politics that parties never win elections,
but governments lose them.
That may be so. And given Labour's pathetic performance, even the terminal optimists in the movement are having to admit that Labour's best hope now is probably a Tory dis aster.
It's all too tempting then to prociaim every hiccup in the government's perfor- mance as heralding a shift in Labour's fortunes. If only it were that casy. But Thatcher's problems are certainly mounting up.
The list of unpopular measures, dis asters and scandals is looking as long as an NHS waiting list. But unpopularity and policy problems have come and gone over the last ten years. And frighteningly little lasting damage has been done to Tory standing, as they've steered their counse, with only minor g changes of tack, into a third term.
But now the goverment is beginning to look as though it might be sailing a bit too close to the wind. The North Sea oil revenues and sell-off receipts which
have kept them in credit are woose to run l
ning out. And the latest on the list of privatisations don't look such a good deal to potential shareholders who are all
Tha also customers faced with bigger bills. But perhaps most importantly. Thatcherism" is coming close to hitting those it relies on for its support; the middle class and those sections of the working class who have felt some gains from the last ten years.
Water and electricity privatisations are ring ing environmental alarm bells. In the case of water, these are being heard loudest in the Tory heartlands, across rural Britain and into the neat county towns. So much so that at the recent by- clection in Richmond, the young Tory hopeful saw his predecessor Leon Brittan's majority cut from over 19.000 to just 2,500.
Rising house prices and mortgage interest rate rises are hegining to hit home. Record levels of homelesness are not just a minor em- barrassment to some Tory bleeding hearts, but an ever-growing financial burden to central goverment and source of frustration to the govemment's friends in the building trade. Working class opposition to the government's plans for public sector housing is gathering force too, as estate hallots reject Tory sell-offs. Effective campaigning - particularly in London's Tower Hamlets - against Nicholas Ridley's other great housing initiative, "Hous ing Action Trusts', has recently resulted in the scrapping of half of the proposed projects.
Transport has recently and dramatically risen to the fore of punti wann. Almost every aspect of policy here presents difficulties for the government. A weaker government might have been brought down by the series of safety scan- dals, injury and even death attributable to their politicians and policies. Only now, on the ropes over Lockerbie after more than three months,
There is a 'common sense' saying in
Transport Secretary Paul Channon is looking vulnerable.
Less immediately dramatic or newsworthy.
but increasingly recognised as central to
transport safety, are the planning problems
facing the govemment. Uncomfortably for the
Thatcher: outliving her usefuiness?
ut
nation's policy makers, these are again being felt first on their own home base. London com- muters driving to work now travel more slow- ly and a lot less pleasantly around the capital than they would have done before the advent of the motor car - at around 11 m.p.h. Under- ground passengers have been driven to direct action - with impromptu sit-ins and lobbies when yet more rush-hour trains are delayed or cancelled. And perhaps most sensitive of all, the government faces a serious challenge from its own 'natural" supporters in Kent where opposi- tion to Channel Tunnel plans cannot be ignored. Faced with marauding middle class masses taking to the streets, even govemment ministers who are unfortunate enough to represent con- stituencies in this danger zone have had to dis lance themselves from the proposed "development'. Cheating-by making sure that the track goes underground in Tory areas and only surfaces in nasty inner city Labour stron- gholds - might just work for the govemment. But they have had to back-track-by going for the marginally more environmentally accept- able but significantly more expensive option. And pious monetarist homilies - that all this is really a sign of prosperity and we jolly well ought to be grateful — are starting to grate, even with many Tory supporters, whose fint instinct is not idenlogy, but self-interest.
Proposals to 'reform' the NHS are in trouhle too, as some professional groups are now join ing NHS workers in opposition to the government's plans. The public's basic suppor of a tax-funded, free health scrvice remains
SOCIALIST OUTLOOh no 14 Anni
solid, and though patchily, effective broad op- position to the Tories, is growing.
Industry, if not the City, is increasingly un- comfortable with the government's economic performance. The director general of the CBI made a post-budget public attack on Thatcher,
complaining that she was complacently
presiding over the "locust years" - uf ex-
cessive consumption and under invest-
ment. "I must wam you that the locusts
will not easily be kept at bay. Last year
the CBI said that the priority should be
investment not consumption. This was
regarded at the time as politically naive
and self interested. Unfortunately it
tumed out to be right."
Clearly the goverment is in some
difficulty but is it possible that all this
amounts to is just a temporary rocky
patch for the government? They have a
packed programme of legislation, much
of it contentions and onpopular. But this
is partly by design: when better to deal
with difficult business, but in the middle
of a term of office when an administra-
tion might naturally be expected to be
low in the polls? Especially when they
have a stash of money put by for tax cuts
later on.
And the rest? Can it be put down just
to bad luck (Pamella now included) in
the number of unpredictable controver-
sies that have emerged rocently?
Well no, not really. Because many of them are more than mere scandals, but are at- tributable, and increasingly are attributed publicly, to the direct consequencies of pursu- ing Thatcherite policies.
So it could just be that Thatcherism (al- though, importantly, not conservatism as such), is outliving its usefulness to the British ruling class.
Sections of the media now are at last waking up to the fact that Thatcherism'snot all they've cracked it up to be.
A Sunday Telegraph columnist recently speculated that the Prime Minister needed a holiday. Peter McKay, writing in the right-wing London Evening Standard under the headline "It's that woman again" concluded that the government is running out of steam - and anyway, he argued, it has already gone too far. Most importantly, he speculated, she might ac- tually be starting to put voters off.
That, of course, is the Tories" bottom line. If 1 were a goverment minister who'd given up a place on the City payroil for what looked like a joh for life I'd be getting more than twitchy. 1 might even be getting out.
The challenge, as always, is for Labour's leaders to apply the political commitment and drive nocessary to shape and advance the grow- ing tide of opposition in the working class. The present performance of Her Majesty's official opposition makes it less rather than more like. ly that they will do that.
Jane Wells
Pade 7