Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Organising miners in 1920s West Virginia

· Socialist Outlook no. 15, May 1989 · p 33 · 471 words

transforms J Edgar Hoover's Matewan

vicious FBI into pro-civil rights Film, directed by John

activists, Matewan sticks close Sayles

to the facts. And Matewan does

not have the tidy resolved

ending of Norma Rae, where

the union clection scems to

guarantee victory. The textile

workers at JP Stevens found in

reality that the election was

only the beginning of the story.

Matewan portrays the subtle

manipulation of relations

between the different groups

brought into the strike by the

mine owner. Whites against

Italian immigrants against

blacks brought up from the

souther states, each group.

with difliculty, sees through

prejudice, to acknowledge

common interest. And, just as

they we coming together, new

divisions are effectively

exploited.

Issues of loyalty arise, with

one unionist's betrayal and the

falsified charge of rape against

Joe Kenehan. The

contemporary case of the

socialist activist Mark Curtis in

the american mid-west mirrors

the false charges against Joe

Kenchan.

The church sides against the

miners and the disillusionment

with this betrayal is shown by

Reviewed by Bradley Judd

MATEWAN FOLLOWS union organiser Joe Keneban into the isolated dells of the West Virginian coal region. But, Joe is not alone. The mine owner of the Stone Mountain Coal Company has hired the most ruthless and feared strike-breakers available in the 1920s.

Matewan vividly brings to the screen the struggles that transpired to unionise in this century, showing the extent to which the bosses must go to keep control. The strike-breakers do not hesitate to use any methods, including murder, to stop the union.

Like Mississippi Burning und Norma Rae, Matewan has the feel of a documentary drama, but it more successfully

ortrays historical fact. Unlike

Mississippi Burning, which

Hidden

Rain Man Film, directed by Barry Levinson, starring Dustin Hoffman and Tom Cruise

Reviewed by JOHN LISTER

IF, LIKE ME, you dread teamest" films overladen with sound moral intent and obsessive desire to focus on 'awkward' topics, you still need have no fears in going to see Rain Man, despite the fact that its main character, an Oscar-winning role for Dustin Hoffman, suffers from the personality disorder known as autism.

However Rain Man is not simply about a particular fomm of mental/psychological handicap: it is about character. Hoffman plays Raymond Babbit, the autistic older brother of car importer Charlie Babbit

Hoffman as Raymond. (Tom Cruise). Raymond has been confined for most of his life to a mental institution - a fact known only to his father, and not to Charlie until his father dies.

Yet while Raymond is the one with a diagnosed condition that makes him unable to form normal human relationships, "nomial" Charlie is the one at the start of the film who is

completely wrapped up in himself and uncommunicative, not least with his girlfriend Susanna (Valeria Golino).

An the story unfolds, Raymond revcals his hitherto hidden

← Hillsborough: a working class tragedy waiting to happen · Hidden Gifts →

Something wrong on this page?