BACK LORA S S
In El Salvador, the murder of Archbishop Romero formed a focus for the developing struggle against the regime. in El Salvador, the murder of Archbishop Romero formed a focus for the developing struc
Marxism and religion
Witn the Saiman Rusndie affair still in the news, this of religion. Should we still see organised religion conservatism and obscurantism as Marx and Engels we couple that with defence of freedom of worship?
month's Back to Basics looks the Marxist view of any description as a buwark of reaction, did n the nineteenth century? If so so how do
Religion historically has been one of the most powerful means at the disposal of the ruling class for the maintenance of inequality, exploitation and slavish obedience on the part of sections of the working class.
The struggle with religion has two sides which must be distinguished. On the one hand we have the struggle with the church as a spe- cial organisation, existing for religious propaganda, materially interested in the main- tenance of popular ignorance and religious enslavement. On the other hand, we have the struggle with the widely diffused and deeply in- grained prejudices of the majority of the work- ing class and other sections of society.
The union between Church and state goes back centuries. The association between the church and the feudalist state of landowners, for example, was very intimate: the autocratic state was mustained by the landed interest. The Church itself was a major landlord, owning mil- lions of acres. These two powers were inevitab- ly compelled to join forces against the labour- ing masses.
During the period in which the urhan bour- geoisie was in conflict with the feudal nobility. the bourgeoisie fiercely attacked the Church.
Page 28
S I eS
since it owned territories which the bourgeoise wanted for itself.
It is this conflict that explains why the demand for the separation of Church and state was made by the liberal bourgeoisie. However, it was never fully realised. Everywhere U- struggle of the working class against the capitalists was growing more intense, and the bourgeoisic saw no reason to break up the al- liance of the Church and state. They thought it would be more advantageous to come to terms with the Church, that is, as Bukharin and Preobazhensky termed it. to "buy its prayers on behalf of the struggle with socialism?
The work which the bourgeoisie in its strug gle with the Church had left unfinished was car- ried to a conclusion by the proletarian revolu-
tion in Russia in 1917. One of the first decrees of the Soviet state was that concerning the separation of Church and state. All its landed estates were taken away from the Church and handed over to the masses. All the Church's capital became the property of the working class. The Soviet state rejected all thoughts of using the Church in any way whatever as a means for strengthening the proletarian state.
However, its one thing to carry through the separation of Church and state. It is much more difficult to combat the religious prejudices al- ready deeply rooted in the consciousness of the masses. Religious propaganda finds its most fertile soil where social institutions do not allow people to understand the real nature of society.
In capitalist society production and the ex change of goods are not carried nut with full conscioumess and in a planned way, they hap- pen as though they were the result of clemen- tal forces. The market controls the producer. Workers excluded from decision making in production do not know if too many or too few goods are being produced, why prices rise af one time and fall at another, why crises and un employment occur. So, having little control over such important events in their lives, work- ing people can casily accept the notion of "the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989
will of God' as an explana tion. Religion also teaches them their station in life.
In organised, communist society, on the other hand, production and distribution no longer hold any mysteries for the working class. The working class collectively and individually participates in claborating a general plan of production and will have ideas and proposals on the matter. The transition from socialism to communism. from the society which marks the end of capitalism to the society completely freed from all traces of class division will bring about the natural death of all religion and all superstition.
In reality, of course we would would make a big mistake if we thought we could sit back and watch the end of religion. In the Soviet Union, after 1917, the Church became central to the political struggle against the dictatorship of the proletariat. The Bolsheviks made a point of continuing the struggle against religious propaganda. Their methods were varied and made use of debates and the publication of literature. They also
The Iranian revolution: religion used by Khomeini placed a big emphasis an to smash class mobilisation. out scientific knowledge to undermine the anthenticity of religion. They opened up the shrines to exposc the "incorruptible relics, to show up the trick- ery on which religion was grounded.
