy and the sufferings of the people.

The political and social situa- tion is highly unstable. In the last six months there has been:

•l a failed military uprising;

• a suicidal attack by left-wing guerrillas on a military base;

• the subsequent establishment of a National Security Council headed by the military;

• waves of strikes particularly in the bankrupt public sector;

• a massive 50 per cent-plus vote against the goverment in favour of a populist candidate from the party founded by former Presi- dent General Peron, now promising better times for working people;

# mass looting of shops in all cities on two occasions, with dozens shot by police.

In the country with 'two Presi- dents but no government', Carlos Menem, the Peronist leader, took over the Presidency from Raul Al- fonsin five months earlier than al- lowed for by the constitution. The Argentine ruling class are desperately hoping that a revamped Peronism can hold the lid down on an explosive situation.

Why did the people turn so massively back to the Peronists? In

the savage decade of the military dictatorship which ended only five years ago, the Peronist bureaucracy openly collaborated with the policy of torture, and death squads which left 15,000 'disappeared". Indeed the last Peronist government, led by Peron's second wife Isabel, was already massacring left-wing op- position before the military took over in 1976.

Perhaps the easiest way to un- derstand Peronist populism in general terms is to think of Labourism in Britain. Populism ob- viously is not the same as social democracy but successful varieties do share some features.

First, it has organic roots in the day to day organisation of the working class. Peronism is politi- cally dominant in the trade union movement. Despite the often "gangster' methods of the union bureaucrats, it co-exists with strong traditions of rank and file shop steward organisation.

Second, it is forever associated in the collective memory of the working class with the golden age' of General Peron's redistribu- tive wage and welfare policies be- tween 1944-1955- somewhat similar to the way Labour Party militants look back to the Attlee government of 1945. International conditions during and after the

Page 7

← Here's the industrial upsurge! · Argentina: Menem's crisis →

Something wrong on this page?