Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Hillsborough: a working class tragedy waiting to happen

· Socialist Outlook no. 15, May 1989 · p 32 · 1,224 words

Racism and anti-fascism

FEATURECOMMENT

The emotional reaction to the

who can be used to justify the most

events at Hillsborough

extreme attacks on civil liberties. 'If

they behave like animals, they stadium on April 15 has

should be treated like animals." The spread beyond Merseyside

bracketing together of all working and the football world to the

class football fans as 'hooligans" whole of British society.

who need to be locked up in cages

However shocking and painful g

was directly responsible for the the images on television and in the

deaths of the 95 Liverpool sup- press have been, the disaster at porters.

Hillsborough will have come as no

The Labour leadership shares surprise to many football sup-

with the government the view that porters. The immediate causes of the

football's problems can be reduced tragedy - inadequate and incom-

petent policing, fans being crammed 2

to 'football hooliganism'. Roy Hat-

tersley provided a graphic illustra- into cages like animals, huge delays

tion of this bipartisan approach getting into the ground and bad planning and

them to travel to away matches. In recent

when he atated in a recent "Newsnight" inter- conmunication by the foorball club are years, however, there has been an explosion of view that if he and Douglas Hurd were to be problems which fans encounter week in, week elf-organised unofficial supporters clubs and

locked in a room overight they would emerge nut at every major league ground in the fanzines - known collectively as the "Altera- with an 'acceptable" ID card scheme in the

country. Hillsborough was a working class tive Football Network'. An independent na-

tional organisation for fans -- the Football Sup morning. tragedy waiting to happen.

The tendency of some on the left to treat

Socialists need to lonk into the underlying porters Association (PSA) has been growing football supporters as an irrelevance. or worse.

causes of the disaster and to propose ways in steadily and now counts its membership in the as irredeemably reactionary, is simply allow-

which the working crass, through its own ac thousands.

ing the Tories, and their allies in the Labour

The existence of football an a mass spec- tivity and organisation, can provide solutions.

On one level, Hillstrugh was typical of tator sport and the self-organisation of football leadership, to quite literally "get away with

the tenth vear of Thatchensm. In common with fans should be supported wholeheartedly by murder: the murder of football as a mass spec

all socialists. In some cases. football provides tator sport. and of football tans in future

Piper Alpha, the Herald of Free Enterprise,

tragedies such as Hillsborough. Kings Cross and the Clapham train crash, the the only collective experience which young

Instead of ignoring these issues we should disaster was . sympou of m. intellereo working class people have available to them. be developing a nolitical programme for the

operation of market forces. The frantic search

The collectivity of the terraces and of sup-

porters organisations represents a gain for the transmaton of footbal ato what it has al:

for short term profit - whetherit warby British

Rail, Pan Am, owners - meant

herne warDy Betssh

w fonthan

owners - means a further decline in already in- adequate health and safety provisions. This

une in alreadyin

is ninisian.

combined with cuts in the emergency services

and the general deterioration in the infrastruc

ture necessary for a healthy and safe environ-

and the general deterioration in the infrastruc ture necessary for a healthy and safe environ- ment, means that the loss of life from accidents' and other environmental causes has increased significantly in the lifetime of

new sport. Most of our larger clubs were founded in the early years of this century, and the English Foothall League itself hasoniy just celebrated its centenary. Huge crowds at foot- ball matches only became common in the 1920%. From then to the present day, football crowds have been almost entirely working class in composition. Working class fnothall fans formed their own supporters cluhs carly in the devejopment of the League. Thene sup- porters clubs organised travel, social and spotting events, fundraising and, in some

wald the genera ure necessar

ment, means that the loss of life from

accidents' and other environmental causes Football in its present for is a relatively

aches 00 the Tory governmeat.

Iscr Lite "retime

cases, elected representation to the boards of

their football clubs.

Over the years, most official supporters

clubs have been transformed into uppendages

of the footbal clubs themselves, and have lost

any accountability to or mass involvement by

the funs. In many cases, they are just a means

for fans to obtain membership cards to enable

Page 30

working class as a whole.

Predictably, as with all working class social

formations under capitalism, football crowds

are contradictory phenomena. Forus of ruling class ideology - sexism, racism and nationalism - are deeply rooted in the mass of football supporters (most of whom are white and male). Consequently, fascist groups have had some limited success at recruiting on the

terraces, although fascist influence (with a few

notable exceptions) has declined recently.

The ruling class, in the shape of the

Thatcher govemment, encourages extreme

nationalist sentiment among football fans, and

is at least benevolently silent on racism and

*30Ic

sexism. Their views on the collective ex-

perience and organisation of so many working

wever are another mas

The proposed introduction of compulsory

ID cards is precisely an attempt to exert social

control over (much smaller) football crowds.

The ruling class regards the loss of more lives in crushes outside and inside grounds as an ac- ceptable price to pay. The knee-jerk reaction

of Douglas Hund and Colin Moynihan to the Hillsborough disaster was to propose all-

seated football grounds - thus trying to destroy

much of the collective emotion and spirit to be enjoyed on the terraces.

Football supporters aim provide a useful scapegoat for the Tories - an 'enemy within"

ways had the potential to become - the

"People's Game'. Some of the elements eif

such a programme are already being developed inside the foothall supporters

"hall sunnorters

developed inside the foothall supporters

movement. Arguments against racism and sexism are common in football fanzines. They also raise demands such as supporters' repre sentation on boards, better facilities, opposi- tion to any fom of ID card scheme, and so on. The PSA has begun to exert some real in-

w exert some Ical in-

fluence on the football authoritics on some of

these questions. Socialists need to have an

input into these debates where it mattes - in

grounds..

fluence on the football authoritics on some of

• debater

the supporters" organisations themselves, as well as raising them in the Labour Party and trade unions. We should be arguing for supportens" conimi of football clubs, women- only sections in every stadium, nationalisation (or municipalisation) of football grounds, opening the facilities of clubs to local com- munity use, matches to be stewarded by sup- porters themseives - police out of football

1 am sure that the list can be added to. The important point is that socialists cannot con- tinue to abstain on the important questions that are raised by football supporters themscives.

Glenn Sutherland The Fontball Supporters Association can be con-

tacted at 59 Oakwood Road, Liverpool 1.26 ID

(membership £2)

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989

← The opium of the people? · Organising miners in 1920s West Virginia →

Something wrong on this page?