However, in marked contrast to later, cruder, Stalinist efforts, the watchword of the Bol- sheviks was sensitivity. To thrust atheism on the masses, to interfere with religious practices and to mock the objectsof popular helief would not assist but hinder the campaign against religion. If the Church was perseculed it could win sympathy amongst the masses. Persecution would remind them of the days when there was a link between religion and the defence of na- tional freedom; it would strengthen the anti- semitic movement and in general it would mobilise all the remains of an ideology which was already beginning to die out.
The well-known phrase 'religion is the opium of the people is generally reckoned to he at the heart of the Marxist concept of religion. However a closer lonk at the issue would reveal Marx's understanding of the dual character of religion.
"Religious distress is at the same time the ex- pression of real distress and the protest against real distress. Religion is the sign of the op pressed creature, the heart of a heartless world just as it is the spirit of an unspiritual situation.
It is the opium of the people. (Toward the Criti- que of Hegel's Philosophy of Right, 1844).
Marx wrote the above passage when he was still
a follower of Feuerbach, a neo-Hegelian. His analysis is therefore without any class reference. But it none the less grasped the con- tradictory character of the religious phenomenon; sometimes a legitimation of cx- isting sociely and sometimes a protest against it.
Engels for his part, tried to explain concrete social expressions of religions. Christianity no Innger appeared as a timeless essonce but as a cultural form undergoing changes in different historical periods, first as a religiom of the slaves, then as the ideology of the Roman Em- pire, then tailored to feudal hierarchy and last- ly adapted to bourgeois society.
Engels, though, realised that the conflict be- ween materialism and religion is not always
identical with the struggle between revolution and reaction. Forexample in Britain, eighteenth century materialism defended absolute monar- chy, while protestant sects used religion in their struggle against the Stuarts. While remaining an atheist, a materialist and an enemy of religion, Engels, like Marx, understood the dual character of religious belief; defending social order on the ane hand and protesting against it on the other.
Later on Lenin insisted in Socialism and religion that atheism should not be part of the Party's programme because 'unity in the really
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 15 May 1989
revolutionary struggle of the oppressed class for creation of a paradise on carth is more important to us than unity of proletarian opinion on paradise in heaven". Thin never meant that Marxists should not wage a struggle against religion but that atheism was not a condition for party membership.
Rosa Luxembourg shared this opinion, but developed a different and looser ap- proach. Although an atheist herself, she attacked, not so much religion, more the reactionary policy of the Church. In an essay written in 1905, called Church and socialism she claimed that modem socialists were more faithful to the original prin- cipler of Christianity than the conservative clergy of today. Since socialists strug gle for a social order of frecdom andequality, priests should welcome it. When the clergy support the rich who explain and oppress the poor they are in open contradic tion to Christian teachings. Luxembourg, predating fot example Tony Bean and Eric Heffer tried to rescue what she saw as the social dimen-
sion of the Christian tradi- tion for the labour move- ment, rather than undertake a I battle in the name of materialism.
Amongst the more recent leaders and thinkers of the communist movement Gramsci showed the greatest interest in religious issues. His ironic criticism of the conservative forms of religion expecially jesuitical catholicism did not prevent him from seeing the Utopian dimension of religious ideas. Religion is the most gigantic Utopia that history has ever known. It affins... that man is... equal to other men. hut it also affims this is not of this world hut of another (the Utopia).
He also pointed out "that every religion...is really a multiplicity of different and other con- tradictory religions, There is a catechism for the peasants, a catechism for the petty bourgeoise and urban workers and a calechisen for workers and for intellectuals."
In general Marx and Engels felt that the sub- ersive role of religion was a thing of the past
without any significance in the era of the
strugen This was true for a period but today new questions are posed in this
field. The methods of Marxism still apply and
will aid our understanding whether of libera-
tion theology or the growth of Islamic fun-
damentalism or the relationship between the
Catholic Church and Solidamosc in Poland.
Ann Potter and Graham Topley
Witnes
Page 29